Wintersday Workshop 2010

Shewmake

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Dec 2006

Alabama

Mo/D

Are the party's details still TBA?

Minami

Minami

Site Contributor

Join Date: Jul 2008

Dallas, TX. USA

Not in any guild at the moment

N/

The complete details, yes.

The date is the 22nd of January, that's a Saturday.
We're still working out the hours.

I need to catch Tzu for the time when she can be at the party to announce the winners.
She will be tallying the votes and announce them. Since I am participating in the workshop, I cannot see the results or announce them.

When we have the walk in dates for the party, I will let you guys know

Thistle Xandra

Thistle Xandra

Site Contributor

Join Date: Aug 2010

Congrats to all of you! Considering the quality of the posted winners, I bet the GW judges had a really, really hard time picking out just 20 (I had a really hard time giving my workshop votes and I bet we had a mere fraction of the ones that GW had to go through!)! As cheesy as it sounds, you all had amazing entries and all deserved to win something I honestly think the best part of the contests are these unofficial workshops (because we're working together), and I really hope no one feels discouraged and will still submit to the future contests

Minami

Minami

Site Contributor

Join Date: Jul 2008

Dallas, TX. USA

Not in any guild at the moment

N/

I agree with Thistle
Even if you didn't place in the official contest, please do come back to participate next time, especially in the Workshop! ^_^

Once I get to talk to Tzu on MSN, we will come up with an announcement regarding the workshops. Keep an eye out for that ^_^

Darcy

Darcy

Never Too Old

Join Date: Jul 2006

Rhode Island where there are no GW contests

Order of First

W/R

Congratulations to everyone who placed or got an honorable mention. And to everyone who entered also. It takes a lot to enter a piece of your art for judging.

KiyaKoreena

KiyaKoreena

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jun 2005

USA

Kirins of Holy Light

N/

Yay for upcoming party! And don't forget there are some nice Workshop prizes to be awarded still. And on a personal note: Wheee! 2nd place equals 7th contest win!

Free Hairnet

Free Hairnet

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2010

R/Mo

I spy workshop winners, yay! Way to go, guys!

Ravenhawk

Ravenhawk

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2009

Eon

Me/N

Congratulations to all the winners. All the participants did great as well! ANet should put more winner slots.

Verene

Verene

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jan 2009

[SOTA]

D/

Ohmygod.



Sentient

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Dec 2010

Philadelphia, PA

sRs

Mo/W

Aw I didn't even get honorable mention . I'll still come to the party though to meet the artists

Nemesis-of-the-Gods

Nemesis-of-the-Gods

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Nov 2010

The Mists

Guild Leader of: More than Seven Deadly Sins [Sins]

Rt/

Gratz everyone who placed.
I guess my pencil just didn't cut it for Anet.
At least I still have the Workshop results to wait for.

` Marshmallow

` Marshmallow

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: May 2009

Canadaa!

Last Friday Night [TGIF]

E/

Gz to the winnars. ; u; <333

I srsly think they should've made like.. moar prize thingies..? XD There's a lot of peices that should've placed imho * u* ...~

I'm gonna see if I can join teh party, too U:< ROAR

GeminiJuSa

GeminiJuSa

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2009

BhLd

E/Mo

EDIT: my forum thing is retarded and showed me the last entry was... not the last one I read T_T Never mind me lalalalalala *does a rickroll for myself*

Congratulations everyone from this workshop!
I'm not surprised I didn't place or win. Why should I? It's not like my entry was THAT funny anyway. I'd just be one of those you wonder "What are you doing there?" anyway. I Had fun making my entries, and I'd like to think I gained some progress in meantime

Eastern Magik

Eastern Magik

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2008

congrats to the winners

oh wow i placed, i guess those 50h+ of work paid of after all :3

too bad some of the workshop entries didn't go too well......

Tommy's

Tommy's

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Dec 2006

[Bone]

Mo/

Aww well too bad. Guess I should go for a more portrait focus next time, seems to be more popular over at ArenaNet..

Zidane, Pery, I think you 2 deserved a spot in those list more then others. But ofcourse its not all about winning

GeminiJuSa

GeminiJuSa

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2009

BhLd

E/Mo

I think it all sums up to taste when it comes to Anet's judging. I think I will keep entering contests, but mostly because I think it's fun to make an effort. Perhaps by next wintersday I'll have a comic with dwayna and grenth ;P I love making comics...

Aeronwen

Aeronwen

not so much fell as.....

Join Date: Jan 2009

UK

bone

R/

Congratualtions to those who placed

Quote:
Originally Posted by Minami View Post
Congrats everyone ^_^

As a sidenote, this was my last contest for GW Minami, I am sad about this but I am not surprised, each year there are a few Anet winners that I extremely surprised about, and I think 'but we had several workshops entries way better than that!'

Obviously appreciation of art is very subjective, but I can only assume some of the workshop enties did not make it to the Anets inbox.

Oh and Kiya did you see the Santa skills on this entry?
http://www.guildwars.com/events/cont...lts.php?pos=20
Thats in interesting idea for a bracelet
Maybe we could come up with Nolani skills ^^

Well roll on the real prizes

Tommy's

Tommy's

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Dec 2006

[Bone]

Mo/

WOW! Wait. Lol I browsed all the entries and went 'meh' as usual. Then I went studying and suddenly realised Minami's entry wasn't between them. I jumped up to check back if I was right.

So Minami, I'd just like to say.. Most undeserved. I'll go file a complaint to Anet for not including you in the prizes! Just keep in mind that Anets opinion doesn't say everything about your costume and know it was great. I at least thought it was a guaranteed win. Just sayin

Tommy's

Tommy's

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Dec 2006

[Bone]

Mo/

Haha no worries Aeronwen I won't Like Minami already stated for herself, so will this be my last official contest I think. I'd rather do some personal works next time. I'm just really pissed because I had a real fun idea for everlasting workshop thing (a bit simular to the anatomy workshopthing Ravenhawk is running, but with different themes!) which I wanted to be able to have prizes for. But sadly enough I now don't.

But I'll restrain from Guild Wars art pretty soon anyway, want to do more personal thingies. But I'll still share it with you all! *spams*

Flying Ninja Monk

Flying Ninja Monk

Academy Page

Join Date: Dec 2010

Fuzzies Anonymous [Fuzy]

Mo/

@Minami
I can't believe your's didn't win o.O
Like many people i've gone through pics and thought, wtf is that there for?
I mean , I find the first place one absolutely horrid o.O Even though it probably took ages
I honestly think yours is the best of them all, here and there
@EasternMagik:
Congrats on winning Knew you'd get there
@Koreena:
Haha do i even need to say it?
Gz for the 7th time running lol Good job!
@Tommy:
:/ I agree with aeronwen
I think your piece was epic, but sometimes its just not what they're looking for
I once entered a rl writing contest with a 700 word poem which i spent hours making
And i didn't even get in the top 10 :/ For the english section, they only really liked the writing pieces , so i know how you feel
Woulda been awesome if you got a tonic All year roundw orkshop? <3
@Zidane: Man yours is so well done, and it has the LOLS in it too >.< I can't believe its not there
22nd should hopefully be an ok date for me, provided that the hours are not too early :S
Oh and i have a really awesomle but slightly gruesom idea for next wintersday even though i'm betting there'll be no GW1 workshop as GW2 should be out by then i think :/ And i won't be able to get it from this country >.<

GeminiJuSa

GeminiJuSa

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2009

BhLd

E/Mo

Maybe arenanet doesn't want too many skilful winners, maybe it'll make their concept artists look bad? ;P

Flying Ninja Monk

Flying Ninja Monk

Academy Page

Join Date: Dec 2010

Fuzzies Anonymous [Fuzy]

Mo/

lmao gemini Good point ;p

I forgot to say
Congrats to marshmallow and verene!
*sends pic of angrily glaring but cute Chiwawa*
How dare thee not tell us, marsh? :O

Tzu

Tzu

Site Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2008

UK/norway

Order Of The Etherbloom Crown [ZEN]

Grats to all the winners, though I honestly think more of you should've placed. It's not worth dwelling on though. I'm looking forward to concluding the workshop judging so that more of you can be rightfully awarded for your efforts this year.

Now's as good a time as any to say; I think this will be my last workshop for GW1. It's getting harder and harder to set aside time, as evident by my lack of contribution and presence this year, and I don't think it will get any easier for some time. The Workshop as a GWG phenomenon is up for grabs, if anyone wants to host and organise future workshops here you can use my icons, code and award-scheme. Just PM me and I'll send it to you.
I might start the workshops up again for GW2 @ GW2G next year or the year after, but I make no solid promise of it. I hope everyone enjoyed the run so far, and that someone wants to carry on the tradition.

Minami

Minami

Site Contributor

Join Date: Jul 2008

Dallas, TX. USA

Not in any guild at the moment

N/

As I have talked to you about this in MSN Tzu, I'll be more than happy to take over the workshop. If everyone liked the way me and Perynne ran it this time, that is

If GW2 comes out in the meantime, I'll be moving over to run the Workshop there, in the GW2Guru forums.

Like I have said before, I am done entering GW(1) contests, unless something radically changes in the way the contests are run (all the things outlined in Kiya's email, to those of you who know), which I highly doubt that it would happen.
If I have some GW related piece that I made for someone else or it has been lying around for a while, I might enter it, but I won't make anything specific for GW1 contests anymore.

Everyone, thank you all very much for the kind words.
It means a lot to me.
It seems to me that every year I enter, people in the workshop seem to like my entries so much, and get angry when I don't place in the official contest.

Again, thanks for all the support you guys, see you at the party, and hopefully see you all at the next contest! Remember, the workshop will be here, waiting for you guys and your awesome art! ^_^

Verene

Verene

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jan 2009

[SOTA]

D/

Honestly, I was seriously surprised that Minami didn't win anything either. I went through all of them when I first saw they announced the winners going "but where the hell is Minami's entry?"

A lot of the honorable mentions I was a bit "...>.>" about, really. I saw a lot better from this workshop. Hell, I figured that between entries like Tommy's and Minami's and Pery's and Zidane's and Magik's, I stood no chance whatsoever.

Tzu! Aww, that's sad. I will definitely pitch in to help Minami and Perynne with the workshops, assuming they want to continue them, though.

(also...grumble grumble...scanned and emailed my form yesterday and got a "this couldn't be sent" message this morning, wtf)

` Marshmallow

` Marshmallow

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: May 2009

Canadaa!

Last Friday Night [TGIF]

E/

Flying ninja monk - XD I didn't tell anyone...because well.... idr D: I think I submitted it at like 2am one day and was all /sleepysleepy..I'll enter/post guru contest tomorrows ,_, but never did 0_0


MOAR WORKSHOP~!! Even though I tend to disappear <__<!!! But I love looking at like, stuff..thats being worked..on? (Wow I'm so bad at english/grammar stuff)

and Verene, I got that email too @___@!! -spams anet- >:U

Minami

Minami

Site Contributor

Join Date: Jul 2008

Dallas, TX. USA

Not in any guild at the moment

N/

^_^

Tzu said she might be back for GW2 workshops, so I told her I'd be happy to partner with her Easier to manage everything when you're not just going at it alone

I'd imagine once GW2 is out, the GW1 workshops will stop. I don't see many of you wanting to stick with 5 years old GW1 things when there's a whole entire new game with new stuffs in it to do artsy things about Right? ^_^

I do cross my fingers for GW2 to come out already, for several reasons

KiyaKoreena

KiyaKoreena

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jun 2005

USA

Kirins of Holy Light

N/

Looking forward to GW2 contests. :-) Time to go start reading the second book.

InfestedHydralisk

InfestedHydralisk

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2007

The Netherlands

None

R/

Congrats to everyone out there!

But in my oppinion, how much time you spent on something shouldn't matter. It's about you coming up with something new/refreshing etc.

frostkisses

frostkisses

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Aug 2007

Wisconsin

Cerberus Guardians of the [GATE]

E/

Congrats to those that placed!

Unfortunately I dont think more than 3 of the winners other than the guru peeps really even made me think "wow thats cool and different they definately deserved it." lol with as poor as my drawing was, really makes me mad I didnt enter, I could have won!
But there really is no point in dwelling on it. I'm sure they review countless submissions, and if it wasnt what they were looking for then it wasnt what they were looking for. Cant win em all.

Tzu I'm sad you'll not be hosting any more workshops, but I think Pery and Minami did a great job in your place.

Yes, rumors are rumors, but I've been seeing a lot of "preorders" for GW2 around the end of December. So maybe a GW2 themed wintersday would be neat for this years. Hopefully by then we'll have some more videos/artwork to go off of. Maybe even a beta

novawhiz

novawhiz

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2006

A/

Congrats to everyone!!

Glad to see a lot of Drawings this year. Dont really get how second place embodies wintersday but anyway Congrats. Wish i had time this year to enter but o well

Verene

Verene

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jan 2009

[SOTA]

D/

Quote:
Originally Posted by frostkisses View Post
Congrats to those that placed!

Unfortunately I dont think more than 3 of the winners other than the guru peeps really even made me think "wow thats cool and different they definately deserved it." lol with as poor as my drawing was, really makes me mad I didnt enter, I could have won!
But there really is no point in dwelling on it. I'm sure they review countless submissions, and if it wasnt what they were looking for then it wasnt what they were looking for. Cant win em all.

Tzu I'm sad you'll not be hosting any more workshops, but I think Pery and Minami did a great job in your place.

Yes, rumors are rumors, but I've been seeing a lot of "preorders" for GW2 around the end of December. So maybe a GW2 themed wintersday would be neat for this years. Hopefully by then we'll have some more videos/artwork to go off of. Maybe even a beta I've had GW2 preordered for a year and a half (since the day we started taking reserves on it at work) really doesn't mean anything. Certainly hope it comes out this year though!

Also, good god, I'm hiding offline while playing GW for a bit, I think >.>

frostkisses

frostkisses

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Aug 2007

Wisconsin

Cerberus Guardians of the [GATE]

E/

oh i know its been on preorder for a long time, but seeing as they're actually showing progress now i would tend to believe a preorder a bit more after seeing it as opposed to a year ago when they werent really releasing anything about the game. but i'm not getting my hopes up for anything. as anet likes to say..."it'll be done when its done" -.-'

InfestedHydralisk

InfestedHydralisk

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2007

The Netherlands

None

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by frostkisses View Post
"it'll be done when its done" -.-' They stole that line from Blizzard.

@Satomz; I haven't checked out your entry I think. But I don't know if they accept music, don't think I ever saw one before too.

Charlie Dayman

Charlie Dayman

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Apr 2009

Trifecta Luminati [TRI]

W/

Congrats to all the winners! I also agree that more of you definitely should have placed. Frankly, I'm quite surprised Mina's costume wasn't rewarded at least an HM.

In any case, nice work all around.

@Tzu: That's a bummer to hear. Though we hope you do manage to swing by these parts every so often.