FoW Groups
Kybos
Why do most pug FoW groups insist on two warriors?
If its not enought that most W/Mo's have no clue what stances are and they think that their DPS is better than nukers - why do groups need two of them?
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows:
WoH Monk
Bonder Monk
Battery Necro
SS Necro
W/Me Stance Warrior
JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger
Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf.
What do you guys think?
If its not enought that most W/Mo's have no clue what stances are and they think that their DPS is better than nukers - why do groups need two of them?
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows:
WoH Monk
Bonder Monk
Battery Necro
SS Necro
W/Me Stance Warrior
JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger
Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf.
What do you guys think?
Nero
i don't think there is an 'ideal' group in any area, anything is possible with any combination of people.
for example: when i beat Hell's Precipe, the pug i joined was 6 warriors (7 total after i joined) and 1 ranger, and we beat it just fine, with no monks at all.
for example: when i beat Hell's Precipe, the pug i joined was 6 warriors (7 total after i joined) and 1 ranger, and we beat it just fine, with no monks at all.
Kybos
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nero
i don't think there is an 'ideal' group in any area, anything is possible with any combination of people.
for example: when i beat Hell's Precipe, the pug i joined was 6 warriors (7 total after i joined) and 1 ranger, and we beat it just fine, with no monks at all. Your experience is most likely the exception and not the rule. It's nothing against you, but a good warrior is a rarity.
for example: when i beat Hell's Precipe, the pug i joined was 6 warriors (7 total after i joined) and 1 ranger, and we beat it just fine, with no monks at all. Your experience is most likely the exception and not the rule. It's nothing against you, but a good warrior is a rarity.
Ira Blinks
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
Quote: they think that their DPS is better than nukers - why do groups need two of them? unfortunately they are correct at this point, but... but dps isnt why eles are still somewhat useful. That said i saw so many s**ty dps eles that call themselves nukers, it makes me want to cry.
Quote:
Backup for when one of them /ragequits. Which always happens.
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows: WoH Monk Bonder Monk Battery Necro SS Necro W/Me Stance Warrior JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf. What do you guys think? i think you confused ideal _forgemaster_ group with ideal fow group. This group will get fryed in burning forest and won't even have balls to try wailing lord. But you right, shadows and cave spiders are easily disposed with just SS and some iterrupts to keep monks quiet. Kybos
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ira Blinks
i think you confused ideal _forgemaster_ group with ideal fow group. This group will get fryed in burning forest and won't even have balls to try wailing lord. But you right, shadows and cave spiders are easily disposed with just SS and some iterrupts to keep monks quiet.
I was in a decent FoW group the other night where we had a similar set up, minus the WoH monk. We did fine with wailing lord but didnt attempt to do burning forest.
What would the ideal FoW group be then? tuperwho
Prob. just my mesmer bias talking here, but no hex dealing or removal? How you gonna deal with all the beast's SS and all the mesmers?
My guild rocks it with: bonder healer tank SS necro who does battery duties, also (yeah, he's the $#!^) nuker Me (dom. and insp. memser) for interrupt, damage, and hex removal and 2 spots for anything else Francis Crawford
I've only been in FoW once, in a PUG a few days ago. When we got to the armor crafter we took a bathroom break. One player never returned -- warrior.
I'm glad we had two warriors in the group when we started. onilink
As pointed out by Francis, I think most Pugs want two tanks just in case one of them is a complete noob, which happens quite often.
Effendi Westland
Cleared it all a few times, group setup usually somthing like this:
Warrior SS/enfeebling blood necro 2x monk (usually 2x healer) ranger (barrage/interrupt) mesmer (domination/fast cast restore life) nuker and the 7th depends heavily on what we have available, another nuker, another ranger, perhaps a battery or another warrior. When everybody is experienced with it the group build doesn't matter that much, just make sure you have enough interrupts and a warrior who understands aggro. (we never do the booktrick) PS recently went in with a Broad Head Arrow ranger with epidemic... made my job as a interrupting mesmer a bit overkill.... dunno what will happen when we bring a BHA and a barrage ranger.... Jas D
When I do go to fow with a group (Which is rare, I don't like doing stuff as a group considering there's a really good chance I won't get a decent group), I perfer one warrior so he/she can take the whole aggro, and nothing can be broken as easily. More than one warrior seems useless to me.
Ronin Rangerin
How do you get to Fow? Ive beaten the whole game but still dont have it
Zui
As most failed FoW/UW groups can attest to, having multiple players be able to cover the role of another player is key. Unless you're going with people you know are compitent, except at least 3/8 of your PUG to be incompitent, leave, never load, take quests that they're not supposed to(like the first quest from the reaper of the labrynth...) or in some other way manage to bring the group down/do nothing.
It's not the warriors, it's the "lone hero" mentality types that see themselvs pwning everything and everyone that you have to watch out for... The majority of which in PvE happen to be warriors. koneko
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
|
Quote:
How do you get to Fow? Ive beaten the whole game but still dont have it
http://www.guildwiki.org/wiki/Fissure_of_woe
Avarre
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
If its not enought that most W/Mo's have no clue what stances are and they think that their DPS is better than nukers - why do groups need two of them?
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows:
WoH Monk
Bonder Monk
Battery Necro
SS Necro
W/Me Stance Warrior
JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger
Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf.
What do you guys think?
1 Necromancer / Monk
1 Monk / Ranger
1 Warrior / Monk
That is all

Quote:
I was just about to mention that.
SS necro who does battery duties, also (yeah, he's the $#!^)
SS and batterizing are a total of two skills, three if you use AtB for additional damage. Not exactly that legendary ![]() Juicey Shake
The build you outlined is pretty much exactly how I went down there last night with some friends [to get one friend of mine pants and feet]
Me woh'ing, someone bonding. A w/me stance tank [1 seed and I never had to glance at him again ^_^], a r/mo JI barrager, a R/x punishing/savage/dist shot int'er, two meteor shower / rodg invocation etc nukers, and a ss/battery nec who err'd out on the second group upon entering. We flawlessed to the forgemaster & seeds quest, and then I had to go. Only took about 40 minutes, I think. One tank was all we needed, but he was insanely good at holding his aggro / taking it back o.X, and this was more friends of friends rather than pug. striderkaaru
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows:
WoH Monk Bonder Monk Battery Necro SS Necro W/Me Stance Warrior JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf. What do you guys think? if you really think that having the warrior go with a stance build is ideal in fow, then i would seriously suggest reconsidering your build. also, a battery is completely unnecessary if your monks know how to manage their own energy. don't criticize other people if your build is just as questionable. QuixotesGhost
Quote:
Originally Posted by striderkaaru
don't criticize other people if your build is just as questionable. |
Stances aren't what you want to rely on as a warrior in the Fissure. Skellies pack wild blow. If you don't have a lot of experience with a class you should really refrain from telling others how to play it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
I figure that the ideal FoW Group is as follows:
WoH Monk Bonder Monk Battery Necro SS Necro W/Me Stance Warrior JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger Nuker x2 - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf. What do you guys think? I'd swap the W/Me stance tank for a strength-based Warrior built around Doylak and "Watch Yourself". Pull out one of the nukers for another JI Barrage /Interupt Ranger and swap the Battery necro for a Choking Gas/Trapper ranger. So... WoH Monk Bonder Monk SS Necro W/* Doylak Warrior 2 x JI Barrage/Interrupt Ranger Choking Gas/Trapper Ranger Nuker - Meteor Shower only, since the AOE nerf. Go ranger heavy next time you go to the FoW. You won't regret it. Jiao Yang
I normally only do my FoW runs with a group of friends.. but the warrior we run (normally me) is a W/E with obsidian flesh {E}, armour of earth, dolyak sig and stances.
coldplay
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jiao Yang
I normally only do my FoW runs with a group of friends.. but the warrior we run (normally me) is a W/E with obsidian flesh {E}, armour of earth, dolyak sig and stances.
pretty good warrior build for book trick. I wish I can get in a group with a warrior like this.
Ajantis
Stances are useless on the plains.. Wild Blow ftw
![]() I go flurry/galrath/final/watch yourself/dolyak signet/defy pain/for great justice/rebirth. 800hp and +80 armor is enough, this way I can also deal some damage (I don't carry books) Star Alfur
I believe you, OP, were JI/Barrager in my Fissure group last night ... I agree with you not needing but only one warrior, but in that set up, I had my reasons. One of our warriors wasn't that experienced, so I felt we'd be safer with another warrior, and the lesser experienced not being the main tank.
And if I've totally mistaken you for someone else, (I was also using ranger, ign = Little Lost Child) Allanon Dark
There really is no ideal FoW group. A battery nec is really not all that necessary. When i go to FoW i usually go as a monk and almost never need a BR. I will not post my build but only two of my skills are over 5 energy, and one of those two is a rez spell. The other things that stop most people from getting far is that there is almost no condition/hex removal whatsoever. I always incorporate it into my build no matter what, it always helps keep the group alive a lot longer.
Now while a stance tank is good for "Booking" it will not get you far at all in the Burning or Wailing Forest. It takes skill to make a good War for FoW that not only can "Book it" but can also just be a tank in the other areas as well and still live to tell about it. Fire Childe
The party makeup is completely flexible and there is no 'ideal' party formation. However, regardless of the mix of classes you have in your group you just to ensure you have the following covered:
1) Hex strips. You want more than 1 person stripping hexes and you should sort out a system of calling hexes to be removed, either in game or over voice comm. Mark of Pain, Iron Mists, Deep Freeze and Empathy, Mark of Rodgort are problem hexes. Alot of trigger happy, gungo fissure pick ups I have been in have also been especially good at destroying themselves by attacking with Spiteful Spirit on them. Inspired Hex is a great spell to have along on any character because with very little inspiration magic, it pays for itself, removes a hex from an ally and allows you to cast that hex. Even better if you are a domination mesmer or curses necro. 2) Interrupt. You can use a migraine mesmer for this purpose. Or not. My W/Me fissure build is very mobile and has 4 interrupts with a bit of direct damage on the side. Power drain is also great because its cheap and pays for itself. And then some. You can use it in conjunction with other spells for energy management too. Interrupt is pretty nice to have because alot of the big hitting creatures in fissure use spells with really slow cast times. Barrage, Firestorm, Fireball, Imolate, Spiteful Spirit, Mark of Pain, Empathy, Heal Area, Ressurect, Iron Mists, Mark of Rodgort, Meteor Shower, Healing Signet, Troll Unguent and all spirits are all really easy to interrupt. There are too many creatures in fissure whose damage dealing and self healing is reliant on slow casting spells. 3) Physical and Elemental protection. You need not have the mesmer skills physical and elemental resistance although, anything that increases your armour against these damage types is extremely helpful. Especially if you put yourself on the front line. Any armour increasing skills that dont adversely effect your movement are extremely helpful - such as Watch Yourself! and to some extent Armour of Earth (with high enough Earth Magic). Since alot of mobs are on patrol routes, and given that some people in your group may be a bit tardy and accidentally, you know, set one off - its nice to have the mobility to be able to retreat to a safe area and regroup. Knowing when to run is pretty important since I see too many groups accidentally take on 3 or 4 mobs in one go and stick around fighting when they KNOW they are going to die. Thats just silly. If you use the book trick then you probably want some kind of tank that can soak up a hell load of damage but isnt too reliant on protective enchantments or stances. Since both can be killed fairly easily by certain fissure mobs. Use 4 ranger/mesmers if you want. or 4 warrior/elementalists. It doesnt really matter so long as you can keep the hexes off you, stop the big spells from getting cast and can handle a fair bit of elemental damage whilst also having a few ways of shutting down some of the melee annoyances like shadow warriors, abyssals and skeles. Its pretty straight forward if you can at least manage that. A W/Me build that I frequently use in fissure is: Disrupting Chop Executioner's Strike Eviscerate Flurry Inspired Hex Power Spike Distracting Blow Power Drain Sometimes I sub out Elemental or Physical Resistance for Power Spike. It depends on whether there is someone else in the group on interrupt duty. Typically I can lock down a single target pretty easily and I typically like to call targets. I usually play this fairly aggressively and find alot of pick up groups are surprised that I generally dont stance tank in fissure. Energy isnt a problem on this build. And if a hex slips through the interrupt you can always remove it and gain more energy for another interrupt using inspired hex. Truth be told, there are enough mobile, mixed mobs in fissure with a wide enough range of skills and damage sources to make stance tanking difficult at best without using the book trick. Controlling aggro in fissure is awkward because of this. Eaimirth Etaivella
1 ss necro
1 shatter hex/surge mesmer 1 warrior 1 monk can easily clear fow in a few hours, bring essence bond Haggard
Quote:
Originally Posted by Francis Crawford
One player never returned -- warrior.
lol! towel racks get more and more lethal with every passing week.
Avarre
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eaimirth Etaivella
1 ss necro
1 shatter hex/surge mesmer 1 warrior 1 monk can easily clear fow in a few hours, bring essence bond Drop the surge mesmer, more drops I don't really like optimizing a FoW group, because FoW isn't exactly hard... with almost any combination, you can do well. It's only in small teams you need to care about what each person does. Linsys
IMO.... FOW is very eazy.... if ur gonna run a 7-8 man team here is what I would suggest:
1 Warrior (Doylac, Armor Of Eart etc...) 2 Heal Monks (Healing Hands, WoH is crap is FoW or One Healer / One Bonder) 2 Barrage / Interrupt Rangers (one with Symbiosis) 1 Mesmer 1 SS Necro 1 Ele (Anything But AoE Firestorm Ele) When I first started to run FoW with 8 man teams (now I run 4-5 man runs since guildies always want to go) I would always bring symbiosis not many people would really know the effectiveness of symbiosis tilll the warriors health would go up I think symbiosis with a bonder makes FoW a lot easier, gives more room for the warrior to run into agro solo to gain 100% agro.. pluss its just fun to bring symbiosis! But in the end most any build with some heals and some dmg and a tank will clear FoW.... period... none of the quests are hard once u've done them 100x Eaimirth Etaivella
Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
Drop the surge mesmer, more drops
I don't really like optimizing a FoW group, because FoW isn't exactly hard... with almost any combination, you can do well. It's only in small teams you need to care about what each person does. Hmm...Lets bring two teams of 4 and clear the whole thing twice as quickly ^_^; also have a backup if one group wipes. Kybos
Quote:
Originally Posted by striderkaaru
if you really think that having the warrior go with a stance build is ideal in fow, then i would seriously suggest reconsidering your build. also, a battery is completely unnecessary if your monks know how to manage their own energy.
don't criticize other people if your build is just as questionable. Since I did not list the warrior build that I had in mind, I am not sure why you would criticize my post. The only stance in my build is physical resist, so I guess I should have rephrased. Battery is completely useless for the most part; however, as you said, the monks need to know how to manage their energy. Lastly, the purpose of my post was to see what the community thought about FoW builds, not to criticize any types of groups. Thank you everyone, for your feedback. Kybos
Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
Ideal FoW group =
1 Necromancer / Monk 1 Monk / Ranger 1 Warrior / Monk That is all ![]() Avarre
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kybos
Did you guys ever release your three man FoW build? I remember the post, but I wasn't sure if you disclosed your skill bars.
Yes, we did. For ease of reference:
W/Mo Skull crack {E}, Galrath Slash, Final Thrust, Dolyak Signet, Healing Signet, Watch yourself, Smite hex, Flurry Mo/R Spell Breaker {E}, Guardian, Mend Condition, Reversal of Fortune, Smite hex, Signet of Devotion, Essence Bond, Divine Boon N/Mo Spiteful Spirit {E}, Awaken The Blood, Defile Flesh, Barbs, Smite Hex, Rebirth, Well of Blood (not actually needed), Desecrate Enchantments Cherno
Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
Yes, we did. For ease of reference:
W/Mo Skull crack {E}, Galrath Slash, Final Thrust, Dolyak Signet, Healing Signet, Watch yourself, Smite hex, Flurry Mo/R Spell Breaker {E}, Guardian, Mend Condition, Reversal of Fortune, Smite hex, Signet of Devotion, Essence Bond, Divine Boon N/Mo Spiteful Spirit {E}, Awaken The Blood, Defile Flesh, Barbs, Smite Hex, Rebirth, Well of Blood (not actually needed), Desecrate Enchantments I must have missed the thread where you guys talked about your build, so forgive me if I ask things that were already covered. Why is the Monk a Ranger secondary? Is it also intentional that the monk has no res? Not that it is always the monks job, just find it strange and I see that the necro does have rebirth. Star Alfur
Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
Yes, we did. For ease of reference:
W/Mo Skull crack {E}, Galrath Slash, Final Thrust, Dolyak Signet, Healing Signet, Watch yourself, Smite hex, Flurry Mo/R Spell Breaker {E}, Guardian, Mend Condition, Reversal of Fortune, Smite hex, Signet of Devotion, Essence Bond, Divine Boon N/Mo Spiteful Spirit {E}, Awaken The Blood, Defile Flesh, Barbs, Smite Hex, Rebirth, Well of Blood (not actually needed), Desecrate Enchantments Very similar to the 3-Man set up I work with ... I'll have to give yours a try. Avarre
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cherno
Why is the Monk a Ranger secondary? Is it also intentional that the monk has no res? Not that it is always the monks job, just find it strange and I see that the necro does have rebirth. Because Monk/Ranger is sexy. It's the necro's (my) job to res because the monk needs all his skills, and I've never died in FoW (unless last down). I often use a shield and +5 wand to ensure this. In all honesty, we only need res when there is a collosal error of aggro. In this case, I'd prefer to be able to res with monk keeping me alive Originally we brought no res whatsoever, then I tweaked the necro to N/Mo for hex removal (all 3 of us remove transfer on ourselves) and res. NJudson
I'm a FOW noob and just got into it for the first time last night. I was using my necro as a SS/Battery. I also play a ranger, monk and warrior, but I decided to take necro into FOW though. I really didn't know what to expect so I just kinda tried to play it smart and "follow the leader" sort of thing. Unfortunately, 1 monk dropped very early and an elem went afk. We were doing ok for a little bit but got overran. The six of us left were:
1 warrior 1 monk healer 1 55 monk 1 elementalist 1 ranger 1 necro (me) I've been reading some of the group types and stuff here and wanted to ask some questions. What is a JI barrager? I'm assuming its Judges Insight Barrager, but not sure. Since I play a necro, ranger, warrior and monk then what are the typical skill sets people take into FOW with these classes. Are enchantments good or bad here? I've been playing the standard BP ranger in tombs and 5-man BP ranger in SF, but I was wondering if those BP groups work in FOW. I'm assuming not since it appears that a MM may not be too terribly effective there. Anyway, thanks for any advice for this poor ol' FOW newb. ![]() Munanko Roha
I wonder what's the problem with 2 warriors.
In an 8 persons party there's no need to tank in any way, warriors can dedicate themselves to their true meaning, dealing damage while monks heal, nukers nuke and rangers interrupt. There is no perfect build for FoW, simply because FoW is extremely easy to clear with any kind of build, the only thing needed is a little bit of skill. So without skill a warrior would be useless, but so would be the monk and the nuker...what's the point of this thread? Anarion Silverhand
You do realize this thread was made a looong time ago, right?
Munanko Roha
Lol I saw hust the last post's date. Anyway the question remains unchanged: what was the point of this thread?
Anarion Silverhand
I don't get what you don't understand...
The creater of the thread was asking what the optimal fow team build was. Get it? Yanman.be
Now where is that screenshot...
We cleared everything. |