Who here wants to see more classes added to GW?
Maxiemonster
It won't change extremly much for me, as I don't play anything but Monk. But of course, more secondary proffesions to consider, and more profffesions to fight against is always nice.
lyra_song
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ninna
more classes please
I like the ANET Magic the Gathering model http://pc.gamespy.com/pc/guild-wars-.../680914p1.html |
And with CCG card games, Anet needs to implement limited rules and phase out certain skills to balance skills without making them truly crappy.
Ira Blinks
if i have to choose between new content (new characters, skills, monsters, areas, etc.) and fixing gameplay (fixing bugs, balance changes, interface/control improvements, market/communication improvements, NPC AI, and making sense out of things like gold and purple vs green drops, etc.) then I always pick second.
No matter how good content is, it is not going to last long on flawed foundation.
No matter how good content is, it is not going to last long on flawed foundation.
prime stinger
nah 8 should be the cap.. add more skills and armous is what i want to see
Selket
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ninna
more classes please
I like the ANET Magic the Gathering model http://pc.gamespy.com/pc/guild-wars-.../680914p1.html |
No more new classes. I'd rather new skills for existing classes and even new attribute lines for existing classes.
SirShadowrunner
I haven't read all the posts, so I bet someone mentioned it already, I would like to
see some different races besides human, getting a little old now, I mean how human
warriors do we really need ?????
I think races that have advantages with certain skills or weapons would be great,
Dwarves with hammers, Elves with bows, and Orcs with axes just to name a few.
As far as weapons, skills, and maps go, that is not the question I see here, so I am not
including any comments on those.
-SirShadowrunner
see some different races besides human, getting a little old now, I mean how human
warriors do we really need ?????
I think races that have advantages with certain skills or weapons would be great,
Dwarves with hammers, Elves with bows, and Orcs with axes just to name a few.
As far as weapons, skills, and maps go, that is not the question I see here, so I am not
including any comments on those.
-SirShadowrunner
EternalTempest
I'm happy with 5 core classes that are always expanded and 2 "specialized" job that are limited to that campaign (aka were NOT going to see much new stuff for them in future chapters). I would guess there will be ZERO skills for the Sin/Rit in Nightfall. Only armor I can see is a new "stat" type, like ele getting HP armor in factions, Sin gets new "type" armor option in Nightfall and that it.
The specialized jobs are NOT going to be built up like the core, think one/two trick pony and that it. The only new use would be mixing them with new jobs/skills.
Also it's a very INVALID assumption everyone is going to own all the games. If Nightfall is on par with original GW, then I can see people getting GW & GW-NF and skipping factions.
I do assume they will be "tweaking" specialized classes skills at time go on to make them fit in the game (buff/debuff).
The specialized jobs are NOT going to be built up like the core, think one/two trick pony and that it. The only new use would be mixing them with new jobs/skills.
Also it's a very INVALID assumption everyone is going to own all the games. If Nightfall is on par with original GW, then I can see people getting GW & GW-NF and skipping factions.
I do assume they will be "tweaking" specialized classes skills at time go on to make them fit in the game (buff/debuff).
MMSDome
I am alright if they come up with new professions every month as long as they are unique. I think the Paragon is a great idea and I look forward to using it. As long as the developers keep coming with good class ideas im all for it. I get tired of the same classes and new classes make more variety and more of a challenge in pve and pvp and more farming builds!
Mordakai
I don't get the hate towards new classes. I really don't.
No one is forcing you to play with the new classes... I've joined several PUGs in Factions with no Ritualists or Assassins.
And the analogy of Monks being a roll of the dice is totally wrong. It doesn't matter how many total classes are available, you can only play one class at a time. Many people who play healing Monks will continue to play healing Monks, and some people who don't play healing Monks should eventually try it out. Add to that other possible Healing Profs, and it will all balance out. Plus, the new Hero characters should help "fill in the gaps."
The only problem I see with the new classes is just the fact everyone wants to play them in the beginning (naturally), so you have a gazillion Assassins LFG when you really only need one per group.
But, like I said, that situation has gone down quite a bit since release.
So, expect tons of Paragons and Dervishes with the release of Nightfall. But there will also be all the other classes as well, so don't worry, I'm sure you can find a group to play with. I always have....
No one is forcing you to play with the new classes... I've joined several PUGs in Factions with no Ritualists or Assassins.
And the analogy of Monks being a roll of the dice is totally wrong. It doesn't matter how many total classes are available, you can only play one class at a time. Many people who play healing Monks will continue to play healing Monks, and some people who don't play healing Monks should eventually try it out. Add to that other possible Healing Profs, and it will all balance out. Plus, the new Hero characters should help "fill in the gaps."
The only problem I see with the new classes is just the fact everyone wants to play them in the beginning (naturally), so you have a gazillion Assassins LFG when you really only need one per group.
But, like I said, that situation has gone down quite a bit since release.
So, expect tons of Paragons and Dervishes with the release of Nightfall. But there will also be all the other classes as well, so don't worry, I'm sure you can find a group to play with. I always have....
prism2525
might be a pointless thing but i hope they give more options on to change the character's posture. Who saw the female paragon you'll see that her posture is IDENTICAL to the female elementalist.
I like the idea of new attribute lines for existing professions. wars from GW4 would have some unique attributes (like crowbar instead of hammer
). Accounts having both campaigns could gain access to all attributes.
I like the idea of new attribute lines for existing professions. wars from GW4 would have some unique attributes (like crowbar instead of hammer
lyra_song
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Selket
Except MTG has kept the same five colours of magic since release (colours can essentially be compared to classes) but adds new spells of sorts to the game (skills for guild wars) adding new classes is like adding another colour of magic (something that they'd never do because they've awknowledged how terrible an idea it is).
No more new classes. I'd rather new skills for existing classes and even new attribute lines for existing classes. |
closer to colors than the professions in your analogy.Dwayna (White)
Balthazar (Red)
Grenth (Black)
Melandru (Green)
Lyssa (Blue)
The different professions and their abilities fall within those 5.
Selket
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lyra_song
Nope, theres still only 5 gods
closer to colors than the professions in your analogy.Dwayna (White) Balthazar (Red) Grenth (Black) Melandru (Green) Lyssa (Blue) The different professions and their abilities fall within those 5. |
Mordakai
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Selket
Except MTG has kept the same five colours of magic since release (colours can essentially be compared to classes) but adds new spells of sorts to the game (skills for guild wars) adding new classes is like adding another colour of magic (something that they'd never do because they've awknowledged how terrible an idea it is).
No more new classes. I'd rather new skills for existing classes and even new attribute lines for existing classes. |
Professions don't equal colors, Attributes do. So already you have 24+ "colors" in Prophecy (although, not all Attributes have skills related, most do).
However, using a skill is based on two things: Your level in that particular attribute, and a power source (at this point, Energy, Adrenaline or Signets).
So, it's not like Mana, where you have to have red mana to cast a red spell - any profession can use any skill. It's just that to be effective, you must have high enough points in the attribute (except for Non-attribute skills, perfect for secondary professions).
In a way, each new profession is offering new skills available to your character as secondaries.
In addition, exisiting professions give all their secondary skills to the new professions.
It's a good system, and one that will work for a good time to come.
Horseman Of War
i look forward to any new characters ANet produces.
If they only ever had the same old core classes, I probably would never buy an expansion, and would have started losing interest.
They WILL continue to make new classes, not much any of you can do about it.
if a new chapter had no new classes, what would they put on the box?
There would be nothing to make me want to buy it. (yay some more maps, but I dont care. Gimme pvp variety. thxkbye)
If they only ever had the same old core classes, I probably would never buy an expansion, and would have started losing interest.
They WILL continue to make new classes, not much any of you can do about it.
if a new chapter had no new classes, what would they put on the box?
There would be nothing to make me want to buy it. (yay some more maps, but I dont care. Gimme pvp variety. thxkbye)
lyra_song
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Selket
No because you don't pick a god and cast stuff, you pick a profession and cast stuff.
|
In reality, all new skills and professions fall under those 5 types of behaviours.
Assassin: Lyssa, Balthazar
Ritualist: Grenth, Dwayna (imo)
Dervish: Balthazar, Dwayna, Melandru
Paragon: Balthazar, Dwayna (forgive me i dont know Paragons too well)
No matter how many professions and skills and attributes we get.
--------
Unless Anet adds more gods.
Mordakai
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lyra_song
But your analogy is saying that the more professions in the game, the more "colors" there are.
In reality, all new skills and professions fall under those 5 types of behaviours. Assassin: Lyssa, Balthazar Ritualist: Grenth, Dwayna (imo) Dervish: Balthazar, Dwayna, Melandru Paragon: Balthazar, Dwayna (forgive me i dont know Paragons too well) No matter how many professions and skills and attributes we get. -------- Unless Anet adds more gods. |
- you can't choose your god, so it's not like choosing a Color in Magic
- gods don't have any influence on choosing skills or attributes, it's little more than fluff
- The only thing gods provide game effects for are blessings and access to special areas (and some quests)
- In regards to your skills, your attributes and power source are the only thing that effects your ability to use the skill. That's all.
You can't directly compare the Colors of Magic to Guild Wars, because all professions use "colorless" mana, i.e., Energy, Adrenaline or Signets (basically, a spell that uses no power source at all).
The only thing comparible to Colors in Magic is your Attributes, which is what allows you to "play" your "skills" effectively (although, as I mentioned above, nothings going to stop you from taking any spell for any character. It just won't be very effective at level 0, in most cases).
saphir
i realize this isn't bard's tale, but how about a bard class?
i love the idea of a pirate class though. it would be really cool to have a chapter take place on the high seas (not the frozen ones like we have now) =)
imagine some pvp arenas fought across some 3 masted vessels, firing cannons and the like heh
i guess i'll never get to play my rot wallow monk, although what does a female rot wallow look like...?
i love the idea of a pirate class though. it would be really cool to have a chapter take place on the high seas (not the frozen ones like we have now) =)
imagine some pvp arenas fought across some 3 masted vessels, firing cannons and the like heh
i guess i'll never get to play my rot wallow monk, although what does a female rot wallow look like...?
Huntster
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by saphir
i realize this isn't bard's tale, but how about a bard class?
i love the idea of a pirate class though. it would be really cool to have a chapter take place on the high seas (not the frozen ones like we have now) =) ..? |
saphir
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Huntster
The amount of people with some variation of Jack Sparrow would be insane.
|
Age
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lyra_song
Nope, theres still only 5 gods
closer to colors than the professions in your analogy.Dwayna (White) Balthazar (Red) Grenth (Black) Melandru (Green) Lyssa (Blue) The different professions and their abilities fall within those 5. |
Dwayna (blue)
Balthazar (orange)
Grenth ( dark green)
Melandru (light Green)
Lyssa (pink)
It is the same colour as to what the skills look like on your skill bar.
unholy guardian
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by actionjack
I hope they have more innovative classes.. not just re-combination of existing ones.
|
eternal pho
IMO, there's already enough classes. People are still making new build.
lyra_song
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mordakai
You've lost me, Lyra.
|
I compare MTG's decks to TEAMS not individual players. So a GVG team of 8 players with 8 skills from 2 different gods each.
Quote:
|
All the warrior skills fall into Balthazar. Some assassin skills fall into Balthazar. Some Dervish skills fall into Balthazar.
Quote:
You can't directly compare the Colors of Magic to Guild Wars, because all professions use "colorless" mana, i.e., Energy, Adrenaline or Signets (basically, a spell that uses no power source at all). |
Im just justifying adding more profession, as a response Selket's accusation that adding more professions is like adding more colors to MTG.
And that justification that colors cant be compared to professions, they are more closely related to the 5 gods than anything else, imo.
Quote:
| The only thing comparible to Colors in Magic is your Attributes, which is what allows you to "play" your "skills" effectively (although, as I mentioned above, nothings going to stop you from taking any spell for any character. It just won't be very effective at level 0, in most cases). |
Lyssa's lines include: Illusion, Fast Cast, Domination, Inspiration, Energy Storage, Shadow Arts.
Balthazar's lines include: Strength, Axe mastery, Sword Mastery, Hammer Mastery, Tactics, Dagger Mastery
and so on and so forth.
its not a rock solid arguement, but it certainly holds up better than selket's, which is what im trying to dispute.