Ebay and Guild Wars

Stur

Stur

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: May 2005

Athens Georgia

Outlaws of Ascalon

E/Mo

11 May 2005 at 15:45 - 81
Well that makes a bit more sense and you make some good points there. It would seem that we have deviated from the original topic a bit but I have found this little debate thoroughly enjoyable anyway lol
I would love to hear from some of you in game so if anyone wants to add me to their friends list. My toons name is Fyre Starter (and yes I am a guy playing a girl toon but that’s a whole different thread, one that got deleted I think).

Master Elyas

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: May 2005

People Of The Dragon

W/Mo

11 May 2005 at 16:00 - 82
lol... ill add ya then... i have a screenshot of my character, just incase you see him, and i dont see u... ill post it here in a sec...

Deagol

Deagol

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2005

Denmark

11 May 2005 at 16:11 - 83
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramus
It seems to me you think that because we do not pay monthly fees that this somehow makes Guild Wars less of a online RPG than any other game.
I think the financial model for the game has influenced how it has been designed. I think this partically because one of the ArenaNet founded stated that explicitly in an interview.

I probably also think so because I haven't played enough MMORPG's to have a fixed idea of what anything "must" be. So I look at the game for what it is, rather than what other games I know have been.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramus
If you truely want to compare this to World of Warcraft, or Counter-strike, you can bet that 90% of the game has more in common with WoW than CS.
I could, but I would lose. The game is 50% PvP, and the PvP is based on skill, not time played. Thus it has substantiably less than 90% "more in common" with World of Warcraft than with Counter Strike. The PvE is of course more similar to WoW, especially the pre-Ascension part where level (and thus: time played) still play a significant role.

I'll agree that the superficial similarities can be decieving.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramus
They adverstised this game as the first MMORPG with no monthly payments, and now they are going to have to put there money where there mouths are and live up to that by providing features to us players who want more non-pvp content
I have never actually found any of those advertisements. What I have found repeatedly is ArenaNet personet insisting that the game is a new genre, called CORPG, competitive online role playing game.

I have found lots of previews that calls it a MMORPG, especially from those previewers that never left pre-searing Ascalon.

Edit: Ok, I talk too much. I promise not respond more in this thread.

Ramus

Ramus

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: May 2005

Florida

Zero Tolerance

W/Mo

11 May 2005 at 16:14 - 84
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deagol
I could, but I would lose. The game is 50% PvP, and the PvP is based on skill, not time played. Thus it has substantiably less than 90% "more in common" with World of Warcraft than with Counter Strike. The PvE is of course more similar to WoW, especially the pre-Ascension part where level (and thus: time played) still play a significant role.
Yes, but you misunderstood me here. I mean if we only compare it to world of warcraft and CS. No other games, that it would be much more like WoW.

Yes, they did advertise (and not stamp out the rumor) that this would be a non-pay to play mmorpg. Thats why they put so much emphasis on there not being a fee on everything.

As for talking, feel free to continue. I love a good debate and I have no bad feelings towards you for giving your opinion. Its what makes these forums great.