Guild Wars Guru

Detailed Second Birthday Present Poll

3 pages • Page 3
t
tre_peter
Academy Page
• #41
A new skill (PvE only), that is super-powerful and godly. (So the character gets to go through games easier). Put farming restrictions on it or something (like no drops when using it).

I'd love to click a button and nuke everything, would be highly satisfying. I'd just walk around RoT getting revenge.

I know it is very unrealistic, I'm just dreaming. (Though I think the skill idea is good, along the lines of the lightbringer skills).
g
greendc27
Frost Gate Guardian
• #42
I personally like the idea of a title like veteran or something. It wouldn't appect the game at all, would probably be easy for them to put in and is still something not everyone would have. I'm sure some people would complain about it affecting the KOABD title but if you've had a character that long chances are you've already got a good start on it.
leeky baby
leeky baby
Desert Nomad
• #43
i think the token/book/amulet idea like u get at the end of fractions anf nf is the best idea to choose a new weapon
Ferret
Ferret
Elite Guru
• #44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaile Gray
Once again and to clarify, since some seem to think we've said more than we've said, the message in our initial casual question (not a poll, you'll note) was not to say, "The Second Birthday Present will be miniatures." We have only asked what miniatures would be desired if we do offer those as the gift or -- consider this! -- if we add more for other purposes.

And just to clarify, some of the ideas in this poll are do-able, some are not. I only caution that we all take an open-minded approach, so that no one gets locked into a certain notion and cannot see the value of any other.

Simple message there. I hope no one is confused or concerned about it. Thanks for reading.
Thanks for the clarification Gaile and point noted. It's nice to see you taking an active role in this poll and i'm sorry that some people seemed to have a negative approach to your comments.

They have been helpful and i'm glad that you have at least given this poll some serious consideration.

Much appreciated,

Ferret
Ferret
Ferret
Elite Guru
• #45
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dont Mess WithMe
I really wish people would realize these are all extras ANET gives us, not because THEY HAVE TO, but because THEY WANT TO. Be grateful and happy with what you get, enjoy it, and have fun, instead of complaining about it.
Please read my initial post in detail and you will see that i have already said as much, but it is only thorugh means such as this that Gaile and other at ANet get to hear what regular players would like to se in game. This does not mean that this is a demand or that if it doesnt happen then ANet are bad, but a set of ideas and their popularity...or not in some cases.

I thank you for giving your opinion on the matter and your point has been noted.
V
Viruzzz
Krytan Explorer
• #46
I voted other, but in truth i would like almost any of them except for mini-pets.
It just screams "easy way out" in every way.

It's what they do for everything now. every event, every special prize.
and because of that, it will be almost impossible to ever get a complete set of them as they are releasing new ones every couple of weeks on average.

And if you do go for mini-pets which you probably will, then at least give us a chance to chose which one we actually want. don't give us something random. please.

think of it as getting someone a gift card instead of a random video game that the person might or might not like
arcanemacabre
arcanemacabre
Grotto Attendant
• #47
Disguises, definately. Should be easy to program, since there is already disguises in the game (Candy Corn, Elves, Corsair Disguise, Kournan Soldier Disguise, Wurm). Just need to make it an unlimited use "Double-click to use, Double-click again to put away"-style item that's tradeable, like minipets.

Plus, it's just so darn cool. I'd much rather have that than a mini, aura, wings, or anything else on that list.
u
unknown1
Krytan Explorer
• #48
disguises please ... i picked the last one for disguises
Eldin
Eldin
Forge Runner
• #49
I vote for the aura/visual effect. It's like the CE Divine Aura. Great way to flash your seniority, without taking up inventory space or being too dull.
ShadowStorm
ShadowStorm
Wilds Pathfinder
• #50
I vote for Disguises. It's realistic. They already have items that can change a player's appearance (Transmogrifier Tonics and Yuletide Tonics). And I understand completely that certain animations have not yet been programmed into the game for a lot of the enemy models. Solution A: Make them only useable within outposts. That way, all they'd have to program would be a few emotes. Solution B: Disable all skills and attacks while in your disguise. What animations are there that don't require the activation of a skill or the command to attack, save emotes? (Moving from point A to point B has already been programmed into the game for literally every model in the game)

So, in Conclusion: Vote for Disguises
Hockster
Hockster
Banned
• #51
The ability to have seven heroes in my group. Barring that, skill selection for the hench. What idiot thought Charge was a good idea for most of the warriors?
G
Gustin
Academy Page
• #52
actually I love the warrior henchies using Charge. Helps speed things up, esspecially if I'm doing some map uncoverage for cartographer title...but that's off topic.

I wouldn't mind disguises either. Seems like a great alternative to minipets and a lot funner and easy to implement.
Ashleigh McMahon
Ashleigh McMahon
Site Contributor
• #53
I'd like to see something that nobody can buy into.

Minipets for example - great - but I don't like the way people could buy into them.

I voted for the veteran title - as it's one of the few things that people cannot buy into.

One thing I DO NOT want is ascetics/items that make people jealous. I have fell victim in the past where I was made very jealous over something I could not obtain soon/at all.
I sound like i'm contradicting myself - but let me explain.

-A title is just something to show that you have had that character since day 1 (or 2 years -post 28April). Nothing too big or to small. (Shouldn't count for PKM or KoABD)
-Something like a 1337 set of max armor that only veterans have access to would be over the top- It would make many players jealous and sometimes jealousy leads to leaving games.


I hope you understand my point
-Ashleigh

Important Edit to Gaile: Will there be any love for 'account is 2 years old?' I've had the game since before day 1 but only one of my characters is 24 months old. (Probably 2 days less than 24 months as of 28th April due to remake)
kimahri
kimahri
Lion's Arch Merchant
• #54
I voted on a title but now that I see Hair Change Token as a alternative I think I should have voted for that one, I need one of those since my ele's FoW set will cute through his hair .
NeHoMaR
NeHoMaR
Desert Nomad
• #55
The title will be perfect for me. But if added, it must show in 1 year characters too.

Veteran (1) / 1 year.
Fierce Veteran (2) / 2 years.
Mighty Veteran (3) / 3 years.

.. or whatever another name, I don't care to much about the name of the title.

Anyway, the 2 years "gift" could be anything; The title idea is an add-on (not the gift)
Marth Reynolds
Marth Reynolds
Wilds Pathfinder
• #56
Hmm a token or probaly some signet of capture armor wich can duplicate a armor worn by a humanoid enemy of your class?

Cough White Mantle Knights kuch
NeHoMaR
NeHoMaR
Desert Nomad
• #57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marth Reynolds
Hmm a token or probaly some signet of capture armor wich can duplicate a armor worn by a humanoid enemy of your class?

Cough White Mantle Knights kuch
Nah, I want a helmet like in your avatar
actionjack
actionjack
Furnace Stoker
• #58
What about a mini-mini pet for your mini-pet?
Diddy bow
Diddy bow
Furnace Stoker
• #59
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaile Gray
I fully support your right to create and vote in a poll, and your interest in doing so. But I cannot help but mention that many of the requests in that poll are truly not possible as birthday presents. We are working on... other things. Those... other things mean that team members are assigned to significant, time-consuming, and extremely valuable tasks. We must focus on the future while supporting the present, and the presents, too.

So while I appreciate the thoughts behind many of these excellent ideas, they are, unfortunately, unrealistic requests and will not be possible as a 2nd birthday present. That is not because we don't want to give them, but because (1) we have time constraints that would not allow their implementation by April 28th, (2) they are features or elements that we intend or hope to offer all players, not just birthday celebrants, or (3) they demand too many resources that are, for the good of the game and the good for the entire playerbase, best focused elsewhere.

I hope this note isn't discouraging -- that's not at all my intention! I'm offering these words only to let you know about some of the realities that we face -- as devs and as players -- and to ask for your support. Player polls are great, and they do help us learn a lot, as long as "wish" doesn't become "demand" or "unfulfilled promise." Thanks for understanding.

there is always birthday 3 . IMO the weapon idea is the best ONLY if its customised!
LifeInfusion
LifeInfusion
Grotto Attendant
• #60
Nothing.
People should stop expecting things to be handed to them.