Hundred Blades may need some boost.

jibikao

jibikao

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

R/

Hundred Blades is an elite and quite a few warriors don't use it because of its low damage and usefulness.

From my understanding, HB is good for building up adrenline but there are other ways to gain adrenline through faster attacking and other warrior skills which are not elite.

My question is will it be overpowering to at least add some damage to HB? I mean Sword Level has nothing to do with HB. Maybe +1 damage per lvl? Would that be too overpowering? Or maybe +8 at lvl 12 Sword and +13 at lvl 16?

What's your thoughts?

Tmm Ryan

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Sep 2005

Plkn

I agree with you tottally, i personally have hundred blades as my elite all the time, this is becz it fits in well with the rest of my skills. But yea a dmg bonus wud make me pwn even more.

And if they did do nothing about the damage, at least change the recharge from 8 to 4 or 3

Navaros

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2005

Mo/Me

Hundred Blades sucks.

Apparently in the beta it used to not be elite, and then they nerfed it by making it an elite.

Long past time to unnerf Hundred Blades.

Helios

Helios

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2005

It got turned into an elite because it was being coupled with illusionary weaponary (at least that's what I've heard). At least it's had an unnerf. It used to do only 75% damage per swipe.

NatalieD

NatalieD

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

If it's too good in conjunction with IW, they could solve that by giving it a failure chance at low Swordsmanship levels. That way IW builds would have to give up a lot in order to use it, while plain sword warriors would have no problems.

Skyheart

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by NatalieD
If it's too good in conjunction with IW, they could solve that by giving it a failure chance at low Swordsmanship levels. That way IW builds would have to give up a lot in order to use it, while plain sword warriors would have no problems.
Well, yeah, but Illusionary Weapon is also an Elite now, so they really could boost it up, if Hundred Swords should stay as Elite.

Xasew

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2005

Storm Bearers[SB]

It's elite, because:
-Stuff like Vampiric Upgrade, Mark of Pain, Conjures, Orders and Strenght of Honor get double effective.
-You get double adrenaline(more if you hit more than 1 guy)
-It's AoE
-Doesn't cost that much, especially with a Zealous Hilt

It's bad on it's own, but it has uses.

Skyheart

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2005

Well, yes, but Cyclon Axe does more damage, also hits all enemies around, gets all the benefits you listed, and isn't an elite. Plus it recharges at double speed (only 4 second). This is kinda un-balanced, I say.

Hannibel

Hannibel

Banned

Join Date: Oct 2005

Playboy Entertainment

hundred blades doesnt suck, it hits twice to any adjacent foe, maybe you don't know how to read skills more clearly, if it was +1 per lvl it would be way to overpower because you would swing twice with +dmg each time

Ian Savage

Academy Page

Join Date: Nov 2005

Nowhere. And Everywhere. At the same time!

Born of Revolution [BoRN]

Mo/Me

doesnt suck at all. i use it as a constant elite on my N/W and i can level enemies with lower armor. two attacks for only 5 energy works for me. it may be underpowerd a bit, but i like it

Racthoh

Racthoh

Did I hear 7 heroes?

Join Date: May 2005

Scars Meadows [SMS], Guild Leader (Not Recruiting)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Skyheart
Well, yes, but Cyclon Axe does more damage, also hits all enemies around, gets all the benefits you listed, and isn't an elite. Plus it recharges at double speed (only 4 second). This is kinda un-balanced, I say.
Suppose we have 12 in sword, 12 in axe.

You use Cyclone Axe, +10 damage on top of the 28 max for axe dealing 38 damage.

I use Hundred Blades, strike twice at my maximum for 22, dealing 44 damage, and gaining two strikes of adrenaline over your one.

Not to mention that HB is by far more useful on a single target, and any warrior worth their value would know how to make two enemies stand next to each other to hit both with this skill.

From the PvP perspective, I could imagine it would be difficult to attack a fleeing target with Cyclone Axe, and you probably won't be able to hit a lot of targets with it.

A User Name

A User Name

Academy Page

Join Date: Jul 2005

None atm

Even though i'd like to see it have the +X. It could be overpowered. I mean if you strike someone 2 times for +X comboed with whatever that damage will really begin to add up. HB can be extremely powerful as it is with a good team (ex. warrior cunning+HB+ order of pain,vampire + vampric sword hilt.) That's an unblockable+10-22(2x)+17(2x)+17(2x)+(1-3)(2x) life steal. Adding up to around a 100 damage or more strike not including adrenaline gain. Meaning it prolly good for now.

Guardian of the Light

Guardian of the Light

Forge Runner

Join Date: Sep 2005

Radicals Against Tyrants

W/

The 100 blade team which is my creation takes advantage of 100 blades and if 100 blades would be increased in any way my build would become a 2nd IWAY http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...ad.php?t=74121

Try it and you'll never underestimate 100 blades again.

O ya almost forgot the final version is on page 4 and ingnore Conjure I got rid of that

easyg

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jul 2005

Hawaii

FPS

Mo/Me

Personally, I think HB is better than cyclone axe in a lot of ways. With my current set up, I use vigorous spirit and live vicariously at 9 healing prayer and a 3:1 vampiric weapon (axe of sword). Every time I connect with my axe, I get 21 health back and 1 strike of adrenaline. Every time I hit with my sword, I get 42 health and 2 strikes of adrenaline.

Say you're fighting 10 minotaurs. Assuming there's no blocks or misses:

Cyclone Axe: 210 hp and 10 strikes of adrenaline per 5 seconds
Hundred Blades: 420 hp and 20 strikes of adrenaline per 8 seconds.

This isn't counting the damage from HB, which obviously is much higher.

With a little practice, you can hit 10+ monsters at once with hundred blades. After you've agroed everything you want to kill, try walking away from the monsters while keeping your nose pointed towards them. The monsters come after you in a funnel like motions and get all packed together. Target the nearest and HB should hit everything. Just takes a bit of practice.

Deadlyjunk

Deadlyjunk

Banned

Join Date: Nov 2005

Fisherman's Haven

Endangered Species List [List]

W/E

Especially in an Arcane Mimicry/Illusionary Weaponry build...
Look:
Illusionary Weaponry
+
Arcane Mimicry
to fetch:
Hundred Blades
With flurry, this deals about 900 damage in 20 seconds, of which 400 to all adjacent foes as well. Underpowered? I thought not...

kg_lildude1

kg_lildude1

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jul 2005

Lionheart Braves [LHB]

W/

add some damage to hundred blades per level and it would be NO different from Barrage except you have the very low possibility to hit 8 people in pvp, or even more in pve

/signed for boost

Symeon

Symeon

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2005

/signed it needs a bit of a boost

jibikao

jibikao

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Racthoh
Suppose we have 12 in sword, 12 in axe.

You use Cyclone Axe, +10 damage on top of the 28 max for axe dealing 38 damage.

I use Hundred Blades, strike twice at my maximum for 22, dealing 44 damage, and gaining two strikes of adrenaline over your one.

Not to mention that HB is by far more useful on a single target, and any warrior worth their value would know how to make two enemies stand next to each other to hit both with this skill.

From the PvP perspective, I could imagine it would be difficult to attack a fleeing target with Cyclone Axe, and you probably won't be able to hit a lot of targets with it.
I don't think 100 Blades can deal +44 damage at max. The reason is that Cyclone's +10 damage is "on top of" damage so if the target has great physical defense (warriors), you are actually doing more damage with Cyclone per hit than 100 blades does. Not to mention Cyclone is not an elite and it has 5s recharge whereas 100 Blades has 8s. Another thing you forget is that 100 Blades swings twice at the target so two hits are reduced by Warrior's absorption. Of course you gain more adrenline with HB but don't forget the argument is you can gain more adrenline through other warrior skills.

I am not saying Cyclone > 100 Blades. I am just saying 100 Blades "may" need some boost. I guess you can only enjoy 100 Blades if you combo with secondary skills. 100 Blades by itself does very little damage and Sword Attribute has nothing to do with the effect which is what I don't understand. I like the idea of "success" rate with higher sword attribute.

Oh, and I think if you have Empathy on you, you take Empathy damage for every hit??? I know it happened to my Ranger's Barrage!! Two arrows hit the monsters and I took two Empathy damage! Ouch.


I do think 100 Blades can be a good solo farming skill since monsters only focus on you and you have much better chance to lure monsters to you.

Guardian of the Light

Guardian of the Light

Forge Runner

Join Date: Sep 2005

Radicals Against Tyrants

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by jibikao
I don't think 100 Blades can deal +44 damage at max. The reason is that Cyclone's +10 damage is "on top of" damage so if the target has great physical defense (warriors), you are actually doing more damage with Cyclone per hit than 100 blades does. Not to mention Cyclone is not an elite and it has 5s recharge whereas 100 Blades has 8s. Another thing you forget is that 100 Blades swings twice at the target so two hits are reduced by Warrior's absorption. Of course you gain more adrenline with HB but don't forget the argument is you can gain more adrenline through other warrior skills.

I am not saying Cyclone > 100 Blades. I am just saying 100 Blades "may" need some boost. I guess you can only enjoy 100 Blades if you combo with secondary skills. 100 Blades by itself does very little damage and Sword Attribute has nothing to do with the effect which is what I don't understand. I like the idea of "success" rate with higher sword attribute.

Oh, and I think if you have Empathy on you, you take Empathy damage for every hit??? I know it happened to my Ranger's Barrage!! Two arrows hit the monsters and I took two Empathy damage! Ouch.


I do think 100 Blades can be a good solo farming skill since monsters only focus on you and you have much better chance to lure monsters to you.
I read in my 100 blade team someone said test Empathy + 100 blades and they say it does do double damage but I'm not confirming it myself

Dralspire

Retired

Join Date: Apr 2005

Personally, I am not so excited by the recharge time of hundred blades, but that's just me.

GWGuru

Banned

Join Date: Nov 2005

The fact that it swings twice is why it's an elite. Try to think about how to use your skills instead of throwing 8 random skills into your bar and hoping it does damage.

Hundred Blades + Mark of Pain
Hundred Blades + Orders
Hundred Blades + Judges Insight
Hundred Blades + Conjure Light/Flame/Frost
Hundred Blades + Spinal Shivers

etc. etc. etc.

think about coupling your attacks with a buffer from your secondary and all of a sudden Hundred Blades becomes an elite.

Sentao Nugra

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2005

Crystal Lake, Illinois

Grenths Rejects [GR]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deadlyjunk
Especially in an Arcane Mimicry/Illusionary Weaponry build...
Look:
Illusionary Weaponry
+
Arcane Mimicry
to fetch:
Hundred Blades
With flurry, this deals about 900 damage in 20 seconds, of which 400 to all adjacent foes as well. Underpowered? I thought not...
the most interesting 2man solo build i have ever seen

jibikao

jibikao

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by GWGuru
The fact that it swings twice is why it's an elite. Try to think about how to use your skills instead of throwing 8 random skills into your bar and hoping it does damage.

Hundred Blades + Mark of Pain
Hundred Blades + Orders
Hundred Blades + Judges Insight
Hundred Blades + Conjure Light/Flame/Frost
Hundred Blades + Spinal Shivers

etc. etc. etc.

think about coupling your attacks with a buffer from your secondary and all of a sudden Hundred Blades becomes an elite.
I actually tried to combo HB + Conjure and I am just not too impressed by the effect especially against warriors/rangers. Warriors have absorption so the damage from both the sword and conjure gets reduced TWICE and against Rangers, the damage is instantly reduced by 30% per hit because of their natural resistance. The 8s recharge doesn't make it easier too.

HB + Curse may be better but Spinal Shivers is something that just doesn't work. HB costs energy and for each interruption you lose energy. How in the world are you going to use HB again after you've interrupted a few times?

I guess my point is there are other ways to gain adrenline and to swing faster...like Furry/Tiger Fury. Even if you don't swing as fast to trigger the secondary "effects" (like conjure, curse, smiting), that elite spot can be something MORE useful than HB IMO.

Maybe you've tested it and the skill looks elite to you. I just haven't been able to figure out why HB is worth elite.

jibikao

jibikao

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

R/

After thinking about it...

A team of Mark of Pain and HB may be fun, just like MoP + Barrage but Barrage adds damage and with less recharge.