I just read this whole thread through. Very interesting discussion, guys.
I think this is a bit of an issue, Anet's lore on the charr has left us on the edge pondering what the facts are that fill in the gaps.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eldin
I'm not sure if this was said already, but think of it like this:
1) The charr worship the titans, and are their Gods. How on earth did they encounter them in the past is beyond me.
2) Perhaps the charr know of the prophecy. The titans most likely gave them the power to start the searing (if they already had such power they would have blown Ascalon to pieces some time ago). The charr had used the powers to intentionally create the searing. Thusly, they drove the chosen into the Nolani Academy mission, and thusly, the searing created a chain reaction that ended with the chosen being led by the Lich/Vizier Khilbron to the Ring of Fire to unleash their Gods.
3) The second-in-command charr are the charr lords, the third-in-command...well, do you remember in pre-searing, north of the wall, you can travel to the fire shrine that the charr used to conjure the searing? I think all those bosses there are the third-in-command, think of it as a High Council or the Elite Magi, or something of the sort.
4) The lich simply wanted to use the titans to rule Tyria. Not much relevancy there to that of the charr.
5) Vizier Khilbron most likely, as stated above, did intentionally create The Cataclysm. He was probably very aware that the dark magic from such powerful spells would be enough to be so unholy and...well...evil, that it would cause those killed to never find rest, bringing them back as undead.
6) The enchanted are just magical, animated sets of armor and weaponry, brought to "life" by the Forgotten, since they are mainly spellcasters, they had no chance at any melee/archery, hence the need to create them. Similar story with the Mursaat. Due to their inability to excel at much not related to magic, they animated jade and weapons to create Armors/Bows. Ever notice many jade bosses have Cairn in the name? (To name a few, Cairn the Troubling, Cairn the Smug) Maybe Cairn is a popular name...or maybe it's Mursaat-lingo for something like "elite combatant"?
7) The Mursaat, like the lich, don't really care much about what the Charr do with the Titans. They are one of the few races (next to the seers and charr) to know of the prophecy in full detail, and it says they will be destroyed by the Titans. Thusly, they must slaughter those destined to unleash the Titans and assure their doom. Thanks to Saul D'Alessio, the White Mantle worship the Mursaat, so they use them as pawns to do all the chosen-killing for them. The Mursaat prefer to be in hiding, their villages are deep in the jungle, and they did not show themselves until it was truly necessary for them to get involved (after the Crystal Desert, the Chosen have gained so much power and are getting so close that they, themselves, must help attempt to stop them).
|
As far as the issue is concerned, the theory in this post is similar to what I believe. However, there are still several unanswered questions:
1) How did the Charr cross the Shiverpeaks to Kryta and make it past the Deldrimor Dwarves?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
The Charr, as far as I can discern, all came down from the north. They probably went north of the Shiverpeaks to reach Kryta, as it mentions the Mantle drove them back into the north.
|
If this is true, surely then, the edges of the map that we see in the game are not in fact the edges of the world, and so there is land that stretches north, above the Shiverpeaks.
I read something somewhere a while ago, and went looking for it ingame and in the manual just now. Either it has been deleted, changed, it was my imagination, or I just didn't find it, but I believe it was somewhere along these lines:
'There are two ways to cross the Shiverpeaks. One is Borlis Pass, the other is much farther north, deep in Charr territory.'
When I went searching, the NPCs in the area made no mention of this, but instead they talked of two passes, those being Borlis Pass, and the one further north that heads over Anvil Rock, guarded heavily by Stone Summit.
Confusing.
2) Which way did the Charr go to reach Orr?
The thing is, in-game, after the Searing, you don't actually see very many Charr below the wall. Did they sweep through in those 'two years' between when we were in the Academy Mission and arriving outside the shattered Ascalon City? That could make sense.
The other theory would be that they flanked Ascalon on its eastern edge - but there is no sign of that in Pockmark Flats. They couldn't have gone round the west side, as Rin was still holding against them.
And after that...head down the map from Ascalon. You reach a sort of 'wall of mountains' separating the grey land of Ascalon from the creamy land of the Crystal Desert. Did the Charr head through some kind of tunnel through this wall? And then...did they head through the Crystal Desert itself? There is no evidence I have seen in-game to prove this, I think it is highly unlikely. The only way they could have gone is along the northern, slightly greener, more passable coastline along to Orr. And there, they were wiped out.
3)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cirian
It still doesn't explain how the Charr first met the Titans though... the only thing I can think of is that they could summon them at some point? Can they still summon Titans? Hmmm
|
So...where did the Charr first encounter or come into knowing of the Titans? Did some godly being visit them, and tell them about the titans? Did a titan pop in for a chat through a portal? Did they see the titans in action? Or did they just have sense in their brain from the beginning that the Titans existed, and worshipped them?
And furthermore...who created the Charr in the first place? Surely if the gods made all of Tyria...they would have favoured the great human nations rather than this horde of beasts? Or did they just create a few Charr and leave them to evolve? Or did they create them with the intention of disturbing the human nations?
Regardless of these questions, this is extremely interesting. Keep it up, hopefully from this discussion we can solve these mysteries.