Should we pay for GW?

fezz47

Academy Page

Join Date: Jun 2005

The most disappointing thing about GW is not the game itself. I have finished most of the PvE campaign with the exception of UW and FOW, and recently tried some PvP, both in the 4 X 4 random arenas and the team arenas. While I find the economy in the game and trading system lacking, the game itself is great. It’s the community that sucks IMO.

I thought is was bad in the PvE part of the game with the whiners, rudeness, and people insisting of getting the “perfect group“ for a mission. God, you spend more time finding a group than playing. But PvP is even worse. It really is unbelievable. When you first start PvP, you’re pretty much a newb all over again, and subject to the usual bullshit with the “ Stupid noob!” freakin faggot! Etc etc. And that I can put up with, but the thing that annoys me the most are that people are just such big babies and take the game WAY to seriously! This game is supposed to be played for fun. Not like your life depended on it.

I’m new to this genre, with the exception of Asherons Call 2 which I played for a couple of months prior to GW. While that game had it’s share of problems, (and in the process of being shut down), it had a very supportive close knit community. Most of the people playing that game were friendly intelligent gamers and played the game to enjoy it. People actually went out of their way to help out a new player.

In GW, if you have a question on gameplay, don’t bother asking anyone in-game, as you’re most likely to get either no response at all or “STFU noob!” You have to rely on guild mates or the forums to get any info. Thank God for this forum. At least people here will take the time to answer questions. Other than this and a couple other GW forums, it’s the only place I’ve found intelligent people, which is pretty sad.

As bad as I feel to say this, I for one would rather pay a monthly fee, and weed out a lot of the idiots playing now.

ttujc

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Aug 2005

Council of Exiles [CX]

Mo/

paying will not keep out the idiots...

Dakota Collins

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Sep 2005

Cold Fusion

Mo/E

/signed.

agreed.

Akimb0

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jul 2005

Rt/N

you've n00bed yourself...deal with it. GW isnt good enough to be worth paying for.

Veripare

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2005

Canada, Ontario

This will get locked seeing as this has been discussed over and over and over again, only to end up in flames and people crying T_T

Maika Boila Radovu

Maika Boila Radovu

Academy Page

Join Date: May 2005

White Rock, BC

Starfleet Intelligence Guild

R/Mo

Weird I like the game and havent found any real mean people. Most are willing to help answer questions, give new players some start up gold/items, run ppl to different locations. I really havent noticed any of the problems you have.

mortalis doleo

mortalis doleo

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Sep 2005

my house

The Cutting Edge [TCE]

N/

i think it depends on the kind of server (american/european/korean), and i wont say anymore

Shwitz

Shwitz

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

East Coast, USA

Not a Guild [NaG]

R/

I agree that the greater portion of the general GW community consists of childish l33t speakers, but a pay-per-month fee is not the answer. There really is no way from keeping that kind of people from playing the game. Furthermore, its not in ArenaNet's best interest to discourage certain people from buying the game. A gamer who doesn't want to deal with the general GW community just has to play with people he/she knows, form a guild with people he/she likes, and when all else fails, take matters into his or her own hands and form pick-up groups selectively with a few PC's and henchmen. As for PvP, turn off community chat in arena districts and game with guildies...

Tactical-Dillusions

Tactical-Dillusions

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

Grimsby, UK

R/

Children (and indeed immature adults) exist in all online games...it's a sad fact. Best we can do is try to ignore them.
Failing that, you can report anyone who you know are in breach of their End User License Agreement. Guild Wars support don't expect anyone to take the shite that people spew out into the game.

You have a right as a player to enjoy your gaming experience. Don't let them drag you down the pan.

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

agreed. Its the people. In beta it ROCKED. Now it is just above average...

fezz47

Academy Page

Join Date: Jun 2005

I"m not talking about so much about mean people, I'm talking about people that show no respect for other players. I could care less if someone is "mean" to me.

As an example, in the random arena, you start out with 4 people and do a PvP "mission". The problem is, if you start the mission and one of your teamates dies, half the time, at least one of the remaining people on your team will just "drop out" of the game thinking they can't win, so why bother? This leaves you and whatever teamates still there at a huge disadvantage.

I'll always keep playing even if I'm the only member still in the match. It's good experience and you learn as much, if not more by losing, than by winning a lot of the time. Then you get the blame game. Someone dies. "REZ ME!". Now, if no one does.
"WTF? Freakin noob! Idiot!"

It's like a 3 yr old being denied their bottle of moo moo. Wah wah!

As far as helping out newer players, I have done that myself. A couple of weeks ago, I went to Ascalon and started giving away some fur squares, and other assorted items to people just to be a nice guy. And I swear, approx. half of the people I "gave" stuff to didn't even bother to thank me. So long sucker lol.

I don't know. Guess I'm just burned out on the game. I don't mean to sound negative about the game in gen, cause I've certainly gotten my moneys worth and more, and have a lot of fun chatting w/guildies. Just wish some of these people would grow up a bit and have a little more fun with the game.

Charcoal Ann

Charcoal Ann

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2005

In a World of BADGERS!

Eternal Flame Brotherhood

no monthly fee! don't give ANet ideas.... *looks hurredly around room and tries to hide thread*

Phrozenflame

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Aug 2005

I dunno, I've had v. little bad experience, I just ask something, ppl either reply to me there or wisper me the reply..so I dont find it bad...and if someone is in need, even I reply to them and tell them what they needed to know.

If you help someone, that person will take it as an impression from you and will others..thats the way to make community btr.

Nick Hexon

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Sep 2005

311

W/E

I bought the game to play a MMORPG for free. If i wanted to pay for a game monthly I would have bought World of Warcraft.

melbo

melbo

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Aug 2005

New York

E/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Hexon
I bought the game to play a MMORPG for free. If i wanted to pay for a game monthly I would have bought World of Warcraft.
Ditto, I've seen the same kind of stuff going on in WoW when my friend was playing...a monthly fee isn't going to change anything except make those of us NOT willing to pay to play drop out of the game.

You don't like the immature people? Turn off local/trade chats. Or go on during the day or late at night when the kiddies are asleep. I see a huge difference in the crowd since I sign on around 9 PM...when i sign on earlier it can get really immature.

OverlordTyrael

OverlordTyrael

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jun 2005

#amplitudestudios

Xen of Onslaught [XoO]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by fezz47
The most disappointing thing about GW is not the game itself. I have finished most of the PvE campaign with the exception of UW and FOW, and recently tried some PvP, both in the 4 X 4 random arenas and the team arenas. While I find the economy in the game and trading system lacking, the game itself is great. It’s the community that sucks IMO.

I thought is was bad in the PvE part of the game with the whiners, rudeness, and people insisting of getting the “perfect group“ for a mission. God, you spend more time finding a group than playing. But PvP is even worse. It really is unbelievable. When you first start PvP, you’re pretty much a newb all over again, and subject to the usual bullshit with the “ Stupid noob!” freakin faggot! Etc etc. And that I can put up with, but the thing that annoys me the most are that people are just such big babies and take the game WAY to seriously! This game is supposed to be played for fun. Not like your life depended on it.

I’m new to this genre, with the exception of Asherons Call 2 which I played for a couple of months prior to GW. While that game had it’s share of problems, (and in the process of being shut down), it had a very supportive close knit community. Most of the people playing that game were friendly intelligent gamers and played the game to enjoy it. People actually went out of their way to help out a new player.

In GW, if you have a question on gameplay, don’t bother asking anyone in-game, as you’re most likely to get either no response at all or “STFU noob!” You have to rely on guild mates or the forums to get any info. Thank God for this forum. At least people here will take the time to answer questions. Other than this and a couple other GW forums, it’s the only place I’ve found intelligent people, which is pretty sad.

As bad as I feel to say this, I for one would rather pay a monthly fee, and weed out a lot of the idiots playing now.
I personally have not had this experience. I've found nearly everyone on Guild Wars supportive. For example, when I was just a newbie in Beacon's Perch, a total stranger offered to run me to Droknar's Forge free of charge and then gave me 10k for my forge armor. I've never forgotten this, and now, after I've made my million gold, I help out anyone who asks for gold and/or help whenever I can. I can tell you right now that World of Warcraft has a much much worse community than Guild Wars. Because the game is pay to play, I found in my short time in the game that most people were not willing to waste their "precious" time and gold to help out new players. Be thankful for the Guild Wars community. If you have had a bad experience, don't use it to judge everyone else.

Alone)

Alone)

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2005

Campbell, California

Legio Imortalii

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Akimb0
you've n00bed yourself...deal with it. GW isnt good enough to be worth paying for.

Whoa now. Talk, but no walk. Can't back up what you're saying eh?

Anyways, Anet wanted people to play without having to pay a monthly fee, so that people can enjoy. Dealing with all annoying people and what not is just how it in real life too.

I feel that if you had to pay for GW, you would NOT weed out "idiots." For I feel that more smug and snotty people who can afford things more than others, are more idiotic. Whever you go, there WILL be idiots. Until we all mature.

Kai Nui

Kai Nui

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

Behind you with a knife

Celebrity Gangsters [FamE]

Me/

Hell no. I paid 50 bucks so I didn't pay monthly. The game I was playing prior was 5 bucks a month and I played it for more than 10 months, so this game is better. Monthly fees will not keep idiots out, it will just force them to pay to play. I think you should be ashamed for suggesting this, seriously.

Ultimate_Gaara

Ultimate_Gaara

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jun 2005

BC, Canada.. how aboot that eh?

Look at wow, it has fees and is has more immature morons than GW could ever cook up... fees stop nothing, little kids don't care if its not their money

A NERD1989

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Aug 2005

Elite Black Ops

W/Mo

i dont fully understand but if you need help join a guild with 50+ members

Axle_Fieshe

Banned

Join Date: May 2005

Mo/W

if there was a monthly fee i'd sell my account straight away, only reason i got GW was cos of the no-monthly cost

Xue Yi Liang

Xue Yi Liang

Jungle Guide

Join Date: May 2005

Northern CA

Outlaws of the Water Margin

Mo/Me

Welcome to the wild west that is online RPG.

Juvenile behavior is rampant regardless of what you play. WoW has a monthly fee but it's much much worse.

If you can find a guild with people who think like yourself (yes, it IS possible) then see about joining. It makes the whole experience more palatable.

So I don't believe a monthly fee is the answer. Besides, there are many nice casual players in GW who wouldn't have purchased it if there was a monthly fee. A monthly fee would make some folks, like myself, feel obligated to be online 24/7 to get our money's worth .... or to quit playing altogether. Implimenting a fee now would only drive many decent and good-natured players away.

kevinj

kevinj

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Aug 2005

R/

I love this game, im nice to all others who play, and i have never done anything to make anyone else mad. If guild wars had a fee though, i wouldnt play it.
Xue Yi Liang is right, it would drive away a lot of people who are curtious gamers.

heist23

Journeyman

Join Date: Jul 2005

R/Mo

sometimes i just head to the major towns just to help people out. i can't exactly give away gold, since i'm pretty much always low, but there's always someone who doesn't know where the Competition Arena entrance in LA is, or who doesn't know something else. i've met people on both sides of the spectrum, but most of the people i've interacted with are the nice types-or the totally silent types.

turning this game into a monthly-fee game would kill about half of the playerbase, but it wouldn't weed out the fools, idiots, self-contained elitists, "n00bs", and the other annoying players.

fezz47

Academy Page

Join Date: Jun 2005

You know, like I said, I think I've just burned out a bit on the game, but once I got playing some PvP I thought it might be different as far as the player mentality goes. Once I got to Droknars in the PvE campaign, it seemed people did take the game more seriously as far as teamwork and what not was concerned, so I guess I was just hoping that by playing level 20 PvP it would apply to that as well. It didn't, but I shouldn't have expected it to really.

As far as paying to play, I admit it probably wouldn't make much of a difference and was a mistake on my part. Having only one other game to compare it too, I wasn't aware that this kind of behavior was the norm for all games in this genre. Perhaps I do need to join a larger guild or just take a few weeks off.

Anyway, I appreciate all the replies.

Jakerius

Jakerius

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2005

Marhan's Grotto, reminiscing about the good old days when it had more than two people.

Children of Orion [CoO]

R/Mo

Quote:
Hell no. I paid 50 bucks so I didn't pay monthly. The game I was playing prior was 5 bucks a month and I played it for more than 10 months, so this game is better. Monthly fees will not keep idiots out, it will just force them to pay to play. I think you should be ashamed for suggesting this, seriously.
Heh, I bet it was Runescape.

Even in p2p (pay to play) games like WoW, AO, and EQ, you get plenty of disrespectful, immature people. You can't get rid of them, so just ignore them, or quit.

Bingley Joe

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2005

Philosophers of Denravi

We always have a choice in how to react to something another person does.

If somone does something, and our reaction is to become angry or annoyed.. well, then that's the choice we've made. We could have just as easily chosen to laugh, or raise an eyebrow, or simply ignore it completely and move on.

RamTheSneak

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Sep 2005

R/Me

I really think that it WOULD keep some of the idiots out. Having said that, I haven't seen any "idiots" in the game so far. I have never been truly bothered, and newbs are just something to deal with. Remember, you were a newb once too. Making GW a thing to pay for makes it too much like WoW. Guild Wars is a great game that should NOT be paid for. It gives people the freedom of playing the game. Think about it. Does it really seem fair that you pay $50 for a game that is ONLY online play, and to play that game you have to pay $15 a month? Very lame. Either pay every month for a game you can only play online, or not play this game you really want. Pointless. A lot of the people that like playing and are willing to pay don't have a Credit Card or Debit Card to pay for the game, or can't get their parents to pay even if the kids are willing to reinburst their parents.

Jaythen Tyradel

Jaythen Tyradel

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2005

Choice A:

Play GW and ignore rude and obnoxious players, etc, etc... and not loose money over it.

Choice B:

PLay a game paying each month to keep playing AND having to deal with rude players, greifers, player killers, loot stealers, juvenile main chat conversations, and likewise.

romO

romO

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jun 2005

Chicago

Idiot Savants [iQ]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Charcoal Ann
no monthly fee! don't give ANet ideas.... *looks hurredly around room and tries to hide thread*
i was just thinking the same thing! lol anet look away! and making people pay will in no way work to weed out the newbs/jerks/idiots. it will just make them pay ^^

coolsti

coolsti

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2005

Denmark

Hey fezz47,

you can still have a lot of fun with the game if you change your attitude a bit to all the idiots out there. First thing to remember is that there are also a lot of good players, and it does take a little luck and maybe time to find them. But when you do, its a lot of fun.

Not much you can do about the idiot players except laugh at them. There are the egoists, the perfectionists, the "I am better than you all because I have a higher level and am wearing Droknars armor" types, the types that go AFK to eat in the middle of a mission, the types that suddenly leave a mission because they need to go to bed, the types that expect anyone with monk as primary or secondary to personally heal them while they charge ahead into the middle of a mob with no concept of the tactic of luring, etc., etc. etc. I meet these all the time, and I either just ignore them, or play around with them. Like, if I am playing a character with healing and/or resurrection, I just will start to refuse to heal/res anyone that acts rudely or plays stupidly (like, charges ahead into the next monster group without waiting for support to regen or catch up).

Another thing I do is I try to be the leader of any PVE group, and if I already see that a party member is beginning to act up, I kick him (oh, so and so had to leave the group guys, so lets find another ... ). I'm not a leaver, and will try to stick out any mission or quest to the end, but in some rare cases where several of the party are really annoying, I explain to the group that I am leaving and why I am leaving. Either that, or I just don't aid the annoying ones at all and hope they all die!

So just ignore them, tease them, take revenge on them, whatever, but just have fun with the game!

Alone)

Alone)

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2005

Campbell, California

Legio Imortalii

W/Mo

^^^^^^

I like coolsti's style.

I do the same thing when I make groups. Don't like 'em, kick them. If they decide to bitch to me, I just give them a smile and say sorry. I mis-clicked. Setting examples to other people can stop the idiocy.

STOP THE IDIOCY. CURE THE PLAGUE. Set an example! One bitch at a time!
...

/sort of sarcasm.

Balrog1978

Balrog1978

Academy Page

Join Date: Sep 2005

India

Chi

W/E

Dude I play in the american servers, and except for a few chidings(i was asking WAYY to high for my dye, some other noob advised me to put that offer), Im yet to come across any such sad sack!!! Ppl are generally nice, although compared to Asian MMORPGs, they tend not to get very buddy like..
Still, they're helpful and till now ive NEVER had a query (in-game)thats gone unanswered.

Salute!

Balrog

coolsti

coolsti

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2005

Denmark

Quote:
Originally Posted by =HT=Ingram
I like PvP, and I like PvE BOTH. But I prefer PvE. Why? Cause the a$$holes that populate PvP are way over the top anymore. so I let them have their little turf, and leave them to compare, c0ck sizes on their own.
After a few months of PVE only and a little taste to PVP last night, I was actually looking forward to trying out PVP with my two higher level characters. Is it really that bad? Or are the unfriendly types only xx% of the total, with xx being a number significantly less than 100?

Quote:
Originally Posted by =HT=Ingram
Oh and one last thing. remember. the average age of some of these so called twits is like 15 at best... Heck I'm 33, and its hard as h3ll to find players around my age.
Yes, its hard to remember and imagine when you look at the same aged characters on the screen, that many of them may not be much older than 11! But one of the best players I have met so far with respect to maturity and teamworking and just general enjoyment of the game is only 14! Hey, I'm 51 and am currently playing this game every free hour I get! Fortunately my wife also loves the game.

Numa Pompilius

Numa Pompilius

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

At an Insit.. Intis... a house.

Live Forever Or Die Trying [GLHF]

W/Me

Quote:
Originally Posted by fezz47
While I find the economy in the game and trading system lacking, the game itself is great. It’s the community that sucks IMO.
Truth.
Quote:
I thought is was bad in the PvE part of the game with the whiners, rudeness, and people insisting of getting the “perfect group“ for a mission. God, you spend more time finding a group than playing. But PvP is even worse.
Truth. Playing PvP is an excercise in aggravation. I simply don't.
Quote:
In GW, if you have a question on gameplay, don’t bother asking anyone in-game, as you’re most likely to get either no response at all or “STFU noob!”
Truth. I stopped asking questions about when I reached Lions Arch - there just was no point, because I hardly ever got an answer.
Quote:
As bad as I feel to say this, I for one would rather pay a monthly fee, and weed out a lot of the idiots playing now.
Don't know if it'd work. By all accounts the WoW crowd is about the same, and that's a pay-to-play MMORPG.

GW's problem is that it inherited the battle.net crowd from DiabloII, through no fault of the game itself, just as WoW's problem is that it inherited the warcraft crowd.

Yukito Kunisaki

Yukito Kunisaki

Forge Runner

Join Date: Mar 2005

Chicago, IL

W/N

The moment this game becomes p2p [which will never happen thank God], you're not going to weed out the idiots...

Instead, there'll be about 3x more idiots than mature gamers because the mature people with wives, husbands, kids, jobs, and better things in life, will LEAVE and then you're stuck with these 15 yr. old morons who've got nothing smart to do with their money...

Me and my guild would easily disappear from this game simply due to the fact that we play this casually... [not 24/7 like these p2p wannabes who want to p2p because they have the idiocy to do so...]

I've got better things to do with my money and this game lets me do that.

Gustav Gloomp

Gustav Gloomp

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2005

Sydney, Australia

/signed
this WILL remove those little kids that swear and think they know what theyre doing.
ive played world of warcraft and havent come across a single person that has swore at anyone bcoz of how a battle went or blaming someone on why they lost or anything like that. i hope they make guild wars p2p.

Naprius

Naprius

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Sep 2005

mtricht

Limburgse Jagers

W/Mo

i dont want to pay for WoW and EverQuest and stuff, so why would i want to pay here?
i've often thought about starting to play those other games coz they look and sound really cool but the monthly fee fcks it up for me. pay like 20 euros per month just to play a stupid game??? hell no... ive got enough to pay for my internet connection.

i think guild war is THE game just becoz they let us play without a fee (ander other stuff that isnt important here)

Blu Vein

Blu Vein

Academy Page

Join Date: Sep 2005

Tampa

E/Me

Quote:
Originally Posted by =HT=Ingram
Heck I'm 33, and its hard as h3ll to find players around my age. why? well basically cause we have lives on the outside, and only play every once in a while...
I'm with you there anytime you want to get together and run some missions let me know I'm 27 and much perfer to play with other casual adult players with the more laid back "let's just go out and have fun" mentality.

Like I have said several other types on this forum. Real fun in the game comes from a group of people just out there having fun with it and having laughs along the way!