Originally Posted by MSecorsky
Aside from name, how do you know they're unoriginal?
|
The name is simply a description of the class...sheesh people complain about everything and no real info is even out yet.
Eet GnomeSmasher
Originally Posted by MSecorsky
Aside from name, how do you know they're unoriginal?
|
Align
All these whiners complaining about unoriginality, have no creative thinking themselves. |
There's a whole lot of room to make the skills and role of the assassin very original and unique. |
Mordakai
Originally Posted by Align
I can make up three professions on the spot that would be more original than an Assassin(though not necessarily 100% new - thats not what the problem is). Its not hard at all. Using something many others have used looks like lack of creative thinking to me..
|
Mordakai
Originally Posted by IlikeGW
more cliches, and I'm sure underdeveloped gameplay to go with it. No thanks Anet, I learned my lesson with chapter 1.
|
BigTru
Originally Posted by Align
I can make up three professions on the spot that would be more original than an Assassin(though not necessarily 100% new - thats not what the problem is). Its not hard at all.
|
Mordakai
Originally Posted by BigTru
Do it.
|
BigTru
Originally Posted by Mordakai
Nice! LOL, I thought of posting that too.
A Summoner A Shapeshifter A D&D Style Monk (no armor, no weapons) Are these great ideas? Meh, to me they are just as "un-original" as Assassin. |
Originally Posted by Mordakai
EDIT: Love your avatar, BigTru!
|
Sir Skullcrasher
Originally Posted by Eet GnomeSmasher
Exactly. All these whiners complaining about unoriginality, have no creative thinking themselves. There's a whole lot of room to make the skills and role of the assassin very original and unique.
The name is simply a description of the class...sheesh people complain about everything and no real info is even out yet. |
MSecorsky
Originally Posted by sir skulkcrasher
1) you make a great skills and watch how long before someone complain and it get balanced or "Nerfed"
2) Come on, A-Net is not thinking hard enough if they can put assassins and other generic class in there. I mean, give them credit for thinking about it, but does assassins or pirates fit in the OVERALL theme of Guild Wars (assassins.. maybe.. pirates.. hell no) I'm not complaining but just want to point out that assassins isn't going to cut it in the world of Tyria. Most of the missions and quests required you to kill stuffs not run and hide and sneak my way to it. It might bring new elements into PvE.... but trust me. (quote me on this) once chapter 2 is out and people abused the hell out of assassin's skills. Watch how fast A-Net will react to it! Period! |
S H I N O B I
Originally Posted by MSecorsky
Pirates... I see another swordsman here, with cutlass/rapier type swords and new skills. Who cares if it's called 'Bob' if it's fun, balanced and manages to fill in a gap?
If they had the exact same thing as the expected assassin, but instead called the class a governator, everyone would be chomping at the bit to see what it is. As was said... what's in a name... |
Eet GnomeSmasher
Originally Posted by Align
I can make up three professions on the spot that would be more original than an Assassin(though not necessarily 100% new - thats not what the problem is).
|
Sir Skullcrasher
Originally Posted by Eet GnomeSmasher
See, you yourself admit that anything you make up wouldnt be new at all either. The problem is that in a sword and sorcery based game where the characters are combat oriented, there really is not going to be a whole lot of original classes....
ANYTHING that anyone makes up within these restrictions is going to be unoriginal and basically fit into the primary archetypes in the "D&D" type game. Like someone said, it's not about the name or even the class but how original the skills and role will be. If it turns out that the assassin is the typical dual weilding, stealth high damage dealer then I'll be the first one to agree with you that the class just isnt very original at all. |
BigTru
ghezbora
Vilaptca
malus
Smog
Seron Dalar
Smog
Originally Posted by Seron Dalar
^Corruption? Quit whining. People don't roleplay unless they want to. If you don't like the Halloween stuff, well, too bad. It's harmless fun. If you don't like assassins, don't play one.
|
Goonter
Eet GnomeSmasher
Originally Posted by Smog
I agree with that, everyone is going to be an assassin, well for the most part at least to try it. I'm just interested to see in the skills it has, stats as well. I just see the assassin as more corruption to the game just like Halloween items, I mean its bad enough that they don't seperate Roleplay and PvP servers, even if they did it's not like anyone actually roleplays (though they should)
|
Originally Posted by Smog
. Oh and also on my first post the only reason I think it is corruption is because, most likely a lot of people will play them, and since they have not been worked on as long as the rest of the game was they won't be balanced at the beginning.
|
Kratos Angeltear
Nightwish
Originally Posted by Align
Considering the uncountable options, this was definitely among the less original professions to put into the game.
I can make up three professions on the spot that would be more original than an Assassin(though not necessarily 100% new - thats not what the problem is). Its not hard at all. Using something many others have used looks like lack of creative thinking to me. We trust ANet to be as capable as usual in doing that. But I'd rather see something unusual than something common remade to be less like the others of its sort. |
Phades
Originally Posted by Eet GnomeSmasher
Exactly. All these whiners complaining about unoriginality, have no creative thinking themselves. There's a whole lot of room to make the skills and role of the assassin very original and unique.
The name is simply a description of the class...sheesh people complain about everything and no real info is even out yet. |
Originally Posted by sir skulkcrasher
1) you make a great skills and watch how long before someone complain and it get balanced or "Nerfed"
2) Come on, A-Net is not thinking hard enough if they can put assassins and other generic class in there. I mean, give them credit for thinking about it, but does assassins or pirates fit in the OVERALL theme of Guild Wars (assassins.. maybe.. pirates.. hell no) I'm not complaining but just want to point out that assassins isn't going to cut it in the world of Tyria. Most of the missions and quests required you to kill stuffs not run and hide and sneak my way to it. It might bring new elements into PvE.... but trust me. (quote me on this) once chapter 2 is out and people abused the hell out of assassin's skills. Watch how fast A-Net will react to it! Period! |
dr_james2k
Mordakai
Originally Posted by S H I N O B I
Tough luck for the people who hate the class... If you dont like the character then DON'T PLAY IT. Simple as that... I'm sure there are more people who welcome the class then hate it... |
Mordakai
Originally Posted by Kratos Angeltear
I think instead of an assasin they should implement a class similar to the american fire emblems "myrmidons" I believe that would be fitting. THe character would have a special ability of doing an attack that hits a critical organ or body part of the opponent and inflicts a condition (blind, deep wound, crippeled) and inflicts more damage
|
Nightwish
blackbloodzero
Savio
thesword
quanzong
Watmonster
Ice Blessings
Sir Skullcrasher
Originally Posted by Ice Blessings
Do you guys know why a Assassian is being put into the game? Not because Anet wanted to, but because alot of the players wanted that class. Period.
If you want some weird new proffession added to the game, then get 1000 people and spam the forums asking Anet and they will do it. ~Ice~ |
Savio
Originally Posted by sir skulkcrasher
A-Net should stick to their OWN plans and make characters according to them not put in Assassin who IMO is out of place with the world of Guild Wars.
|
Sir Skullcrasher
Fear The Destroyer
Eet GnomeSmasher
Originally Posted by sir skulkcrasher
Exactly.. I'm telling you.. People will abuse the skills for assassin and end up with being nerfed.
|
nihilous