EU players on US servers, why?

Sadalsuud

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2010

A/W

A few years back the European servers were packed to the extent you would meet dozens of people even in remote outposts. Now you're lucky if there are more than 10 people in Kamadan. Did anything happen to the EU servers so people couldn't keep playing on them or what?

Those lag spikes are pissing me off to no end but there is nothing I can do to fix them at the moment (maybe except moving to America, but I can't do that either). The choice is either play with decent ping and all by yourself, or play with people and watch as your character teleports around when he casts a spell after running. It's not THAT bad as I describe it, but it's kind of annoying because the EU servers are THERE. It's just that for some unclear reason all of the EU players have decided to migrate to the US.

Help me to understand, please?

ajicorath

Academy Page

Join Date: Aug 2007

Sensation O Seven

Mo/Me

Trade.

12chars

crazylady

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Aug 2008

UK

Elite Dragons Coalition[RoaR]

Mo/

This May help you understand a little more
I have been back ingame for around 4 weeks now after a very long break and it happend twice
Thats why i play in the American Sever


Oh yes and also trade

Sadalsuud

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2010

A/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by crazylady View Post
This May help you understand a little more
I have been back ingame for around 4 weeks now after a very long break and it happend twice
Thats why i play in the American Sever


Oh yes and also trade
EU servers have been working just fine for the last couple of days. Heck, they were on earlier today when I made my Rit and it automatically started in Europe.

Are you telling me that 98% of the EU players are getting this 24/7? I bet trade wasn't that bad to make them all flee.

Bellatrixa

Bellatrixa

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2010

Under a blanket drinking tea and being British n_n

Brothers of Other Mother [BoOM]

N/

Actually, there are several reasons:

Some people are in mostly American guilds
Some people prefer the greater trade in the American districts
Some people are sick of people not using the language options correctly (I personally get sick of going to ENGLISH districts and seeing nothing but French etc).
Some newer people aren't aware that there are European districts.

And not ALL of the Eu players have migrated. I personally H/H most things so I prefer sticking to Eu servers for less lag. I had a guildie help me with a mission once in AD2 and I D/Ced three times in 5 mins.

Sadalsuud

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2010

A/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bellatrixa View Post
Actually, there are several reasons:

Some people are in mostly American guilds
Some people prefer the greater trade in the American districts
Some people are sick of people not using the language options correctly (I personally get sick of going to ENGLISH districts and seeing nothing but French etc).
Some newer people aren't aware that there are European districts.

And not ALL of the Eu players have migrated. I personally H/H most things so I prefer sticking to Eu servers for less lag. I had a guildie help me with a mission once in AD2 and I D/Ced three times in 5 mins.
1. How'd you get in an American guild if you weren't playing in America to begin with?
2. Dunno about trade, so I can't say.
3. And how does having the entire userbase play in America helps to solve this? The only languages you won't see are Japanese/Korean etc. because English districts don't allow typing of East Asian characters.
4. If you bought the game in Europe you start in Europe by default. Applies to all PEGI rated copies sold outside of Europe as well.

Mac_Eanruig

Mac_Eanruig

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Jul 2010

Sweet Home Alabama -ROLL TIDE

Reign of Justice [RoJ]

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sadalsuud View Post
A few years back the European servers were packed to the extent you would meet dozens of people even in remote outposts. Now you're lucky if there are more than 10 people in Kamadan. Did anything happen to the EU servers so people couldn't keep playing on them or what?

Those lag spikes are pissing me off to no end but there is nothing I can do to fix them at the moment (maybe except moving to America, but I can't do that either). The choice is either play with decent ping and all by yourself, or play with people and watch as your character teleports around when he casts a spell after running. It's not THAT bad as I describe it, but it's kind of annoying because the EU servers are THERE. It's just that for some unclear reason all of the EU players have decided to migrate to the US.

Help me to understand, please?
Maybe in PvE but in PvP.....On an HA weekend....try hanging out on the US servers in HA and see how many ppl are there. EVERYONE and their uncle is in Intl. Dist. literaly 5 ppl in US Dist. 1 on this past Sat.
It's mind boggling.

Dzjudz

Dzjudz

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

gwpvx.com/user:dzjudz

- trade
- easier to find parties if everyone plays in the same dis
- don't have ping problems in america like you describe

In short, it's just more convenient.

Hobbs

Hobbs

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2006

Organised Spam [OS]

W/

When I solo farm I play in EU districts for less lag, but all the rest of the time I play in US districts because it's a more social environment due to more English speakers there. The European districts are mostly French and German in Local Chat.

neoteo ex animo

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2010

Army of Lightness

E/

i still think they should remove all the language and continent districts , and just dump everyone on international dists ...

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

I don't know,my best drops have always been Polish.

But people tend not to write/type English even in the Euro English district. In the German district there's a lot of activity, though.

Del

Del

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2009

In a van, down by the river.

RED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GO if I know, ask Lynette.

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by neoteo ex animo View Post
i still think they should remove all the language and continent districts , and just dump everyone on international dists ...
Terrible idea.

Yawgmoth

Yawgmoth

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Apr 2005

There were many reasons and euro players quickly migrated to american servers.

Euro English district was full of people speaking random-letters-like languages (scandinavian?) and the english speaking euro community was smaller than the american playerbase. One important reason not mentioned by anyone yet is that PARTY SEARCH system doesn't work across continents, so american districts became the default english speaking

The major disadvantage is the high pings and it really decreases the comfort of play if you play something more skill-intensive than C+Space or 1,2,3,4, ... 1,2,3,4.. on each target. I wish Anet did something with it but as it was never widely considered a problem I don't have my hopes high .

Possible solutions could be making PvE instances work just like PvP ones - they should be created on the server where the most players entering are closest to. The only problem with it would be when servers on either continent experience heavy lag issues, now players can just move to the less laggy continent in that case, but with a PvP-like change they would be stuck (except for parties with many players from the other region).
Another one would be improving the Party Search system into fully worldwide (it "just" requires a building a connection between 2 server sites for this service)

Faure

Faure

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2006

Mystic Spiral [MYST]

R/

I only go there for ab, fa and other (pve) pugging. Whenever i'm with guildies doing something or HH i'm at euro for the better ping (usa is okayish, but ping goes orange from time to time).

Bellatrixa

Bellatrixa

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2010

Under a blanket drinking tea and being British n_n

Brothers of Other Mother [BoOM]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sadalsuud View Post
1. How'd you get in an American guild if you weren't playing in America to begin with?
I got invited to it as my guild leaders are American and I very often play during their time zone therefore it's more pleasurable for me?

Quote:
3. And how does having the entire userbase play in America helps to solve this? The only languages you won't see are Japanese/Korean etc. because English districts don't allow typing of East Asian characters.
Re-read what I said. People in the English language districts on the European servers very often don't speak English. They'll speak Dutch, German, French, Spanish, Polish... It's annoying when you don't know those languages. I've had this before in another MMO I played where the same thing happened. Everyone headed for the English districts because more people = better trade. It's a sad but true fact, but irritating for those who don't wish to speak those languages and can't understand them. Obviously people who DO speak English moved to American districts as a result, also because there are more Americans than Europeans :P

Quote:
4. If you bought the game in Europe you start in Europe by default. Applies to all PEGI rated copies sold outside of Europe as well.
Actually no. I started on a trial account, inputted my country etc, got put on the American server to begin with. It was only when I wondered why the lag was so bad that I happened to notice and changed to the EU server.

Why are you so against Europeans using the American server anyway? IMO as long as the language being spoken by someone matches that of where you are, who cares?

Ting Lafal

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Jul 2009

Sweden

Alliance of Fides[AoF]

D/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Yawgmoth View Post
There were many reasons and euro players quickly migrated to american servers.

Euro English district was full of people speaking random-letters-like languages (scandinavian?) and the english speaking euro community was smaller than the american playerbase. One important reason not mentioned by anyone yet is that PARTY SEARCH system doesn't work across continents, so american districts became the default english speaking

The major disadvantage is the high pings and it really decreases the comfort of play if you play something more skill-intensive than C+Space or 1,2,3,4, ... 1,2,3,4.. on each target. I wish Anet did something with it but as it was never widely considered a problem I don't have my hopes high .

Possible solutions could be making PvE instances work just like PvP ones - they should be created on the server where the most players entering are closest to. The only problem with it would be when servers on either continent experience heavy lag issues, now players can just move to the less laggy continent in that case, but with a PvP-like change they would be stuck (except for parties with many players from the other region).
Another one would be improving the Party Search system into fully worldwide (it "just" requires a building a connection between 2 server sites for this service)
All Scandinavians I've met have always spoken English. Never even knew they were Scandinavian until they told me, I'm Scandinavian myself.

Premium Unleaded

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Aug 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mac_Eanruig View Post
Maybe in PvE but in PvP.....On an HA weekend....try hanging out on the US servers in HA and see how many ppl are there. EVERYONE and their uncle is in Intl. Dist. literaly 5 ppl in US Dist. 1 on this past Sat.
It's mind boggling.
International has always been the default gathering location for HA.

godis

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Sep 2009

LOVE

N/Me

My experience is the complete opposite ! Last night I was amazed of all the people in ee1 Not just in Kamadan but many little outposts in NF. I guess its the HoM luring old players back.
But when buying or selling I always jump to America dis. No offense but if germans started typing in english in trade chat, life would be alot easier.
English is not my native language either.

Iuris

Iuris

Forge Runner

Join Date: Nov 2006

Crazy ducks from the Forest

W/

I'm surprised noone has pointed out the most obvious reason:

The player base is decreasing. All the time. The game is almost 6 years old, after all. So, as fewer people play, they tend to concentrate on areas where the other players are. It's simply a matter of "where are the people nowadays?" and going there.

There doesn't actually have to be a reason for people to gather in a specific place. The fact that it's known as the place where people play alone suffices. When a person sees an empty district, they'll automatically move to the districts they perceive as populous. Of you want to play with people, you go to american districts because people who play are there. It is circular logic - because it's a self sustaining dynamic.

Why this is the american districts and not international? That's where the reasons above come in.

P.S. if the game doesn't die first, I fully expect people speaking other languages to start speaking those languages in US districts, too.

Bellatrixa

Bellatrixa

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2010

Under a blanket drinking tea and being British n_n

Brothers of Other Mother [BoOM]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by godis View Post
My experience is the complete opposite ! Last night I was amazed of all the people in ee1 Not just in Kamadan but many little outposts in NF. I guess its the HoM luring old players back
Take into account there's an event on at the moment. At Halloween EE1 was busy as hell.

Milennin

Milennin

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Sep 2006

Europe

W/

I remember playing on Europian servers a few years ago, and the game was like almost dead to me. There were barely any people playing at all. Also, in major towns like Lion's Arch there were often people speaking in other languages, which is very annoying.
After a long break from the game I decided to check on American servers, and noticed the game was much more alive there.
Never having any lagspikes in American servers.

Aldric

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2007

[IG]

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sadalsuud View Post
1. How'd you get in an American guild if you weren't playing in America to begin with?
.
Because my work hours mean't that I was actually in synch with american play times as opposed to euro times?

Nekodesu

Nekodesu

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Oct 2009

I think it's because everybody is in america or german districts, or most people so maybe everybody just moved there? I can't speak German so I don't go to their server though it's better ping, also cause I know myself how epic annoying it is trying to communicate with people who can't even speak english.

I don't got much facts of it, none at all tbh. But I don't know, it's weird though, aren't the biggest playerbase Europeans?

Bellatrixa

Bellatrixa

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2010

Under a blanket drinking tea and being British n_n

Brothers of Other Mother [BoOM]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nekodesu View Post
I don't got much facts of it, none at all tbh. But I don't know, it's weird though, aren't the biggest playerbase Europeans?
I doubt it. Largest playerbases in most MMOs are Americans. Hence why most of the events/competitions are designed around them. I would have loved to have seen a Guy Fawkes related event (think of the amount of party title points there could have been!) but as it's something celebrated almost exclusively in England, it's something that wouldn't happen. Then you get Thanksgiving and we have an event related to it because more of the players are aware of the holiday. Splitting hairs there but you get my point. You don't just have the Americans but also the Canadians, meaning the game is most active in late GMT evening. Suits me with my insomnia :P

Mordiego

Mordiego

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Sep 2007

Pozna??, UTC+1

We Are From Poland [Pol]

N/A

One reason: German ppl. They are in all EU districts speaking German only.

Himm_Taeguk

Himm_Taeguk

Academy Page

Join Date: Aug 2007

Huddersfield, UK

TOL (Temple Of Love)

R/

I use them for Trade and PuG'ing.

ToA has 2 or 3 American Districts so do other places (DoA, Duncan's, etc.) where I can / don't like to H&H by myself. I only really go back to EE districts for playing with my Guildies.

I do all ZB and Wanted from American district's too because you can get a half decent party in less than 5 minutes.

MithranArkanere

MithranArkanere

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Nov 2006

wikipedia.org/wiki/Vigo

Heraldos de la Llama Oscura [HLO]

E/

I'm free like the wind.
I move here and there with a whim.
Why? Because I can.

Yes, we can.

So what If I get over 200 ping in servers other than the European?
That only affects mostly polymock. I never see myself rubberbanding around due to my own ping.

A +100 ping is still better than seeing only German trade messages and party formation.
If you want an English speaking pug or trade, you have to go to America.

ErrantVenture

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2010

Social Darwinism [SaD]

A/W

Remember there's a difference between districts and servers guys. You can go to a european district and still be on the american servers. Which server you're playing on is determined by the composition of your team and you're opponents. Take GvG for example. If more than half the players in the instance (I.E. 9/16 players) are european, you'll be on euro servers. Otherwise you're on american servers. You can tell what server you're on by hovering over the little dot in the bottom right of the screen. An IP starting with 64 means you're on american servers, and IP starting with 201 or 206 means you're on euro servers. THE DISTRICT YOU'RE IN HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH WHAT SERVER YOU'RE PLAYING ON, IT DOESN'T AFFECT YOUR LAG OR PING.

tl;dr servers & districts are two completely different things. Which server you're on is determined by team composition, not district.

Del

Del

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2009

In a van, down by the river.

RED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GO if I know, ask Lynette.

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bellatrixa View Post
I doubt it. Largest playerbases in most MMOs are Americans. Hence why most of the events/competitions are designed around them. I would have loved to have seen a Guy Fawkes related event (think of the amount of party title points there could have been!) but as it's something celebrated almost exclusively in England, it's something that wouldn't happen. Then you get Thanksgiving and we have an event related to it because more of the players are aware of the holiday. Splitting hairs there but you get my point. You don't just have the Americans but also the Canadians, meaning the game is most active in late GMT evening. Suits me with my insomnia :P
Why celebrate a treasonous englishman fighting for spain, trying to bring catholicism (the more evil of the two evils) to power over protestantism?

Edo123

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Apr 2010

I tend to play on American Dist when i wanan team up with other players to do UW,FoW,DoA and trading in Spamadan due to the fact there is a LOT more players there.

I dont know what happened when most Europe ppl went to america dist for tbh. I quitted GW for like a year and came bak and every1 was on america dist so I too went on it due to the fact that everybody left

I tend to play on EU servers with my guildies, i have 3 guild friends that play in EU servers all the way from South Africa and they are "lucky" to get orange ping.

yitjuan

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Aug 2007

GMT +8

redt

Rt/

I noticed chat in Lions Arch American was better than no chat at all.

Bellatrixa

Bellatrixa

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2010

Under a blanket drinking tea and being British n_n

Brothers of Other Mother [BoOM]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Del View Post
Why celebrate a treasonous englishman fighting for spain, trying to bring catholicism (the more evil of the two evils) to power over protestantism?
It's more an excuse to burn things and blow things up these days.

It's traditionally a celebration of King James I surviving the assassination attempt by Guido Fawkes. Puritans used it as an excuse to preach against the evils of Catholicism and burn effigies but as the years have gone by, it's now more of a ceremonial and social event. So no, it's not to glorify Guido Fawkes, quite the opposite. Hence why effigies of him are made and burnt on the fires.

Link for those who really want to read more

FoxBat

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Apr 2006

Amazon Basin [AB]

Mo/Me

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bellatrixa View Post
I doubt it. Largest playerbases in most MMOs are Americans.
Not true for guild wars, roughly half of their base is European; and of that it is mostly German.

Quote:
Hence why most of the events/competitions are designed around them.
This has more to do with Anet being based in Seattle.

Raven Wing

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Nov 2005

The Imperial Guards of Istan [TIGI]

N/

For me as an european who can read and write danish and english and sometimes want to sell stuff or join pug for z bounty or stuff like slavers, doa, fow etc its a simple choice:

Go to europe english district of the relevant town and often you see only some german or french announcements in partysearch.

As already said, its american district the people are.

The comments on thanksgiving are derailing of thread, why not make a new thread about that?

AmbientMelody

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Apr 2009

Poland

N/A

What's up with the German districts anyway? It's getting tedious, because you'd expect a well-educated German to be genuine and speak in English seeing as players from all nationalities hang around in German districts thanks to their population, but what you usually get are insults, ignore button and more insults. Thanks for your generosity my German friends, I shall return the favour one day

Too bad AM servers are unbearable with the pings they offer. There were times when EU English district was a nice place to hang out and there was a good reason to avoid AM ones, but it seems that since the migration took place it's increasingly pointless to play at EU servers, unless you speak German.

Sprites

Sprites

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jun 2005

royaume de la lumi??re :D

LOGW

E/Me

well the bad thing about germans is i don't understand them , and most of the time they won't change language
neither i understand eastern europe or scandinavian , but i usually play in french districts , much more populated thn english ones

Yawgmoth

Yawgmoth

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Apr 2005

It's a great shame that all non-German non-French players from Europe have to play on American severs, it's because of thoughtless design of certain game mechanics and it's also the fault of the players themselves.

There definately AREN'T more American players than English-speaking Euros. Especially during the European prime time. All the time I find myself in a full 8/8 pug of all Euro players that forms in American districts and proceeds to play on American instances... and sometimes complain about lags. When I play monk I sometimes suggest zoning and starting from euro district for better pings (high ping and lag spikes sux when monking) and then I hear from everyone that actually they're euro aswell and that's a good idea... but they'd never come with that themselves. Everyone's like completely forgotten about the existance of Euro distrcts, so it would be very hard to change players' mentality now.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ErrantVenture View Post
Remember there's a difference between districts and servers guys. You can go to a european district and still be on the american servers. Which server you're playing on is determined by the composition of your team and you're opponents. Take GvG for example. If more than half the players in the instance (I.E. 9/16 players) are european, you'll be on euro servers. Otherwise you're on american servers. You can tell what server you're on by hovering over the little dot in the bottom right of the screen. An IP starting with 64 means you're on american servers, and IP starting with 201 or 206 means you're on euro servers. THE DISTRICT YOU'RE IN HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH WHAT SERVER YOU'RE PLAYING ON, IT DOESN'T AFFECT YOUR LAG OR PING.

tl;dr servers & districts are two completely different things. Which server you're on is determined by team composition, not district.
Nope sir, European districts are always ran on European servers and all other districts are ran on American servers. The actual players' location matter ONLY in PvP combat instances, everywhere else in the game it's strictly predetermined and all PvE instances are created on the same server region on which the outpost district was.

AmbientMelody

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Apr 2009

Poland

N/A

Not to come off as an ass, but the idea of fracturing European districts to language-based ones was a fail since inception. I prefer a Babylon over Ghost Town, not sure about you.

Anon-e-mouse

Anon-e-mouse

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2006

@ Home

League Of Friends [LOF]

R/Mo

Players need a way of blocking or ignoring chat that's not in the appropriate language. Districts was a way of making that happen. I happen to like GW's way of doing things than most other games where the players are seperated out into different server worlds and there's no communication between them.

That being said I really do wish those people not using English in the Euro English districts, either use their home district, or the International district (which is WHY IT'S THERE).

The number of times I zone in and see complete walls of text (usually Dutch) that I can't read or understand simply beggers belief.

bhavv

bhavv

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Sep 2006

I prefer to play in America channels because there are more people, more activity, and I managed o find myself a large and active alliance through America districts.

EU servers are completely dead, it makes no sense to play on them. I would prefer to play all my MMOs on American servers if given the opportunity because Europe is a rather tiny place in comparison with so many fewer people playing games, further divided by so many languages.