Quote:
|
Whats a PuG? THAT's the question! is it something like random teams? |
|
Originally Posted by The Herbalizer
Rename it pls, "Elite Mission Cookie-Cutter Guide".
There is NO NEED to make a cookie cutter guide to the elite missions. Instead of making a guide to the elite missions which actually encourages pugs to take other classes such as mesmer which they wouldnt normally take you encourage them to stick to their cookie cutter mentality. |
|
Originally Posted by capitalist
However, for the mildly experienced PvE'r, some of the statements don't apply.
|

|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
I added a short disclaimer before the roles.
|

|
Originally Posted by Doomlord_Slayermann
While the Warrior's tanking ability may be foremost in importance, there should at least be some room on the skillbar for some damage or knockdown skills. Stance/Knockdown tanks are quite popular and sufficiently effective. Sword-based damage skills can really help finish off the target as well, although Axe is generally less effective here because its strength is in spiking and you can't really spike out a level 28 Oni.
|
|
Originally Posted by Doomlord_Slayermann
Mesmers still get far less credit than they deserve. Yes, the general idea is that they are useless, but some Mesmer builds (such as the Deep Wound nuker) will mesh seamlessly with the other PUG builds here. I think those deserve some recognition.
|
|
Originally Posted by Doomlord_Slayermann
I wish I could, but I can't really defend the Assassin. 90% of them just try to tank and die. The only possible build would be the crit-barrager, which, depending on the situation, could be more or less effective than a Meteor Shower nuker.
|
|
Originally Posted by Doomlord_Slayermann
Battery necros tend to be a waste of a slot if monks and nukers know how to manage their energy. This is, unfortunately, a rare occurance in PUGs.
|
|
Originally Posted by Doomlord_Slayermann
Ward-using E/Mos with Earthquake and Aftershock also can easily mesh with the other PUG builds and are becoming increasingly popular, especially in FoW and UW. Coordinating Earthquake with your Meteor Showers can mean your enemy's ass never leaves the ground, and its not even very hard to pull off.
|
|
Originally Posted by The Herbalizer
<snip>
|
|
Originally Posted by CHUIU
The gain of a mesmer (deep wound nuking or any other builds) isn't much over having another nuker. As it is it takes meer seconds for good groups to take out several groups of enemies as long as the tanks have them walled up properly. In the situation that tanks don't have things walled up properly then the mesmer is just as useless as any nuker when it comes to killing the loose ends of the aggro.
|
|
Originally Posted by CHUIU
No one can defend the sins. They are 100% worthless in these missions EVEN as running crit/barrage (which, for the record, is WEAKER than a barrage ranger). For example, during 90% of the deep a crit/barrage either would deal very little damage and inflict no conditions due to non-fleshies, or would severly mess up aggro by triggering things like Vipers Defense and causing several Oni's to teleport behind the warriors and attack the casters.
|
|
Originally Posted by CHUIU
For the deep they are there for the monks, monks often have to spam a lot of spells or expensive spells (15 energy heal party - 10 energy extinguish) to keep everyone up and using an elite for energy management (because lets face it, thats the only good energy management a monk can hope to bring) still may not provide enough energy and would be a waste of an elite (RC/SB/WOH/Martyr are all effective monk skills in these areas).
For Urgoz when teams like going 4 trappers, its easier to bring QZ and no EW and have a necro BIP them to speed up trapping by a lot. Also the necro almost needs to bip the monks (which many teams only bring 2 of) during touchy situations. |
|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Mesmers: None. Mesmers aren't useless: Backfire and Cry of Frustration can be damaging to enemies. However, the PuG Mentality is that Mesmers are useless. It's been that way since the beginning of the game, sorry. PuGs have always tried the cookie-cutter build. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. You'll never see a group looking specificaly for a Mesmer. |
|
Originally Posted by Reine Stormshroud
Now, THAT makes me mad. Mesmers can perform very well. Heard of Energy Surge? Echoed? Guess not. Interrupts. Degeneration. Spikes. Honestly, people who do not include mesmers because they are not part of the 'cookie cutter buld' - Need to reconsider. I am a mesmer myself and I am looking forward to this event, and yet, a guide is put up, saying mesmers are not gonna work here.
Mesmers may not be any more valuble than a regular fire nuker, but not including them isn't necessary. This kind of guide is discriminating against classes, which i don't find very respectable. I reccomend looking into some good points about this/and other classes that were listed as 'none' and revise. |
