03 Dec 2005 at 16:57 - 3
I have tried incorporating Judge's Insight into my CA builds and this is what I was running only two days ago. I know you specifically mentioned PvE but you will probably face the same problems.
Dual Shot
Quick Shot
Savage Shot
RTW
Judge's Insight
Troll Unguent
Whirling Defense
Free Slot/Res Signet
The problems were, first of all, energy management. I had 10 points into Insight and it lasted for 16 seconds (for 10 energy), not only did I have to constantly reapply it but it was also a big drain on my energy pool. It has a 2s casting time if I remember correctly and in the heat of battle (PvE or PvP) that is a little too much, especially for a ranger.
The other problem was setting up the attribute points so that this would work effectively, I needed a full 18 second duration but that was unfortunately impossible with all the points that I needed to put into expertise.
The final issue was that the damage is not all that impressive. This was PvP, but I dont think you are going to get an appreciable (keeping the energy cost in mind) increase in damage. Preps and Spirits are easier to work with and do more damage. The only synergy that stands out (from a PvE point of view) would be Barrage + Insight. Conjure *Insert Element* would probably be much better considering that it lasts for a full minute with the same energy cost.
Edit:
Quote:
Originally Posted by FeuerFrei
ermmm judges and ignite wouldnt work....as judges is physical damage while ignite is fire...thus itll be bez to get something else...like read the wind as a prep. instead of ignite arrows
Shouldnt be a problem, its Kindle Arrows that makes your damage fire, only the AoE from ignite is fire damage.