PC on 2 gold shields

i would like to get a pc on these 2 shields:

#1
Aegis (gold)
armor: 16 (req 8 tactics)
+44hp (while enchanted)

#2
Tall Shield (gold)
armor: 16 (req 11 tactics)
+43hp (while enchanted)
-2dmg received (while in stance)

i bought these shields relatively cheap (i think) but i have no clue how shields are valued so any help would be appreciated. thank you

1) 30-50k
2) 10-30k

Heres a rough guide from my view point.

Tactic shields are usually valued at less than strength based shield , main reason for this is strength based shields are less common in my experience , i would say as much as 65-70% of shields are tac based.

The higher the requirement on a shield , the less value is obtained , 13 is almost unusable for most builds , 10 is moderate and 7 is perfect.

No1 Aegis shield.

Good points - High Health bonus. (Only 1 away from max) , Low requirement 8
Bad Points - Common skin , only one bonus.

Value 20 -25k.


No 2 Tall shield.
Good points - High Health bonus. (Only 2 away from max) , 2 bonuses (very cool) , more desirerable skin sort after tac shield.

Bad Points - REQUIREMENT above moderate 11 tactics kills the value on this shield.

Value - my estimate 30 -40k
(if req was 8 on this shield value would have been pushed up to about 90k+)

Chaos.

On the Tall Shield req 11 tactics makes it near unusable. Req 11 strength is bearable, but req 11 tactics is too high.

You also need to factor in that health comes from enchanted and -damage comes from stance. It would be worth more if both were enchanted or stance linked.

I had a req. 7 tall shield with +40e/-2s and could barely sell it for 50-55k. Mixed mods like that = unwanted...

wow thanks alot guys for all the input