http://www.gameogre.com/wowvsguildwars.htm
Read the whole first, then you can start with you're flaming..
Guildwars really do dominate WoW...
chicks boy
Renegade26
Runescape is nothing compared to us. But Id agree (WoW vs GW) we both are the top of what we try to do.
Miral
because nine maybe-random peoples opinions makes something fact o.O
anyways, they're really two different games. both have their pros and cons. save the arguments on it for guildwars2 since it will be more WoW-style
anyways, they're really two different games. both have their pros and cons. save the arguments on it for guildwars2 since it will be more WoW-style
Milennin
Yeah, I read that thing a few weeks ago, it's funny.=P Guild Wars for the win.8)
julien
www.xfire.com/ 1. wow
Mystic Cobra
Cartoon Graphic FTW.
upier
Is it wrong of me to have wanted WoW to win despite having never played it?
Must be all the good things that GW has turned into!
Must be all the good things that GW has turned into!
JeniM
owned 
But same as anything like this it depends who's asked, personally GW FTW who wants to fish in a game . . it's dull enough in real life lol
But same as anything like this it depends who's asked, personally GW FTW who wants to fish in a game . . it's dull enough in real life lol
Renegade26
Who plays GuildWars and Xfire at the same time.
julien
Who play wow and xfire at the same time?
chicks boy
who play guildwars and wow and xfire at the same time
julien
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by chicks boy
who play guildwars and wow and xfire at the same time
|
Renegade26
MINUTES PLAYED
World of Warcraft 4,373,314
World of Warcraft 4,373,314
julien
Guild Wars 545,713
julien
Sorry for double reply, lag =(
Lord Feathers
JeniM
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Renegade26
MINUTES PLAYED
World of Warcraft 4,373,314 |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by julien
Guild Wars 545,713
|
Zinger314
That article stinks of worse bias than a Republican Convention.
And yet, do you actually get a year of playtime out of 6 games?
Uhh...what? WoW is "too easy to level?" In a competition between WoW and GUILD WARS?!
Ironic, as all the WoW bashers never finished WoW.
Quoted for irony and naivete.
Also quoted for irony and naivete.
There's a lot more I could say, but that article is so tainted with bias it's sickening (why does GW has 5 comments posted about it and WoW only 4?). None of the commentors appear to have played both games, which is inappropriate when comparing both games. If a website does such a comparison, they would need players who have played both WoW and GW to its limits (such as myself).
It's also an old article, as the level cap in WoW has been 70 for a long time. It seems like a late-2006 article, and Guild Wars has definately lost points since then.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wrt WoW
Rating: 0
Author: gbwong Comment: Costs so much. The game itself is so expensive, but the monthly fee is just outrageous! It might be good, but it is not worth it. If you play this game for 1 year, you could probably buy 6 new games. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wrt WoW
Rating: 0
Author: mmorpg-man Comment: Too expensive. The level cap is level 60 only? Many of my friends have played this and got dissapointed. You character looks the same as everyone else and it's so easy to level that the challenge is just gone. If I had a choice between GW or WoW, I would choose GW. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wrt GW
Rating: 10
Author: SweatyPyro Comment: Great game with a PvP focus. I don't get how people get bored of it so easily. Sure, a lvl 20 limit is bad but Im still stuffed with quests after a week and the game is still great. Some people should finish it before judging it. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wrt GW
Rating: 10
Author: Charger XD Comment: In my opinion, this is probably the best MMORPG ever. It is much cheaper than WoW, even if you buy the chapters/expansions every 6 months. The missions are really fun and the graphics are wicked. If you ever get rejected from a group just use henchmen/heroes for PvE. PvP is also really fun and you can PvP straight ahead if you want to. The lvl cap (20) is there for a reason. ArenaNet knows what they are doing. This game requires more skill than time spent. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wrt GW
Rating: 10
Author: Miclee Comment: Great game! I have all the expansions. A good thing is that the max level is 20 so players don't focus on power-leveling. The graphics are better than WoW and it has no monthly fees. You can go with a PvE character or just focus on PvP. PvP is my favorite part of this game because it is always different. |
There's a lot more I could say, but that article is so tainted with bias it's sickening (why does GW has 5 comments posted about it and WoW only 4?). None of the commentors appear to have played both games, which is inappropriate when comparing both games. If a website does such a comparison, they would need players who have played both WoW and GW to its limits (such as myself).
It's also an old article, as the level cap in WoW has been 70 for a long time. It seems like a late-2006 article, and Guild Wars has definately lost points since then.
Despozblehero
For PvE WoW wins no contest.... based on items, content, replayability, and overall things to do, um just about everything that makes PvE, WoW wins... GW did have the best PvP but...
Shuuda
This thread really fails, Anyone who try to compare two rather different games should find something else do.
However, IMO even if WoW is considered "Better", the fact it has a monthly fee makes it not worth playing. CSS might be worth palying if it had a fee, but that's all, no other game with a fee is really worth it.
However, IMO even if WoW is considered "Better", the fact it has a monthly fee makes it not worth playing. CSS might be worth palying if it had a fee, but that's all, no other game with a fee is really worth it.
Xenex Xclame
1) Do = Does ( referring to the title )
2) This is OLDDDDDD it talks about BC going to be released.
@ Zinger : notice how all the GW posts are positive and WoW have bad and good ( like it should be )
Like Miral said i think we should wait for gw2 to really talk about GW vs WoW, sadly i think we will be voting for WoW :'(
2) This is OLDDDDDD it talks about BC going to be released.
@ Zinger : notice how all the GW posts are positive and WoW have bad and good ( like it should be )
Like Miral said i think we should wait for gw2 to really talk about GW vs WoW, sadly i think we will be voting for WoW :'(
Zinger314
In an attempt to outplay the OP's game, I've decided to reciprocate and post the same thread on the official World of Warcraft forums to see the response. It's quite different than this thread, at the least...
Bryant Again
/target Chicks Boy
/facepalm
Yes he did. See Zinger commented on how hugely biased the guy was?
OH SNAP I GOTS YER NAMES NAO!!1 (Not suprised you're a warlock, though...go orc)
/facepalm
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Xenex Xclame
@ Zinger : notice how all the GW posts are positive and WoW have bad and good ( like it should be )
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
In an attempt to outplay the OP's game, I've decided to reciprocate and post the same thread on the official World of Warcraft forums to see the response. It's quite different than this thread, at the least...
|
Zinger314
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bryant Again
/OH SNAP I GOTS YER NAMES NAO!!1 (Not suprised you're a warlock, though...go orc)
|
Master Ketsu
I tried wow and got pretty far when it started, What killed it for me was the total lack of creativity in builds ( Basically 4 cookie cutters for each class, and if you werent one of those, you were a noob. Hands down. No argument ) And the crappy PvP.
Bryant Again
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
I'm a Warlock for the same reason I'm a Necromancer; I enjoy debuffing, I don't wan to be FOTM.
|
DreamRunner
@Zinger. I like it how the WoW players actually attacked you, when you are trying to stand up for WoW. Brilliant player base!
Anyway, I noticed how they mentioned the population on being the better game. And I quote Srsly "Let me get this straight: 3x as many people PAY to play warcraft, but somehow the other one is better?" But how many players do you PLAY with, or have a chance to play with. My grip with WoW is that the player base of the US is broken up to around 100+ servers.
example.
I meet person X and find out that he\she plays WoW. I ask, what server he\she plays on. Person X says he\she players on Arthas, while I play on Blackrock. Oh, we cant play together. Conversation DEAD.
Anyway, I noticed how they mentioned the population on being the better game. And I quote Srsly "Let me get this straight: 3x as many people PAY to play warcraft, but somehow the other one is better?" But how many players do you PLAY with, or have a chance to play with. My grip with WoW is that the player base of the US is broken up to around 100+ servers.
example.
I meet person X and find out that he\she plays WoW. I ask, what server he\she plays on. Person X says he\she players on Arthas, while I play on Blackrock. Oh, we cant play together. Conversation DEAD.
Knightsaber Sith
Just wait 'til Hellgate: London's out
BeowulfKamdas
GWG: So how awesome is Guild Wars?
ANet: Sooo Awesome
ANet: Sooo Awesome
Miral
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by DreamRunner
@Zinger. I like it how the WoW players actually attacked you, when you are trying to stand up for WoW. Brilliant player base!
Anyway, I noticed how they mentioned the population on being the better game. And I quote Srsly "Let me get this straight: 3x as many people PAY to play warcraft, but somehow the other one is better?" But how many players do you PLAY with, or have a chance to play with. My grip with WoW is that the player base of the US is broken up to around 100+ servers. example. I meet person X and find out that he\she plays WoW. I ask, what server he\she plays on. Person X says he\she players on Arthas, while I play on Blackrock. Oh, we cant play together. Conversation DEAD. |
Sli Ander
I read the link zinger put up and found it quite interesting that about half the people that responded acknowledged that GW is a good game, but has a different focus than Wow. They specifically cited GW's endgame PvP as a highpoint, but they couldn't handle the 'lack of character development and endgame content'. (paraphrased for those that didn't read it)
In the end it comes down to player preference, so polls from different sites will always show different results. As GW and WoW are technically in different mmo categories, its nothing to really worry about (besides Wow had a headstart). I would like to see the day when GW/GW2 surpasses Wow in pop., but it all depends on how 2 turns out. Can't wait to see what surprises are in store.
I'm trying very hard not to make my comment a comparison of GW and Wow, and we really don't need to have another GW vsWow thread...here's to staying on topic (crosses fingers).
But that's just my two cents
In the end it comes down to player preference, so polls from different sites will always show different results. As GW and WoW are technically in different mmo categories, its nothing to really worry about (besides Wow had a headstart). I would like to see the day when GW/GW2 surpasses Wow in pop., but it all depends on how 2 turns out. Can't wait to see what surprises are in store.
I'm trying very hard not to make my comment a comparison of GW and Wow, and we really don't need to have another GW vsWow thread...here's to staying on topic (crosses fingers).
But that's just my two cents
Darkobra
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Renegade26
Who plays GuildWars and Xfire at the same time.
|
samcobra
that thread is interesting because I think it really mirrors the truth of the situation. People on the WoW thread agree that GW is a fun game, at the start; but once you get past the majority of its content and beat the game, etc. the only thing thats still interesting is the PvP. Unfortunately, with the preponderance of metagame builds, pvp is now also becoming boring and there's really nothing much to do anymore but grind for titles in the game.
Miral
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by samcobra
there's really nothing much to do anymore but grind for titles in the game.
|
GWEN will fix it for a few weeks, but then its back to boredom until guildwars2... so far away...
Funk
You realize this one of the worst articles ever written, right? They put up random points without any connection...
...and even use wrong "facts": GW has nowhere near 3 million players. Not even 1 million.
...and even use wrong "facts": GW has nowhere near 3 million players. Not even 1 million.
Molock
Wow... the World of Warcraft fanboys should get of this forum now....
Cyan The Archer
Hahah.. I like how people are more positive towards GW on the WoW site, than they are here xD Maybe I should actually join the WoW forums, to hear about people liking GW >_<
"IT'S THE END OF GUILD WARS AS WE KNOW IT!"
"IT'S THE END OF GUILD WARS AS WE KNOW IT!"
Swift Thief
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by julien
www.xfire.com/ 1. wow
|
Miral
michael jackson's old stuff rocks yknow when he was black...
yknow when he was black...
Muspellsheimr