Ok, there's a fundamental problem with UW...
Unfortunately, quite a few times I've seen folks INTENTIONALLY killing reapers before others in the party can get the end-chest. It's not right that these punks can just get the reaper killed before the rest of the party can get the end-chest, and then go on their merry way.
And PLEASE don't simply respond with 'well just open the chest sooner!' - this is NOT a solution as some quests require team members to kill-off monsters long after the quest registers as completed. A great example of this is the '4 Horsemen quest', where the two terras must kill off the remaining dryders so they don't kill the reaper.
Seems like the answer is either (1) not kicking out the team due to reaper-deaths AFTER completing all 10 quests (perhaps make the reapers invulnerable at this point, so they can't die??), or (2) somehow punishing the perpetrators with 'dishonorable points' (although I have no idea how the game engine would determine who killed the reaper).
Recently ANet made the change to not teleport the entire party once all 10 quests are completed. Now I say that, due to the above issue, further updates are needed to prevent inconsiderate players from preventing their party members from getting the UW end-chest.
Please /sign if you agree!
UW Change - can't be kicked once completing all 10 quests due to Reaper death
Day Trooper
robot of chaos
/sign
123chars
123chars
hubridnox320
/sign
Had this happen a couple times.
Had this happen a couple times.
Abedeus
Maybe just make it so monsters ignore Reapers once all quests are finished? Like some NPCs in FoW. Would be even explainable plot-wise - after finishing those 10 quests, Grenth regains his control in UW and monsters stop being aggressive towards his servants, so Grenth won't punish them.
obsidian ectoplasm
signed
i saw soemone lose a req9 eternal blade due to this
i saw soemone lose a req9 eternal blade due to this
RotteN
/signed for obvious reasons
There will always be people acting like total asshats
There will always be people acting like total asshats
traiss7
/sign
never had this happen to me and i dont want it to
never had this happen to me and i dont want it to
Hyper.nl
/signed
I can understand it would be quite annoying if that happened...
I can understand it would be quite annoying if that happened...
izzywish
/Signed
Happened to me loads too, very annoying.
Happened to me loads too, very annoying.
IronSheik
/signed
MisterElemonk is a great example of this
MisterElemonk is a great example of this
Alex Dimitri
/signed
that is just so lame if u left without reward after such a massive work !
that is just so lame if u left without reward after such a massive work !
Stuart444
/signed
not had this happened, and don't ever want it to happen
not had this happened, and don't ever want it to happen
I Will Heal You Ally
/signed!
I hate when this happens
I hate when this happens
phan
/notsigned ;
Don't team up with ursanfaggs then
Don't team up with ursanfaggs then
Borega
/signed
i just cant understand why ppl are doing so as they dont get anything from it
i just cant understand why ppl are doing so as they dont get anything from it
SmokingHotImolation
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phan
/notsigned ;
Don't team up with ursanfaggs then |
Im gonna /sign this.
kupp
/signed
Never happened to me as well, and never want to.
Never happened to me as well, and never want to.
Rothan Celt
/signed
for obvious reasons.
for obvious reasons.
I pwnd U
/signed for all the reasons stated above
Hermos
Hah, dude - I was in your party. :P Yes, it did suck big time for the guy who didn't get his chest. I'm Malina Alexius - just fyi. 
/sign
/sign
Flightmare
/signed
Alltough I only do elite missions with friends and alliance members, I can imagine there are ppl pugging ruining all the fun.
Alltough I only do elite missions with friends and alliance members, I can imagine there are ppl pugging ruining all the fun.
Sjeng
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phan
/notsigned ;
Don't team up with ursanfaggs then |
1) do not make this into yet another boring ursan QQ thread
2) you say all ursan users are faggs, which is insulting to say the least. worth a ban imho.
3) what the hell does this have to do with the OP in the first place?
back on topic: /signed.
chfanfiction
/signed...
I never UW but it makes no sense to allow them to die AFTER you've completed UW.
I never UW but it makes no sense to allow them to die AFTER you've completed UW.
KoKoS
Dishonor points only work in PvP me thinks.. not sure
But /signed cuz it is quite annoying..
But /signed cuz it is quite annoying..
TheodenKing
/signed
This is why I don't clear UW and FoW with puglies.
This is one of those changes I could see Anet making if enough people complain about it.
This is why I don't clear UW and FoW with puglies.
This is one of those changes I could see Anet making if enough people complain about it.
Anduin
Signed, because I can only imagine how frustrating that would be.
Baku_The_Killer
/signed
I'm sure I'll never get a good UW End Chest drop...but if it happens...won't that a stupid guy RED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GOs me.
I'm sure I'll never get a good UW End Chest drop...but if it happens...won't that a stupid guy RED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GOs me.
tichi
/signed
or atleast add options for such ppl to/report command
or atleast add options for such ppl to/report command
Shayne Hawke
Reapers should just not die if all the quests are completed.
/signed
/signed
romeus petrus
I would /sign just coz I understand its a problem for pugs. Easy solution in the mean time, only do UW with guildies/ppl you know and trust. Just like all elite areas, having random players in your team increases your chances of failing dramatically.
zelgadissan
/signed
TBH something like this hadn't even crossed my mind. I guess every time I've done the UW we just killed anything that even had a chance to kill the reaper. That totally sucks for anybody to have happen.
And like was just said, more reason why PuGs fail.
TBH something like this hadn't even crossed my mind. I guess every time I've done the UW we just killed anything that even had a chance to kill the reaper. That totally sucks for anybody to have happen.
And like was just said, more reason why PuGs fail.
Cyb3r
/signed for obvious reasons
MithranArkanere
It would even better to make each Reaper Invulnerable once you have made all quests he gives.
EmptySkull
/signed
Yeah this happened to my alliance group a while back. We had one pug. Who had a role. He didn't finish his role and went to farm. We had a few fuss at him and we got flamed. Called us noobs and such. So we had to finish his work and did as a party. But he stayed behind at labyrinth. After chest spawned he ported somewhere and brought agro into a reaper, thus killing him, thus kicking our team.
I even suggested the same thing on the other GW forum. I just wished after last quest is complete the Reaper npc would become neutral to all foes.
Yeah this happened to my alliance group a while back. We had one pug. Who had a role. He didn't finish his role and went to farm. We had a few fuss at him and we got flamed. Called us noobs and such. So we had to finish his work and did as a party. But he stayed behind at labyrinth. After chest spawned he ported somewhere and brought agro into a reaper, thus killing him, thus kicking our team.
I even suggested the same thing on the other GW forum. I just wished after last quest is complete the Reaper npc would become neutral to all foes.
DarkEnzanArikado
/signed
Saw one of my friends lose a req 11 eternal blade due to this.
Saw one of my friends lose a req 11 eternal blade due to this.
DarkGanni
/signed
I too think making them invulnerable can be the best solution. When pugging UW is always a risk.
- Ganni
I too think making them invulnerable can be the best solution. When pugging UW is always a risk.
- Ganni
Bowstring Badass
/notsigned Simply because reaper's shouldn't die anyway because you should have killed all the mobs.
joshuarodger
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bowstring Badass
/notsigned Simply because reaper's shouldn't die anyway because you should have killed all the mobs.
|
/signed
N1ghtstalker
/signed
hate patrol that kills reaper
oh and
pls give them a skillbar that fits them
not a crap bar without elite skills
make reapers able to defend themselves just in case
hate patrol that kills reaper
oh and
pls give them a skillbar that fits them
not a crap bar without elite skills
make reapers able to defend themselves just in case
Jenn
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bowstring Badass
/notsigned Simply because reaper's shouldn't die anyway because you should have killed all the mobs.
|
/signed - never happened to me, but it would be ass if it did.