Pleikki your not one of the "few" imo...I also hate the term "pre nerf" as a couple of these will show. {shield stat change for instance was not a nerf at all, rather hosed my once great shields by making them not so great anymore}
This thread looks to me like it was started more as a "hey look I have a bunch of crude shields" {I would have salvaged most of those but thats just me

} but regardless here are a few actual "old schools"
Imp slayer/endless IDS supply.
who remembers how lame the ranger spikes were?
"Spike the warrior in 3-2-1" ... "WTF"

I think this is the only ugly shield I ever kept, not sure why, some junk I just keep for no reason.
