I searched for this and i didn't find anything, so here is my idea.
I want to be able to regulate the power of the officers in a guild. I used to be a guild leader and sometimes i would log on and find that my officers had booted people from the guild or done a guild battle without me knowing and I would return from being away to find our rating had gone down and there were people missing from the guild. My idea is an extra tab on the guild bar for the leader to regulate power. The picture doesnt show too much right now, but with guild storage supposedly coming in the future, i can see there being more options.
I made a picture to show what i mean.
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a87...ptionscopy.jpg
edit: for the picture, you might have to click the zoom button to see it clearly.
edit2:Here is a new picture to show how you set options per officer.
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a87...tions2copy.jpg
Officer Power suggestion
benmanhaha
Kool Pajamas
/signed
I've been in some guilds where the officers really messed things up.
Even if you are careful about promoting, sometimes you can run into a idiot that could ruin it.
I've been in some guilds where the officers really messed things up.
Even if you are careful about promoting, sometimes you can run into a idiot that could ruin it.
Guardian of the Light
/signed
Symeon
well this is the kind of thing I'm thinking of, after a traitor officer just took a few supporters from Master Casters and left to make his own guild, before he did kicking randomly about 20 members. Well, we trusted him before, but dunno...
anyway, /signed
anyway, /signed
benmanhaha
Haha, that reminds me of when i was an officer in another guild. Well our guild sucked an all the good people left. So when I left i made everyone an officer. Hardy har har, this suggestion came about after alot of self reflection.
chris_nin00
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by benmanhaha
I searched for this and i didn't find anything, so here is my idea.
I want to be able to regulate the power of the officers in a guild. I used to be a guild leader and sometimes i would log on and find that my officers had booted people from the guild or done a guild battle without me knowing and I would return from being away to find our rating had gone down and there were people missing from the guild. My idea is an extra tab on the guild bar for the leader to regulate power. The picture doesnt show too much right now, but with guild storage supposedly coming in the future, i can see there being more options. I made a picture to show what i mean. http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a87...ptionscopy.jpg edit: for the picture, you might have to click the zoom button to see it clearly. |
Jokin'./signaroo!
benmanhaha
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by chris_nin00
That's an amazing idea ben, the most intelligent post you typed yet.
Jokin'./signaroo! |
Lampshade
I think it should be per officer, not all.
My idea is when you click their little head on the Roster, the dropdown menu would include a "powers" thingy that would bring up a window with the options posted here.
My idea is when you click their little head on the Roster, the dropdown menu would include a "powers" thingy that would bring up a window with the options posted here.
benmanhaha
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lampshade
I think it should be per officer, not all.
My idea is when you click their little head on the Roster, the dropdown menu would include a "powers" thingy that would bring up a window with the options posted here. |
Shimus DarkRaven
Per officer, and yes, we need..no, nay, HAVE TO have this! It can't be guild wars without a guild..and if someone can do that..well.. no.
////Signed <--The only time you'll ever see me quadruple sign, something I bet.
--The Shim
////Signed <--The only time you'll ever see me quadruple sign, something I bet.
--The Shim
TheGuildWarsPenguin
good idea.
/signed
/signed
Son of Dusto
an officer in my old guild kicked every single non-officer (50 plus members)
Kai Nui
I love that idea so much. Definitely should be part of the guild tabs.
Fred Kiwi
/signed /signed/signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed
/signed /signed
/signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed
/signed /signed
/signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed /signed
A User Name
//signed
Great idea.
Great idea.
Mercenary662
/signed cool idea
Juhanah
/signed
Even tho i never had problem with my officers since they were people i trusted before guildwars was even realeased
But i totally agree that more power over officers could just make things better for everyone (excluding untrusty officers of course)
I think there should also have an option to let members invite a guest(of course that member would have to pay for the nvitation) The guest then could apply for membership.
There's still so much work to do on guilds. Some games not centered on guilds even have more options than guildwars.
Ragnarok had a taxe system for guilds. Any members could share a set % of exp to the guild and then with more experience you could have special guild skills such as rent storage, more members and more defense to guild castle...
Even tho i never had problem with my officers since they were people i trusted before guildwars was even realeased
But i totally agree that more power over officers could just make things better for everyone (excluding untrusty officers of course)
I think there should also have an option to let members invite a guest(of course that member would have to pay for the nvitation) The guest then could apply for membership.
There's still so much work to do on guilds. Some games not centered on guilds even have more options than guildwars.
Ragnarok had a taxe system for guilds. Any members could share a set % of exp to the guild and then with more experience you could have special guild skills such as rent storage, more members and more defense to guild castle...
Monseir
/signed
artemis inferno
mebbe even choose things for each individual officer
/signed
/signed
almightytom
/signed
this needs to be done to keep idiots like me from abusing power
this needs to be done to keep idiots like me from abusing power
benmanhaha
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Juhanah
/signed
Even tho i never had problem with my officers since they were people i trusted before guildwars was even realeased But i totally agree that more power over officers could just make things better for everyone (excluding untrusty officers of course) I think there should also have an option to let members invite a guest(of course that member would have to pay for the nvitation) The guest then could apply for membership. There's still so much work to do on guilds. Some games not centered on guilds even have more options than guildwars. Ragnarok had a taxe system for guilds. Any members could share a set % of exp to the guild and then with more experience you could have special guild skills such as rent storage, more members and more defense to guild castle... |
benmanhaha
I just wanted to let you guys know, i uploaded a new picture that shows changing powers per officer.
Venus
/Signed
That is a really good idea.
That is a really good idea.
Dash Logan
/signed
Very good idea, this officer thing not happend to me but i have heard so many horror stories out there, this must be implemented.
Very good idea, this officer thing not happend to me but i have heard so many horror stories out there, this must be implemented.
Sagius Truthbarron
/signed
For the per-officer idea.
For the per-officer idea.
PieXags
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Shimus DarkRaven
Per officer, and yes, we need..no, nay, HAVE TO have this!
|
Anyway, enough with being a smartass.
I do think it's a wonderful idea, and it's something I'd thought of in the past. There should definately be something like this, it's very similar to the way forums are set up and it works really well. Every guild is different, so it's only realistic that each guild might want their officers to be able to operate a little differently.
Sereng Amaranth
/signed
i had this idea a few months ago, but i didn't explain it in as much detail
i had this idea a few months ago, but i didn't explain it in as much detail
ghezbora
/signed
definitely need per-officer controls. havent had any bad things in my guild, but its still a good idea.
definitely need per-officer controls. havent had any bad things in my guild, but its still a good idea.
Jaythen Tyradel
/signed
Mister Someone
Can anybody say they want to sign or not sign on a subject? If they can im definately
/sign just had something happen recently in guild where an officer/traitor kicked everyone but other officers really p/o a lot of people.
/sign just had something happen recently in guild where an officer/traitor kicked everyone but other officers really p/o a lot of people.
Banaticus
I like multiple ranks, say, 5 ranks in a guild. Only three ranks is somewhat limiting. Everyone in the guild is either a Peon, a Duke, or King. Why not allow Merchant, or something in between the cousins to the King (Duke) and the lowly commoners?
As it stands, allowing different officers different powers would be great. There should be a way for members to see who has what power, though.
/signed
As it stands, allowing different officers different powers would be great. There should be a way for members to see who has what power, though.
/signed
Hannibel
/signed
i think maybe instead of it being for all officers, you should have a window for each seperate officer, you might trust some officers more then others.
i think maybe instead of it being for all officers, you should have a window for each seperate officer, you might trust some officers more then others.
lasteele
I have a story of spite that lead to revenge then hatred then death.My guild has ranged anywhere from 60-100 members.About a month ago i caught one of my officers trying to recruit ppl to his guild he had just started.So i kicked him not knowing his best friend was an officer as well and had his password,he came back and kicked 70+ members.I waited a week or two and bought another account and joined his guild.Which in turn like a noob he made me an officer within two days.Then as you guessed i kicked everyone out and invited them to my guild.About a week later a friend of mine in another guild invited me as a guest in his guild and guess who i seen?Well lets just say i wasnt happy.So we did an unrated gvg battle between the guildes and my friend made his ppl set back watch us beat this guys char to death.
So if anyone has or sees darknesscrow crow or bull dogz steer clear they have the traitor trait!!!
/SIGNED
So if anyone has or sees darknesscrow crow or bull dogz steer clear they have the traitor trait!!!
/SIGNED
benmanhaha
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sereng Amaranth
/signed
i had this idea a few months ago, but i didn't explain it in as much detail |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by PieXags
I do think it's a wonderful idea, and it's something I'd thought of in the past. There should definately be something like this, it's very similar to the way forums are set up and it works really well. Every guild is different, so it's only realistic that each guild might want their officers to be able to operate a little differently.
|
chris_nin00
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by benmanhaha
hey thanks, it makes me feel good that the great PieXags himself likes this idea.
|
Getting commended by Pie is like getting crowned King of England by a lottery
./////////////////////E1000000000 signed
{IceFire}
/signed for per officer
2_fingers
/signed
more control to the guild leader this way.
more control to the guild leader this way.
mangakiwi
/signed
Skuld
Yes 
phreakilla
/signed