I personally like the ball hammer. No frilly decorations, just a big sphere of meanness, equipped well if it's Victos Maul. I have a warrior on my second account who uses one, but I don't play him much anymore since I only bought 1 factions acount.
I think that the Plagueborn Maul is the coolest one.
I agree. I personally like all of the Plagueborn weapons at this point over the normal counterparts.
The thing though about the collosal pick is that it does piercing damage. If I am not mistaken there are armors with +armor vs piercing yet none with +armor vs blunt/slashing.
Its so simplistic yet exotic at the same time (exotic being ice... and simple being a tiny rod and the cylinder of ice at the end, nothing really fancy)
In second place..... gavel of the nephilim!
then afterwards probably marble hammer and stone crusher