Ever want to sell a mini pet but it's dedicated at your Hall of Monuments? Sure you can still sell them, but you probably won't get as much for it. And some people prefer non-dedicated minis.
This idea came to me when my guild was holding a raffle and winners got mini pets, but they were already dedicated to a HOM.
I think that, for a fee, you should be able to un-dedicate mini pets. And, while we're at it, un-customize weapons. What does everyone else think?
Un-dedicate mini pets
Tender Wolf
Arkantos
Don't want your minipet dedicated? Don't put it in your hall of monuments. Don't want your weapon customized? Don't customize it.
We don't need to be able to un-dedicate/customize. If you think you're going to want to sell your mini pet/weapon, then keep it as it is. It's as simple as that.
/notsigned
We don't need to be able to un-dedicate/customize. If you think you're going to want to sell your mini pet/weapon, then keep it as it is. It's as simple as that.
/notsigned
Darkobra
I think the three warning screens or so you get WARNING you what will happen when you dedicate something to a monument should be enough.
RavagerOfDreams
/notsigned
just like uncustomizing not going to happen
just like uncustomizing not going to happen
DarkFlame
Free Monuments of Devotion and Valor for everyone right?
Dedicate/customize serve a purpose and unless the fee is the same as the cost of a mini Polar Bear, you should not be allowed to reverse it.
Dedicate/customize serve a purpose and unless the fee is the same as the cost of a mini Polar Bear, you should not be allowed to reverse it.
Arkantos
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Darkobra
I think the three warning screens or so you get WARNING you what will happen when you dedicate something to a monument should be enough.
|
Witchblade
wow 
i'm speechless.. and so notsigning
i'm speechless.. and so notsigning
Zydonis
Dedicate:
To commit (oneself) to a particular course of thought or action.
To commit (oneself) to a particular course of thought or action.
Div
Tender wolf returns to compete with Solange for the Sardelac crown!
/notsigned.
/notsigned.
RedStar
/notsigned
It's been suggested a LOT of time... and each action has consequences (think before dedicating/customizing).
It's been suggested a LOT of time... and each action has consequences (think before dedicating/customizing).
MagmaRed
/unsigned
Do you know WHY things are dedicated/customized?
Do you know WHY things are dedicated/customized?
Konig Des Todes
No, why? Because then people would dedicate, undedicate, sell, and still have those minipets in their HoM. The only way this can be a good thing is if you can remove the minipet from your HoM. And if that is what this idea is changed to, then it must be that you have to have the mini pet you dedicated in your inventory, so that you cannot simply buy another mini pet of the same kind, dedicate it on another character, undedicate it on your first character, then sell.
Although an idea that would be loved by the poor, it is just poorly thought out. If you want to not get flamed to death like Solange, I suggest thinking through and not posting half-a$$ed ideas. Not to be insulting or anything but its the truth, and truth hurts.
Although an idea that would be loved by the poor, it is just poorly thought out. If you want to not get flamed to death like Solange, I suggest thinking through and not posting half-a$$ed ideas. Not to be insulting or anything but its the truth, and truth hurts.
StormDragonZ
What this thread tells me:
Buy a Mini Kuunavang, Mini Gwen and Mini Destroyer Dedicated, then undedicate them by whatever means, and enjoy the overflow of gold by reselling them.
Buy a Mini Kuunavang, Mini Gwen and Mini Destroyer Dedicated, then undedicate them by whatever means, and enjoy the overflow of gold by reselling them.
travis ranger
ya /notsigned
that would be terrible i agree with most that were saying that people would be able to "undedicate them" then sell them..
people got free minis and are whining that they are ded? psshhhh
that would be terrible i agree with most that were saying that people would be able to "undedicate them" then sell them..
people got free minis and are whining that they are ded? psshhhh
HawkofStorms
/notsigned
GW already has the most forgiving system of any game of its type. You can restructure skill tree at any time. You can change secondaries. You can map anywhere.
Having one or two things like customization and dedicated mini-pets doesn't destroy the game.
GW already has the most forgiving system of any game of its type. You can restructure skill tree at any time. You can change secondaries. You can map anywhere.
Having one or two things like customization and dedicated mini-pets doesn't destroy the game.
cellardweller
Thankyou for making me smile.
wilderness
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by StormDragonZ
What this thread tells me:
Buy a Mini Kuunavang, Mini Gwen and Mini Destroyer Dedicated, then undedicate them by whatever means, and enjoy the overflow of gold by reselling them. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Azazel The Assassin
No, why? Because then people would dedicate, undedicate, sell, and still have those minipets in their HoM.
|
Oh, and the OP is a horrid idea.
Lykan
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Tender Wolf
Ever want to sell a mini pet but it's dedicated at your Hall of Monuments? Sure you can still sell them, but you probably won't get as much for it. And some people prefer non-dedicated minis.
This idea came to me when my guild was holding a raffle and winners got mini pets, but they were already dedicated to a HOM. I think that, for a fee, you should be able to un-dedicate mini pets. And, while we're at it, un-customize weapons. What does everyone else think? |
Yuhe Ji
Definitely /notsigned
Dedication and customization should not be undone. Then people can easily buy them for cheap and undedicate/uncustomize and sell for higher.
Dedication and customization should not be undone. Then people can easily buy them for cheap and undedicate/uncustomize and sell for higher.
wilderness
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Yuhe Ji
Definitely /notsigned
Dedication and customization should not be undone. Then people can easily buy them for cheap and undedicate/uncustomize and sell for higher. |
It might help to think before you click reply
MirkoTeran
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by holymasamune
Tender wolf returns to compete with Solange for the Sardelac crown!
|
Vilaptca
While everyone else is thinking of reselling their minipets, I'm thinking dedicate, then undedicate and trade for a different mini. Or trade with guildies until everyone in the guild has all the minipets in their halls. Completely filling my minipet monument on all my characters forever and ever and ever.
/unsigned.
It would completely demolish the point of even having minipets in your Hall of Monuments.
/unsigned.
It would completely demolish the point of even having minipets in your Hall of Monuments.
wilderness
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Vilaptca
While everyone else is thinking of reselling their minipets, I'm thinking dedicate, then undedicate and trade for a different mini. Or trade with guildies until everyone in the guild has all the minipets in their halls. Completely filling my minipet monument on all my characters forever and ever and ever.
/unsigned. It would completely demolish the point of even having minipets in your Hall of Monuments. |
It's still not sign worthy.
Vilaptca
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wilderness
I think, quite obviously, the proposed system would remove the pet from your hall when you remove the dedication, thus negating the exploit.
It's still not sign worthy. |
N1ghtstalker
it pains my heart to see mini's get dedicated as i love to keep them as they are
but if a mallyx is around 100k and 20e
and you can unded it for 20k (ded is 80k) you can still make a huge profit
once it's ded it stays ded
/notsigned
but if a mallyx is around 100k and 20e
and you can unded it for 20k (ded is 80k) you can still make a huge profit
once it's ded it stays ded
/notsigned
wilderness
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Vilaptca
You can't just assume with these kind of things
|
Necro Quink
/notsigned
The rare minipets wont be as worth as much anymore if you start doing that.
The rare minipets wont be as worth as much anymore if you start doing that.
IslandHermet
And another bad tender wolf post woot. keep it up you are going to set the record.
/notsigned
/notsigned
legion_rat
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by N1ghtstalker
once it's ded it stays ded
/notsigned |
To Tenderwolf, I will not flame you like the rest of the board. While I see where you are going with the idea, as you can see, it would cause problems with people dedicating minis selling then the other person dedicating blah blah freaking blah. Of course I thought you meant that if it was undedicated then said person loses it from the HoM. So its no longer theirs at all. They cant go "check out my cool ass mallyx mini in HoM!" Maybe I misunderstood.
so if you mean they get to keep the mini in HoM but sell it as undedicate
/not signed
If you mean the seller loses it completely and its a brand new mini again
/signed
~the rat~
TheRaven
Ok, I won't stoop to flaming but I have to agree that it's a bad idea.
There are trade offs to everything in this game. If you want the extra damage a customized weapon offers then you need to sacrifice the resale value to customize. If you want to dedicate a minipet then that mini is yours and can no longer belong to anyone else's HoM. That's the tradeoff. If it's too high a price then don't customize/dedicate and instead sell the item.
There are trade offs to everything in this game. If you want the extra damage a customized weapon offers then you need to sacrifice the resale value to customize. If you want to dedicate a minipet then that mini is yours and can no longer belong to anyone else's HoM. That's the tradeoff. If it's too high a price then don't customize/dedicate and instead sell the item.
Orange Milk
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by holymasamune Tender wolf returns to compete with Solange for the Sardelac crown! |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MirkoTeran What I was about to post. Its a tough competition |
If only Freaked out fish would come back, he's a good dark horse pick for the crown.
also
/NOT SIGNED
I MP I
/not signed. For basically the same reasons everyone else has already said. Really bad idea.
BlackSephir
Sardelac- providing GW players entertainment since 1965
the 55 warrior?!?
well we all make mistakes wen we first start out playing GW so i think that there should be a timer and if the wepon has been costomized at least 6 months ago than it should be able to be uncostomized but for a realy unresonable fee like 10-15k depending on if its white blue purple or gold
/signed
/signed
Jetdoc
A big /notsigned on this one. Absolutely no reason to do this, since that's the purpose of having them dedicated.
Tyla
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by holymasamune
Tender wolf returns to compete with Solange for the Sardelac crown!
/notsigned. |
Tender vs. Solange, get your popcorn...
Lycan Nibbler
sorry, so /not signed
the savage nornbear
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by holymasamune
Tender wolf returns to compete with Solange for the Sardelac crown!
/notsigned. |
zamial
/not signed
surprised? I'm not.
KTHXBYE
surprised? I'm not.
KTHXBYE
Witchblade
Now i think i understand a lil more why NPCs are asking 3 times when a confirmation is needed
Maybe this should apply to minis ...^^
Maybe this should apply to minis ...^^