Canthan Grandmaster Cartographer in a day - What's A-Net going to do about it?

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

Quote:
As was I, and I was explaining that he is not being ironic and is instead just being rude.
No you weren't explaining, you were asking a question:
Quote:
So you think Karyuu doesn't like the way her avatar looks at all and is just having it there to say "lol look at me"???
See?


I agree with the above, I think Torqual's long post would of been better without the insults. I still think it had valid points in it.

Bryant Again

Bryant Again

Hall Hero

Join Date: Feb 2006

Quote:
Originally Posted by elektra_lucia
No you weren't explaining, you were asking a question:


See?
Explaining by making a point, yes, but that's not OMG nevermind, this is derailing too much into stupid.

Torqual

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2006

W/Mo

There was. But come on, this is guru. Every thread is like this. It's much easier to snipe than to tolerate being sniped at for 12 pages. I'm entitled to join in....after all I am not St. Torqual.

When you read pages of ignorant people saying "QQ more" to your long and thought out post, it kind of makes you lose interest in continuing to post constructively yourself. I accept my error.

The discussion has most definitely run its course.

Saraphim

Saraphim

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Mar 2006

The Hand of Omega [WHO]

E/

Actually, I could open a bigger can of worms, considering I've been defending the cartography mod,

/Dons Devil's Advocate hat.

Question: Does the mod affect gameplay?

Answer: Popular opinion says no.

Another Question: Does Legendary Cartographer affect the amount of time we recieve the favour of the Gods.


Answer: Oh yes.


<pigeons><cat><pigeons>


DISCUSS

Have fun.

Torqual

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2006

W/Mo

Nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooo

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

I think you enjoy seeing people fight Saraphim xD.

Mineria

Mineria

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

Denmark

Dragonslayers Of The [Mist]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karyuu
@Mineria: And what point are you trying to make? If anything, you are proving my own. Screenshots + Photoshop = very time consuming to see what spots you have yet to explore. Texmod = quicker to see what spots you have yet to explore.

Sooo....
Gesh...
If the title doesn't mean nothing, if it is to time consuming then ytf bothering to get it??

Karyuu

Karyuu

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2007

Kahlifownia

Roses of the Moonlight Sigil [RoMS]

W/Rt

The title means something to me personally :] In every game I have played, and in all the previous guilds I have joined, I've been an "Explorer." Since GW has an explorer/cartographer title, I figure I should continue with my tradition.

Saraphim

Saraphim

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Mar 2006

The Hand of Omega [WHO]

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by elektra_lucia
I think you enjoy seeing people fight Saraphim xD.
Who me?

/whistles innocently.

Nah, tbh I only just thought of that, and it is quite a big issue really as favour affects every single player in the game, indirectly and directly. You could potentially argue that it even affects the economy as if this mod is really creating LGMCs all over the place then if it was taken away it could reduce access to FoW and the Underworld, prices of ectos etc.

Them's big worms crawling out of that can. Or I may be full of it, can't really say as I've never been a hardcore farmer or trader.

HawkofStorms

HawkofStorms

Hall Hero

Join Date: Aug 2005

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Saraphim
This thread has completely deterioated to +1 sniping and snarkiness, even from the OP.

Frankly, despite his commendably large thought out post (and despite the fact that it's a bit of an epic rant) the moment someone dismisses other people's opinions as "bilge" and "excrement" and makes assumptions that those people have no idea what they're talking about then they've effectively shot their own argument in the foot anyway.

I think there was a vaild discussion in here at some point.
QFT. Ignoring and insulting people because they disagree with you is a ridiculous policy.

I can't believe Galie sided with the OP.

Karyuu

Karyuu

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2007

Kahlifownia

Roses of the Moonlight Sigil [RoMS]

W/Rt

Heheh, Saraphim

At the same time, you could make that same argument about guides and wikis. More and more people have access to them, so more and more people are finding out where to go for skill capping, as one example. Guides and wikis sure affect the Legendary status for that title track.

Fates

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2005

Kanuckistan

Mirror of Reason [SNOW]

R/

I would like to thank the OP for bringing this mod to my attention. I haven't been following the mod community so didn't really know such a thing existed. I find the cartographer titles to be a real PITA. I tried it out and wow, i'll be grandmaster in a couple days.

Thanks for the 4 titles, you rock!

Saraphim

Saraphim

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Mar 2006

The Hand of Omega [WHO]

E/

Quote:
Heheh, Saraphim

At the same time, you could make that same argument about guides and wikis. More and more people have access to them, so more and more people are finding out where to go for skill capping, as one example. Guides and wikis sure affect the Legendary status for that title track.
Lol. And so the circle closes !

For what it's worth, Torqual I do see your point. I don't particularly agree that the mod makes it quite that easy, you still have to do a lot of work. I remember I finally finished Tyria about 12 months after I started playing and I was ... relieved more than anything else, but there is a sense of satisfaction to be gained from doing something by yourself. No mod can take that away from you.

Big_Iron

Big_Iron

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Dec 2005

The Edge

Tormented Weapons [emo]

I don't wipe my nose without first consulting Wiki these days. I really don't see much of a difference. I guess I'm a big ol' cheater.

arcady

arcady

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: May 2006

San Francisco native

Mo/P

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richardt
See....this is just frustrating.

I have several friends who don't care about titles and as such don't work on them. But they at least appreciate when someone works really hard at one and actually earns it.
Shrug.

I don't care for titles, and I have no respect for the titles on other people's characters. I think they are a silly waste of time.

I'm not alone in this view.

I'd prefer they not exist in GW:2, though I'm certain they will.

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

The best thing is to look at these things with an exaggerated view otherwise it's hard to tell if something is cheating. I think if one is to be truly honest, it is some what cheating (or else it wouldn't be used). Though also, if I'm honest I don't really care too much.

I hope I haven't implied I actually care too much if someone cheats. That is why (up until now) I tried to keep personal views out of it. I find arguing is best when you don't get so personal.

Quote:
Who me?

/whistles innocently.

Nah, tbh I only just thought of that, and it is quite a big issue really as favour affects every single player in the game, indirectly and directly. You could potentially argue that it even affects the economy as if this mod is really creating LGMCs all over the place then if it was taken away it could reduce access to FoW and the Underworld, prices of ectos etc.

Them's big worms crawling out of that can. Or I may be full of it, can't really say as I've never been a hardcore farmer or trader.
Yes, get back in your can .

Mineria

Mineria

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

Denmark

Dragonslayers Of The [Mist]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karyuu
The title means something to me personally :] In every game I have played, and in all the previous guilds I have joined, I've been an "Explorer." Since GW has an explorer/cartographer title, I figure I should continue with my tradition.
Respect for that.
But did you think a bit about the HoM issue concerning it?
Quote:
Your own personalized Hall of Monuments to preserve your achievements, trophies, and titles across all Guild Wars games, allowing descendants to reap the benefits of your character's fame in Guild Wars 2
As you see titles mean a bit more then some text flashing under your characters name.
I think Anet can soon flush a lot of the titles, since not all got them equally.
Hope that mods will not be permitted for GW2, or that they think a bit more about how they implement title tracks, so you actually got to do the same for them from the very beginning to the very end.

nbajammer

nbajammer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

Iowa

Blade And Rose [BaR]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaile Gray
But I think the point is, the mod does change things, dramatically! I do not see the OP "belittling" someone. I see him expressing concern that suddenly those achievements that had one level of requirement are substantially easier to obtain. If someone wanders around trying to get that last .03%, that's entirely different than if someone can fire up the mod, jump to the map, and complete the final percentage in a matter of minutes.

Torqual, I understand your concerns, and this thread will be included in this week's community summary. I honestly don't expect that the game will be altered to revert the newly-changed parameters back to what they once were. But I will pass along how you feel about it, principally for future consideration.
Pray tell, Gaile, exactly what is changed by TexMod? It does not modify any in-game files, so how exactly is anyone other than the user incovenienced by this program? And if a person decides to inconvenience themselves, well they'd have only themselves to blame wouldn't they?

Furthermore, if the program actually was a cheat, then explain to me this. Why, then, is there an entire page devote to it, on the OFFICIAL Wiki, with comments from Emily stating that it is okay to use but not to contact support if it breaks our game because they will not support it? To anyone reading that page, it looks like it is in fact PERMITTED by Anet to use. The OP just wants a bigger e-peen for achieving something without aids that many people used. All of them should not be punished for using a permitted program to achieve a title that only affects them and not other users, and does not change the game client in any way, shape, or form. Nor the server, either. The page in question is here: http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Texmod

As others in the thread have stated, Anet has more important matters to focus on than one poster's QQ about worked harder for a title than others. Please do us all a favor and take that out of the summary. There's NO problem here, and we'd rather see time devoted to better and more useful things than this.

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

I play GW with a cinema screen, yo. Then when the enemy casts, it shows up as a huge bar and it is so huge I can react in a nano second to interrupt it... Oh also, I can see the fog over the map, without having to hack!

So... Don't cheat, get yourself a cinema screen.

Fried Tech

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2007

[Yeti]

E/

Torqual, shut up... if you think that them doing a map overlay is cheating then,, you using the internet to find glitches, or to compare maps is also cheating. you had help and so did they... they were just smart enough to do a photoshop overlay. stop being jealous.

And hello to all of my fellow Legendary Cartogrophers.

PS - I used photoshop after i reached 99.8%........ so i guess i cheated to. lol

Vilaptca

Vilaptca

Pre-Searing Vanquisher

Join Date: Jun 2005

Fifteen Over Fifty [Rare]

If this thread just starts to be more of page 12, then I'm just going to close this.

Karyuu

Karyuu

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2007

Kahlifownia

Roses of the Moonlight Sigil [RoMS]

W/Rt

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mineria
But did you think a bit about the HoM issue concerning it?
Did you think about skill capping info on the wiki making the Legendary title in that track easier to get? Why are there no arguments against that? Now instead of doing guess work, asking guildies, friends, making threads in the forum, you have a central place with all the info on where to go and what strategies to use.

nbajammer

nbajammer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

Iowa

Blade And Rose [BaR]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Saraphim
I do, in fact the 'Mapping Out' tool from this very forum is a joy to use. I can find out in seconds which characters need which elites, and the info is saved for me for future reference. I used to use an excel sheet to record elites before, Mapping Out is a godsend IMO.

Only have Canthan hunter so far, as I need more cash before I do the other two.
Shh Saraphim, we don't want Mapping Out to be erroneously called a cheat program!

To be truthful, both TexMod and Mapping Out are godsends, and since they run independently, they are both great assets to the community. This thread really is all about e-peen.

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

Quote:
PS - I used photoshop after i reached 99.8%........ so i guess i cheated to. lol
No worries, you don't want to know the percentages of players in other games that have cheated one point or another... By the way, I use crystal meth every PVP game so my reactions are uber!

Quote:
To be truthful, both TexMod and Mapping Out are godsends, and since they run independently, they are both great assets to the community. This thread really is all about e-peen.
Well I could not argue for so long if it was about normal 'peen'. There'd be no competition for me!

Big_Iron

Big_Iron

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Dec 2005

The Edge

Tormented Weapons [emo]

Quote:
Originally Posted by nbajammer
Pray tell, Gaile, exactly what is changed by TexMod? It does not modify any in-game files, so how exactly is anyone other than the user incovenienced by this program? And if a person decides to inconvenience themselves, well they'd have only themselves to blame wouldn't they?

Furthermore, if the program actually was a cheat, then explain to me this. Why, then, is there an entire page devote to it, on the OFFICIAL Wiki, with comments from Emily stating that it is okay to use but not to contact support if it breaks our game because they will not support it? To anyone reading that page, it looks like it is in fact PERMITTED by Anet to use. The OP just wants a bigger e-peen for achieving something without aids that many people used. All of them should not be punished for using a permitted program to achieve a title that only affects them and not other users, and does not change the game client in any way, shape, or form. Nor the server, either. The page in question is here: http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Texmod

As others in the thread have stated, Anet has more important matters to focus on than one poster's QQ about worked harder for a title than others. Please do us all a favor and take that out of the summary. There's NO problem here, and we'd rather see time devoted to better and more useful things than this.
QFT...

Nuff said in this post. Please close.

nbajammer

nbajammer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

Iowa

Blade And Rose [BaR]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
When you read pages of ignorant people saying "QQ more" to your long and thought out post, it kind of makes you lose interest in continuing to post constructively yourself. I accept my error.

The discussion has most definitely run its course.
Your post is long, but not well thought out. And calling everyone ignorant who knows better, has actually used the program and knows what it does, makes you to be the sore loser here. Because of that, we know who is the one actually doing the QQ.

Torqual

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2006

W/Mo

My whole point was that use of the mod is widespread - check the OP.

Three types of people have posted in here:

1) Those who did the title without modifying their game client, who are also disappointed that it's been cheapened and can be achieved with 5% of the original effort needed when it was implemented into the game.

2) Those who used the mod to get their own title and take offence to me saying they got it on the cheap. Plenty of these. They are as offended by my comments as I am by their use of it to steal the title.

3) People that have little interest in the subject or knowledge about it who make a habit of entering random threads and trying to look cool by making throw away comments and putting people down.

I am quite sure that this discussion has drawn the attention to use of the mod and may even increase usage. But come on, there's a link to it on the official GW Wiki! It's well known and as I said in my OP, LGMC is the third-most maxed title you see popping up in Kamadan ... and it's evident why.

Can I also clarify that this is not an attack on the modding community. I have enjoyed some great mods in many games: RTW, CS: Source, even Kick Off 2 (bet no-one here knows what that is).

This is a very, very smart mod, a really fine piece of programming. And I would suggest that use of this mod to put someone on 99.7% out of their misery is quite a reasonable and understandable thing. I am not a grind Nazi. But using the mod to take yourself from 60% to 100% in half a day ... I'd call that ABUSE of the mod. When does a mod cross the line from time-saving to being performance-boosting? Should we give Legendary titles to people that do this? And is such use what the mod-writer intended?

zwei2stein

zwei2stein

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Jun 2006

Europe

The German Order [GER]

N/

Now, the reall concern is indeed Gaile "looking into it".

I think its safe to say that if results are unfavorable for modding community, OP is going to face some massive abuse. BTW, do we have his IGN?

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

Would you even need the mod for 60%. I mean so much of the map is blanked from the foggy stuff ;o. Then again, no telling with some .

Torqual

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2006

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vilaptca
If this thread just starts to be more of page 12, then I'm just going to close this.
I never cease to be amazed how full of hate GWGuru is. So many people on here would never act like this in real life; they'd get their faces filled in within 10 seconds.

Torqual

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2006

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by zwei2stein
Now, the reall concern is indeed Gaile "looking into it".

I think its safe to say that if results are unfavorable for modding community, OP is going to face some massive abuse. BTW, do we have his IGN?
What the hell?

Who do YOU think YOU are? What you gonna do? Hack my PC?

See my comment above.... it's not an attack on the modding community. However maybe you should attract the attention of the moderators for the threatening overtones here?

Karyuu

Karyuu

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2007

Kahlifownia

Roses of the Moonlight Sigil [RoMS]

W/Rt

Torqual, there also have been many "traditionalists" posting that have never used the mod, but also stated they don't care about others using it.

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

Quote:
I never cease to be amazed how full of hate GWGuru is. So many people on here would never act like this in real life; they'd get their faces filled in within 10 seconds.
I'm more confident in real life than online. Seriously.
Quote:
Torqual, there also have been many "traditionalists" posting that have never used the mod, but also stated they don't care about others using it.
It effects favour, and people get excited when they get the title!

Maybe I'm an animal lover?

Skuld

Skuld

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Sep 2005

Thousend Tigers Apund Ur Head [Ttgr]

A/

Quote:
Originally Posted by zwei2stein
Now, the reall concern is indeed Gaile "looking into it".

I think its safe to say that if results are unfavorable for modding community, OP is going to face some massive abuse. BTW, do we have his IGN?
What are the options?

> ANet installs spyware to detect texmod, bans accounts: (this aint gonna happen, im sure) lawsuits
> ANet makes their game incompatible with texmod (complete rewrite of architechture, not likely) people carry on using photoshop, not a massive difference
> ANet changes the cartographer title mechanics (kill all monsters in NM?), not gonna happen, too much effort for no return
Any more?

I think we can safely say that nothing is going to happen.

Fril Estelin

Fril Estelin

So Serious...

Join Date: Jan 2007

London

Nerfs Are [WHAK]

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
When does a mod cross the line from time-saving to being performance-boosting? Should we give Legendary titles to people that do this? And is such use what the mod-writer intended?
How do you think that this can be technically done? As I said before, GW and modding are two different applications, and Anet can NOT go the path of spyware to try to detect and prevent a mod (they can make the life of the modders more difficult, but surely not impossible)

So how do you prevent this from happening?

Leighwyn

Leighwyn

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2005

Seattle

Limbo

Mo/E

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
My whole point was that use of the mod is widespread - check the OP.

Three types of people have posted in here:

1) Those who did the title without modifying their game client, who are also disappointed that it's been cheapened and can be achieved with 5% of the original effort needed when it was implemented into the game.

2) Those who used the mod to get their own title and take offence to me saying they got it on the cheap. Plenty of these. They are as offended by my comments as I am by their use of it to steal the title.

3) People that have little interest in the subject or knowledge about it who make a habit of entering random threads and trying to look cool by making throw away comments and putting people down.
4) Those who did the title without modifying their game client but compared to other 100% maps manually or through the assistance of a 3rd party

5) People that have both interest and vast knowledge about the subject who provide compelling counterarguments against the OP argument.

etc.

lists are only as complete as the list maker's intentions.

nbajammer

nbajammer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

Iowa

Blade And Rose [BaR]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
My whole point was that use of the mod is widespread - check the OP.

Three types of people have posted in here:

1) Those who did the title without modifying their game client, who are also disappointed that it's been cheapened and can be achieved with 5% of the original effort needed when it was implemented into the game.
How, exactly, is it cheapened? If I load TexMod, it shows me where to go and yet I still need to go there, scrape the wall, and hope that I'm on the RIGHT wall (since some places are on the line between zones). Since I'm still doing the same work you are, it is NOT cheapened.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
2) Those who used the mod to get their own title and take offence to me saying they got it on the cheap. Plenty of these. They are as offended by my comments as I am by their use of it to steal the title.
You're offended because you put more work into it than they did, despite their method also being permitted and not directly affecting your ability to play. That is QQ. The only person they cheated, if anyone, is themselves. And if they cheat themselves, it is by their own choice.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
3) People that have little interest in the subject or knowledge about it who make a habit of entering random threads and trying to look cool by making throw away comments and putting people down.
Which is what you've done this entire thread, accusing everyone who didnt get LGMC your way of being cheaters, liars, and the sort. Like Saraphim said earlier there may have been a topic of discussion here, but your accusations derailed any hope of that.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
I am quite sure that this discussion has drawn the attention to use of the mod and may even increase usage. But come on, there's a link to it on the official GW Wiki! It's well known and as I said in my OP, LGMC is the third-most maxed title you see popping up in Kamadan ... and it's evident why.
And do you honestly think that the mod makes it all that much easier? So the player knows where to go. Big deal. It doesn't defog for them. Learn what it does before you attack it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
Can I also clarify that this is not an attack on the modding community. I have enjoyed some great mods in many games: RTW, CS: Source, even Kick Off 2 (bet no-one here knows what that is).
Beggars can't be choosers. Deal with the fact that it isn't cheating, or attack all mods everywhere. To enjoy mods in one game but another is being a hypocrit (sic?).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
This is a very, very smart mod, a really fine piece of programming. And I would suggest that use of this mod to put someone on 99.7% out of their misery is quite a reasonable and understandable thing. I am not a grind Nazi. But using the mod to take yourself from 60% to 100% in half a day ... I'd call that ABUSE of the mod. When does a mod cross the line from time-saving to being performance-boosting? Should we give Legendary titles to people that do this? And is such use what the mod-writer intended?
So you finally admit that the mod is a great thing. But who are you to tell me (or anyone else here) how to play their game? They abide by Anet's rules, they don't get banned. Anet has an entire page on the wiki devoted to this program and clearly state their opinion of it. Given that, you have no business telling anyone they are a cheat or a liar or anything of the sort because of their use (or lack thereof) of this mod. If they go from 60% to 100% in half a day, kudos to them! If they do it with TexMod, still kudos to them! Doubly so if in Tyria or Elona where the map is bigger. But that's not ABUSING the mod. The mod is doing exactly what it was designed to do, and if a player chooses to play that way it isnt your right to tell them not to do so.

Please, for the sake of the community accept that you are wrong and get over it.

elektra_lucia

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2006

England

Leteci is [sexy]

Mo/

Quote:
What are the options?

> ANet installs spyware to detect texmod, bans accounts: (this aint gonna happen, im sure) lawsuits
> ANet makes their game incompatible with texmod (complete rewrite of architechture, not likely) people carry on using photoshop, not a massive difference
> ANet changes the cartographer title mechanics (kill all monsters in NM?), not gonna happen, too much effort for no return
Any more?

I think we can safely say that nothing is going to happen.
Therefore the reason that an 'official wiki' page says the program is some what allowed? Although, I have never used texmod. What exactly is it, dll files or what? It's easy to ban dll files.

Savio

Savio

Teenager with attitude

Join Date: Jul 2005

Fifteen Over Fifty [Rare]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Torqual
1) Those who did the title without modifying their game client, who don't care if others use a mod.
Fixed.

One point I'd like to bring up: for Cartography guides/mods to be useful, "traditional" GMCs had to contribute to them. Now why would those GMCs object to people using the guides or mods?

nbajammer

nbajammer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2005

Iowa

Blade And Rose [BaR]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by elektra_lucia
Therefore the reason that an 'official wiki' page says the program is some what allowed? Although, I have never used texmod. What exactly is it, dll files or what? It's easy to ban dll files.
Nothing more than an executable and a text file. You load .tpf files into the Executable and then tell it which .exe to load (in GW's case, Gw.exe).