24 Jun 2008 at 02:00 - 232
@Stockholm: You argue that all the games sold and active members mean it's a good game? Hellgate:London hit record sales on its release in Korea, and I don't think anyone would argue that is a worthy successor to Diablo 2.
As far as listening to the forums, it isn't from blind faith that the opinions given on the forums are God. How else would you suggest they get opinions of people playing the game: on General Chat? A read of LA AD1 shows the huge fail of that idea. A "forum" is where people meet to discuss public business, or in the case of GW, Guild Wars business. As mentioned before, the devs come on with their own accounts to guru and GWO to test the waters. You will see a lot of correlation, if you read them, between certain buffs and nerfs and opinions voiced on the forums. It's arguable that the skill split and PvE skills were from opinions voiced about the affects of PvP adjustments on PvE. The devs don't have time enough to play this game long enough to see how well things work over time. Forums give them a window into the game, without affecting time spent doing their job: keeping the game working.
The "vocal minority" are also the ones who are the best word of mouth to advance a game. If a sizable group of that minority has a negative view, or if you don't listen to that group, they will have a low opinion of the next thing you produce. When you go into something with a negative view, that affects what you see. People are just voicing that they feel the direction a part of the game, PvE, has taken has changed the structure of the game from what got them interested in the game. The whole part of the PvE side, before, was to build a character up with skills and training, going through a paced storyline, to a level which they would be ready to start in PvP. You can't say PvE challenges you that way, now.
That being said, yeah, we voice our disappointments on how the game has gone, and post in this thread our disagreements, but we all know, if we're honest, that Anet has created their niche out of a simple formula:free to play. They don't need to create a game better than any out there. If it's decent, the animation is good, and it looks pretty, they will SELL GAMES. In large numbers. We're lucky they have enough of a conscience to have CR that post regular on the forums and listen(whatever your opinion of the later). The new game will be free to play, probably start out all in Tyria, and expand, like Wow did with Burning Crusade/Lich King, into Elona and Cantha. It will look great and be good enough to justify dumping 50 bucks a pop.