Make all grind-based titles account based.

Phoenix Tears

Phoenix Tears

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Feb 2007

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
So tell me, what would happen if they made LB, SS, Norn, Asura, Vanguard and Drawf titles account based?

Thats right.. you get 6 instantly maxed titles on all your characters from creation! The minute you create one, they are a KOABD right from the start.

You are inherantly making KOABD account based, but making more and more pve titles account based! A title they dont deserve because that character hasnt even set foot outside of a town or outpost or even killed anything.
I can sign this only ever and ever again, people stop beign so god damn selfish >.>
Why do people think ever, only because something should be account wide, what a player has made first with his/her main character is less worth, when being account wide on all characters of the account ...

I've get now x free titles too all my characters of my account, because I'm with my main character KOABD, then this doesn't change anything, that the player behind the account is worth this title for his ACCOUNT...with which character he showsa now this title, is somewhat of total regardless, the player made the title once and will be also worthy to show the title.
If i as worthy player of KOABD show this title now to others with my character A, B or X is and will be ever absolute irrelevant. important is ONLY the FACT, that the player behind the Account made the title at least once and that should make the player worthy to show the title for his Account, regardless with which character I want to do this ...

Stop doing to act like, as if each character of an account would be like an own personality....-.- Important is only the Account, not the x thousand characters on it .... theres only 1 personality, and thats the player and keeper of the Account and no one else.


Titles should be a long term motivation YES!!, but no senseless stupid grind ,where you have to do everything senseless with every of your characters again and again,, when you still have done all the stuff once with your main character ...

Playing the Game with more then 1 character should be FUN, not the biggest grindfest for titles, on the whole MMO history .... and Fun means to me, that I've to do the important things only once with my main character for the whole account.
Therefore counts also the whole Hall of Monuments issue .... it makes no sense to complete them x times with all of your characters, when an account wide HoM would make 1000 times more sense for the gameplay of GW

pumpkin pie

pumpkin pie

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2006

behind you

bumble bee

E/

The thing is, say a player is extremely experience at playing a monk, and by playing that monk profession/character said player has achieve a lot of chest open, earn lots of gold, experience lots of stuffs, that does not automatically means said player is also going to be good at playing warrior, ranger, elementalist, mesmer, ritualist, dervish, paragon, assassin or necromancer. said player achieve all those from playing a monk, that does not mean said player can do the same thing with any other character of other profession as good as said player can play a monk.

if you want to show off your KOABD , do it with the character that has earn it and not on any other character that has not earn it.

all profession has different type of skills, build, and way of playing them just because a player is skill at playing one type of profession does not automatically qualify them to flash their KOABD on all type of profession/characters.

freekedoutfish

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2006

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackSephir
Wow, lvl 1 character has KoaBD and... and what? Big, fat nothing. Just shows that some player managed to max soe titles on other characters.
"Omg, look mommy, that ele is lvl 1 ad he's already glad 3, do something!"

I'm going to ask again so you'll understand it fish- some guy has KoaBD on his lvl 1 char- so what?
thats point! KOABD means something now to thee individual. Allow any character to show it and it meaans nothing!

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Thats exactly why this is only for grind titles pumpkin. Those titles dont show any skill with a proffesion.
How is being drunk more challenging on a monk than a ranger?
How is jumping into a wurm for LB/SS different for an ele than a necro?

Thats the point of this change, skill less grind doesnt need to be repeated on every char because by getting it on one you have already done exactly what you will do on any other char.

Something like protector or cart does change depending on what proffesion you are playing.

*edit*

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
thats point! KOABD means something now to thee individual. Allow any character to show it and it meaans nothing!
How is it any character? Only those who have achieved the required number of titles can show it.
Its the same person behind all the chars, it doesnt matter they are on their monk instead of their ranger. They still completed the titles.

If it makes no sense for titles then what about storage? It doesnt make sense your lvl1 can have 1,000s of gold, or a perfect weapon etc.

The point is its the person playing who plays and it should be the person playing that titles are tied to simply because its they who have achieved it.

pumpkin pie

pumpkin pie

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2006

behind you

bumble bee

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Thats exactly why this is only for grind titles pumpkin. Those titles dont show any skill with a proffesion.
How is being drunk more challenging on a monk than a ranger?
the thing is players want to achieve everything NOW, thats why they grind, to me none of the title listed in the OP are grind if you honestly enjoy and play the game. you will get it sooner or later without having to grind, instead by enjoying and playing the game. if it means nothing and has no effect why are there so many player grinding to get it? you will get it when you get it by enjoying/playing the game.

Yes, there is a different, playing a ranger to get all the alcohol consumable, and playing a monk to get all the alcohol consumable are totally different experience. The problem is most players are only comfortable with playing one single profession for farming and depends a lot on that character to get everything, and give it to the rest of the character. and by doing that its repetitive, thus becomes a grind. if you do things the way it was meant to be done you have totally different experiences and its not a grind at all.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
How is jumping into a wurm for LB/SS different for an ele than a necro?
As I remember I did not get sunspears and lightbringers point by jumping into wurms alone. Jumping into wurms comes much much later if I remember the game correctly. If you choose only to jump into wurms to get the lightbringers and sunspears points, thats your problem, you choose it, there are so many other aspect of the game that you can play and enjoy to get the titles.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Thats the point of this change, skill less grind doesnt need to be repeated on every char because by getting it on one you have already done exactly what you will do on any other char.
Simple, if you don't feel like repeating don't get the title. and its not exactly the same as what your other character does, if you are only going to use just that one single character to farm everything then maybe, but all my character earn all their title themselves, whichever character gets a gold, that character will identify it and not another character.

Like I said before, if you are the one who choose to grind then, please don't whine. Play the game and enjoy it.

BlackSephir

BlackSephir

Forge Runner

Join Date: Nov 2006

A/N

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
thats point! KOABD means something now to thee individual. Allow any character to show it and it meaans nothing!
Quote:
KOABD means something
Quote:
something
Yeah? What is that "something"? What's so awesome about KoaBD?

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Thats kind of the point of this change, we dont want to have to grind them.

Yes you can get the titles over time, thats nice. But then you have to go and do it again if you want it on another, and then again if you want it on another, and the again if you want it on another, and then again if you want it on another...

The point is, I am the one who did it. My char didnt go and do it all by himself, I did it. Yet I have to do it again for my others?


By your argument should be stop people passing items between chars? Because thats was aquired by char x and not char y right?

The player got that drop. The player plays the game. The player achieves the titles.



As for none of the titles being grind. You dont think drunkard or sweet tooth are gind? Thats all they are. There is 0 skill involved.

Most of the others still require specific enemies to be killed over and over. It doesnt matter if you do it over a day or 2 years, its still grind.

pumpkin pie

pumpkin pie

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2006

behind you

bumble bee

E/

don't you need to like go out of town kill something to get gold to buy alcohol to drink to get the drunken title? ale and rice wine do not drop from the sky last i check.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

And that means it all has to be done by the same char? Or that going out and farming or grinding for gold makes it any less of a grind?

pumpkin pie

pumpkin pie

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2006

behind you

bumble bee

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by pumpkin pie
Like I said before, if you are the one who choose to grind then, please don't whine. Play the game and enjoy it.
to me, none of the title is a grind, if you don't think they are worth repeating to get why get them. stick to one character.

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Thats kind of the point of this change, we dont want to have to grind them.
But I think THAT is the point and always has been. PvP titles are cross-account and PvE titles not, generally speaking. Want to amass a collection of titles on a particular character? Need to do them on that character. Its not really intended for anyone to gain very high ranks of KoaBD on multiple characters, but the option is of course there. PvE titles have acceptable functionality at the levels you get them simply by playing a character. A desire to max them on multiple characters is indeed work and ought to be.

I retired once, permanently I thought, specifically due to titles not being cross-account, so I have sympathy. I've since come back and decided my monk is the only one to amass titles in one location and have any progress on KoaBD. Other characters simply see play as I desire, may aim for one maxed PvE title or two if appropriate. Having come back with that outlook has changed how I feel about the subject.

I do think the Treasure Hunter track should be cross-account, as well as Wisdom. I do agree with that. Not so SS/LB and the Reputation PvE tracks. They should remain character-specific, as should Cartographer, Guardian, Vanquisher obviously. Drunkard and Sweet Tooth do make more sense being character-specific but one could make a case either way. Its far, far too late for Anet to make any tweaks to what is global and what is not now anyway though. Realize of course we're now simply debating something in a rhetorical manner. Its not going to be changed.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

While it is perhaps late in the day to be making such changes GW still has plenty of time left in it. GW2 is still a way off, after that GW will continue to run. Changes, especially smaller ones such as this, would still serve a purpose if they help to keep people active and interested in GW.

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
While it is perhaps late in the day to be making such changes GW still has plenty of time left in it. GW2 is still a way off, after that GW will continue to run. Changes, especially smaller ones such as this, would still serve a purpose if they help to keep people active and interested in GW.
Its not too late to make a change due to GW life. Not what I meant. GW runs as long as GW2 does, since the two are linked via the HoM and the ability to go back and unlock something for a given character in GW2, if one desires.

Its too late for Anet to make changes to what is global and what isnt due to players investing the time to develop the non cross-account titles on multiple characters that they wished to have. A lot of time, depending on what specifically. They simply wont go there, so to speak.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Well they wouldnt loose that time. As it wouldnt remove the titles from them.

All it would do is let those who have achieved it on at least one char get it for all.

The only problem would be the people who think because they did it everyone else should have to. Is that enough reason not to? I dont think so.

I had to complete proph with only proph skills, everyone else should have to.
I never had a car I had to walk 20 miles to work, everyone else should have to.
I never had a nice thermal jacket when I went to the north pole, no one else should have one.


Things change. I could understand if it removed titles from people. But it doesnt.

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Well they wouldnt loose that time. As it wouldnt remove the titles from them.
They wouldnt have invested significant time over a year or more now in many cases to develop certain titles on multiple characters. A change right near the coming forth of a new title makes some sense sure, but after all this time it does not.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
All it would do is let those who have achieved it on at least one char get it for all.
Too easy for many titles, not relevant for most others: Protector/Guardian on a monk is not Protector/Guardian on another profession. Cartographer on one character as the map is unfogged makes sense; Cartographer on another character with the map still fogged does not. Asura rank for completing the game and developing the title makes sense; Asura rank for not yet having started EotN does not. Etc.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
The only problem would be the people who think because they did it everyone else should have to. Is that enough reason not to? I dont think so.
It is. That is the point of character-specific titles. That and many of the non-PvP titles make no sense being cross-account (see above).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
I had to complete proph with only proph skills, everyone else should have to.
I never had a car I had to walk 20 miles to work, everyone else should have to.
I never had a nice thermal jacket when I went to the north pole, no one else should have one.
Having multiple chapters leads to more options on the way to play the game. This was always the game model and an additional reason to own more than one chapter.

Bill Gates made his money on his efforts, but I had no such luck. I'm not rich so we should change the system? You dont NEED all that money, but I agree with you it would be nice to have. Your car and jacket examples are statements of the same sort and dont really have any more relevance than mine.

I am not someone who pursues titles on multiple characters to any degree. Cant see any changes outside of perhaps Wisdom or Treasure Hunter as being either logical or fair. We can agree to disagree. I'd be shocked beyond anything I have seen in GW if they in fact tweaked anything beyond those two titles, stunned into disbelief really. Doubt enough they'd even tweak Treasure Hunter or Wisdom.

freekedoutfish

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2006

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
How is it any character? Only those who have achieved the required number of titles can show it.
Its the same person behind all the chars, it doesnt matter they are on their monk instead of their ranger. They still completed the titles.

If it makes no sense for titles then what about storage? It doesnt make sense your lvl1 can have 1,000s of gold, or a perfect weapon etc.

The point is its the person playing who plays and it should be the person playing that titles are tied to simply because its they who have achieved it.
You could be a really great warrior and deserve KOABD and be a rubbish monk and not. Its missleading to snow KOABD on a character who hasnt earned it because it suggests they have skill and/or experience with that profession.

Also dont use the pvp arguement of "they make pvp title account based and lvl1s can show such and such", because thats pvp and not pve. We're debating pve titles here, not pvp. Their completely different things.

PvE is individual to the character.

PvP is individual to the player.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aera Lure
Too easy for many titles, not relevant for most others: Protector/Guardian on a monk is not Protector/Guardian on another profession. Cartographer on one character as the map is unfogged makes sense; Cartographer on another character with the map still fogged does not. Asura rank for completing the game and developing the title makes sense; Asura rank for not yet having started EotN does not. Etc.
Not all those titles would be changed. Protector and guardian for example wouldnt. Because they require skill to go and complete, and it changes for each char. Cartographer another that would remain per char.

Asura would change. Simply because its not a title that takes skill to get. It takes time or grind.

For example with protector you couldnt make it halfway through and then fail twice and still get it.

With the grind titles, with enough time no matter how bad you are you will get them. Even if you can only get 50 points before you die. Eventually you will get them.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Aera Lure
They wouldnt have invested significant time over a year or more now in many cases to develop certain titles on multiple characters. A change right near the coming forth of a new title makes some sense sure, but after all this time it does not.
No they wouldnt have spent that time, but it wasnt in then.
It goes back to the whole "I never had a car thing". So they dont loose that time, simply because they didnt have the option then. If this change removed titles then yes it would be a waste. But they still have exactly the same titles (possibly even more). While they spent more time getting them they still have them.


As for people playing multiple char that want to spend the time getting titles on them all. They can still do what is required. If they want to spend a few weeks killing the same thing over and over, nothing is stopping them. Or if they want a whole 10,000 mins standing around clicking an icon everynow and then, that option still remains open to them.

But those who dont yet have still invested time and achieved any of the titles can show that they have achieved them even when they are on a different char.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
You could be a really great warrior and deserve KOABD and be a rubbish monk and not. Its missleading to snow KOABD on a character who hasnt earned it because it suggests they have skill and/or experience with that profession.

Thats why only the grind titles and not any skill based ones would be subject to change.

Does having Incorrigible Ale-Hound show they really know how to play monk?
Does having Source of Wisdom show the necro knows what he is doing?
Does having Legendary Delver prove the warrior can play well?

At the end of the day KOABD doesnt show skill either, nor does the lack of it make we wonder if the player knows what they are doing. It can easily be made up of purely the grind titles.


*edit*

Sorry about that meant to edit my above post.

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Asura would change. Simply because its not a title that takes skill to get. It takes time or grind.

With the grind titles, with enough time no matter how bad you are you will get them. Even if you can only get 50 points before you die. Eventually you will get them.
For PvE-skill-related titles only, want them maxed on multiple characters, you need to put in the work. You get them simply by finishing the the given campaign at a level high enough to be reasonably effective.

Reputation titles fall out around Asura 4, Norn 4, Dwarf 3, Vanguard 3, give or take a little bit, just by completing the campaign. You then have a book to apply to the track of your choice to get level 5. Two more books if you want to get any to level 8, each book taking 3-4 hours. You cannot possibly be trying to say that either level 5 in a given PvE skill title track yields a dysfunctional skill or that 8 hours is in anyway much effort to get a reasonably high ranked skill? Its a very similar story for LB/SS in Nightfall.

That's good enough, UNLESS you are trying to max them all for the purposes of KoaBD, in which case 6 of them for free (SS/LB inclusive) for all characters on create once you complete them once on any character is outright silly. A lazy request even. I can see some complaints about Treasure Hunter and Wisdom, but come on. You are simply asking for six free maxed titles.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
No they wouldnt have spent that time, but it wasnt in then.
It goes back to the whole "I never had a car thing". So they dont loose that time, simply because they didnt have the option then. If this change removed titles then yes it would be a waste. But they still have exactly the same titles (possibly even more). While they spent more time getting them they still have them.
You are again simply asking for six nearly free maxed titles. Simply wont happen. I cant believe anyone could even find an argument for supporting the idea.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

But they arent free maxed titles. I had to work for them. Thats the key point here.

It was me controlling my char, it was me putting in the time. Yet the reward is tied to the char.


As for it being a fairly short time to get them its really not. Even after finishing the game (doing all the side quests like I did) my highest was R6 (with 2 books handed in after the change to higher rewards). The others are R3-5.

To get just 1 maxed would take a good 5-10 hours. 30-60 hours for them all on 1 char. 150-300 to get them maxed on 5 chars (A lot of people will have more). Also 5-10 is low just to avoid any arguments over that time taken, according to the wiki you can get about 3k an hour in Dalada Uplands making Ebon a good 30+ hours.

Now I dont know about you, but that doesnt seem quick to me.


Now perhaps if the titles required some extremely hard quest or something challenging and fun I wouldnt mind putting that time in. But it isnt. Its 150-300 hours of pure grind. Have I not already proved im able to achieve them when its done on 1 char?


So no, im not asking for a free title. Im asking to be able to display something that ive achieved.

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Epic laziness to get 6 maxed titles on all characters, all of the PvE-skill related tracks, just for completing them once on any character.

The only reason to want this is for easy KoaBD tracking, since as I pointed out, the skills come to any character that plays the campaign at a level where they are fully usable. They are then easy to get to level 8 with all but a little bit of time on any character for any track you want to use for that character, but not to max on all characters. This is what I mean by six "free" maxed titles. Obviously you have to max them once somewhere, but then you get them everywhere? I dont think so.

This topic fails completely if this is all some 25 pages of discussion has been about. I thought by "grind" people meant any and all of the PvE titles, as one definition of grind is not necessarily negative, but simply anything you do in some repeated fashion, whereby all games have grind of some sort, they just differ in the manner. There is legitimate complaint about Treasure Hunter and Wisdom not being account-wide, but really now...

If you want to max these on all characters across your account, go for it. It is going to be work as you point out, and should be. All characters are perfectly playable with ranks of 5 and any one character can easily get the preferred one or two tracks to level 8 that they want to use, and use the skills for the track effectively.

Its almost laughable, but really, feel free to continue petitioning Anet for it.

freekedoutfish

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2006

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Thats why only the grind titles and not any skill based ones would be subject to change.

Does having Incorrigible Ale-Hound show they really know how to play monk?
Does having Source of Wisdom show the necro knows what he is doing?
Does having Legendary Delver prove the warrior can play well?

At the end of the day KOABD doesnt show skill either, nor does the lack of it make we wonder if the player knows what they are doing. It can easily be made up of purely the grind titles.


*edit*

Sorry about that meant to edit my above post.
1) Who are you to argue whether a title requires skill or time to complete?

2) Reagardless of that, once you maxed out 5 of those account based titles, you are giving a character KOABD who doesnt deserve it. Even less so if those 5 maxed titles (as you put it) only require time to complete and NOT skill.

So you end up with a lvl1 with KOABD which was accomplished by doing nothing but maxing non-skill related titles?

How doesnt that belittle KOABD?

The entire thread is pointless because we have huge varied opinions about

1) what grind is.
2) whether a title shows skill or time.
3) which titles fall under grind.

you could only make the /signed people happy by making all titles account based and you can only keep the /not signed people happy by leaving it as it is.

You cant please both sides!

This entire thread has gone on too long, because no one can decide or define what titles are or aarent grind. A title you call grind I may not. A title I call grnd you may not. A title I say requires skill you say requires just time. A title I say requires just time, you say requires skill.

Its a point debate because it will never get resolved!

But what can be said to be fact, is that if you make all the OP'ers titles account based, it will have knock on events elsewhere. Such as the KOABD title. But there are people in here who dont care about that, aslong as they get what they want.

Thats another reason this thread should just end, because there ARE knock on effects to making all the listed titles account based. But people dont want to listen or accept those effects, because it goes against what they want.

If people are unwilling to accept these changes will effect other aspects and respect those effects, then you cant expect people to sign this idea!

I dont want KOABD effected because I feel it carries prestige and that prestige should remain individual and not account based because its pve and not pvp. But you dont agree because it gets in the way of your wants.

If making these changes had absolutely no knock on effects and didnt turn other aspects of the game on their head, then I would sign it. But it does!

1) KOABD!

It removes the prestige!

2) Having players start NF and GWEN with an instant +damage and + protection against certain creatures.

How can a low level player in NF, when they have never been there, have added damage against abaddons creatures from the start? How can a player entering GWEN without having ever been there, have added damage against destroyers, extra energy or extra damage against the char from the start?

3) The unfair advantage on new players who enter those same campaigns without those advantages.

New players wont have that instant damage and protection or energy. It creates an unfair advantage that makes its unbalanced. You will find people cant enter teams unless they have maxed titles and new players will be alienated.

4) Players being able to aquire pve only skills and have them be instantly maxed out.

Again, how can a player who has never set foot in NF before or GWEN be allowed to aquire a pve only skill from those campaigns and have them be instantly maxed?

It makes their gameplay far easier when your talking about alkar's acid and alike. Why should they have that instant advantage over new players? How does that individual character deserve that when they have only just enter GWEN?

5) It makes no sense for the storylines!

Those playes have only just entered NF or GWEN, so how can they have maxed status effects or pve only skills? It makes no sense! It turns the entire storyline on its head, if you can completely bypass it and have stuff maxed from the instance you begin.

Your meant to earn this stuff, otherwise why play?



But yourself and others dont want to hear that, you dont care about the impacts on anything aslong as you get what you want. If those impacts didnt exist I would sign this. But they do.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
1) Who are you to argue whether a title requires skill or time to complete?
Because we can define skill and time?

Something like protector can only be achieved by doing it in one go. If you mess up you have to start again.

Something like drunkard you cant fail. As long as you have enough time and funds you cant possibly not achieve it.

Something like the rep titles can be achived with no skill given enough time. Even if you can only get 50 points an hour, given enough time you would get it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
2) Reagardless of that, once you maxed out 5 of those account based titles, you are giving a character KOABD who doesnt deserve it. Even less so if those 5 maxed titles (as you put it) only require time to complete and NOT skill.

So you end up with a lvl1 with KOABD which was accomplished by doing nothing but maxing non-skill related titles?

How doesnt that belittle KOABD?
The point is its not the char who spent the time doing. The player behind the char is the one who achieved it. So if the player has achieved them on one char when he switched has he still achieved them? Of course they have. Why cant they show that?

Again why is a it a problem for a lvl1 to have KOABD? Its the PLAYER controlling the char who has been rewarded.

Again I ask you, do you think having storage and passing items and gold across is wrong? Because the char didnt achieve that did they?

Its the player who plays the game. The char left on its own wouldnt go off and start farming rep.

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
The entire thread is pointless because we have huge varied opinions about

1) what grind is.
2) whether a title shows skill or time.
3) which titles fall under grind.

you could only make the /signed people happy by making all titles account based and you can only keep the /not signed people happy by leaving it as it is.

You cant please both sides!
Actually its only being asked for certain titles to be changed. Those that can be achieved with no skill requirements. Yes they may take longer with no skill, but they are still possible to do. Anything that requires skill, and therefore would change from proffesion to proffesion should remain as is.

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
This entire thread has gone on too long, because no one can decide or define what titles are or aarent grind. A title you call grind I may not. A title I call grnd you may not. A title I say requires skill you say requires just time. A title I say requires just time, you say requires skill.

Its a point debate because it will never get resolved!

Based on that should we stop debating religion? Gravity?
Just because two sides dont agree doesnt mean its pointless.


As for it being "Epic laziness" I and many others obviousely dont think thats true. I feel the current system could be improved. I feel that because its me who achieved the title, its me who should be able to display that.


*Edit to include replies to freekedoutfish's edit*

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
I dont want KOABD effected because I feel it carries prestige and that prestige should remain individual.
And guess who is the individual who achieved it. Thats right it was the player not the char.

Going beyond that the title doesnt mean anything. As I said with all the titles that can be achieved through grind alone it shows nothing. Besides, what effect does more characters having KOABD have?

To get it you must have done as much work as anyone who got it on an individual char. Just because one player likes to play multiple chars and another sticks with one means the one who switched should be denied the title even though he did just as much as the player who sticks with one char?


Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
You will find people cant enter teams unless they have maxed titles and new players will be alienated.
7 heroes


But let me ask you this. If it means so much that a new player wont get into a team over it, why does having it at a low level not matter when its used in the argument against the change? According to you (Possibly not you but another poster) it doesnt make any skills unusable, you can still get by fine.

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
Your meant to earn this stuff, otherwise why play?
Guess what, I did earn it Just because I chose to max title x on char y and title b on char c etc, does that mean ive achieved less than someone who did it all on the same char? Havent I as the player had to do exactly the same as you?


Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
But yourself and others dont want to hear that, you dont care about the impacts on anything aslong as you get what you want. If those impacts didnt exist I would sign this. But they do.
Please dont try and make me out as some evil self centered person. The point of threads like this is so people can discuss the pros and cons. You have said why you think it would be a bad idea, just because I dont agree doesnt make mean I dont care about others.

I just dont agree with what you have said. I dont think a title losing value is a valid argument against, the ammount of people with it is constantly increasing, with so many grind titles and runners for some of the skill based ones does it show anything anyways?

I dont agree it will effect new players as you suggest because unless they are in some high end Guild that demands set builds no PuG, friend or guild is going to refuse to play with them. (Although perhaps PuGs would, your standard ones just doing the missions unlikely. But PuGs for farming, elite areas etc yes) But as a new player why are they there anyways?

Aera Lure

Aera Lure

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Aug 2005

In Baltar's head

Bring Out Your Dead [BOYD], former officer [LBS]

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
As for it being "Epic laziness" I and many others obviousely dont think thats true. I feel the current system could be improved. I feel that because its me who achieved the title, its me who should be able to display that.
Well, you and others that want six max titles account-wide easily, yes. I can see where there would be more that would want this than less. Certainly. I think its simply asking a lot to be able to max the six on a character and suddenly have KoaBD 1 on all of your account characters. It would really necessitate a change to the KoaBD track.

freekedoutfish

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2006

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Again I ask you, do you think having storage and passing items and gold across is wrong? Because the char didnt achieve that did they?

Its the player who plays the game. The char left on its own wouldnt go off and start farming rep.
Passing items between chars is trade and commerce!

Making titles account based and allowing people to use the status effects and/or have maxed pve only skills, they havent earnt is a far different thing.

It just doesnt make sense in terms of the storyline why a player has a maxed LB, SS or GWEN title when they have barely set foot into that land!

Why can you and others not understand the principle of pve being an individual experience for the character you play! It cant be account wide because that makes no sense. Why plan an MMO if you want everything your character achieves to be available to all your chars?

Why keep playing! That just removes a huge amount of replayability.

Should we make certan missions account based because they dont require skill and are easy and just take time to do?

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
Why keep playing! That just removes a huge amount of replayability.
Because titles arent everything?

As long as im having fun I will continue to play.

Now this change would make it more fun for me, because I dont want to play with just 1 char, I want to be able to play different proffesions. But I also want to get a title should I want to. Not because I care what someone else thinks about me when I display it, but because its something I would like to achieve.

And again how does it cheapen KOABD? No one who hasnt achieved the requirements can get it.


Quote:
Originally Posted by freekedoutfish
Why can you and others not understand the principle of pve being an individual experience for the character you play! It cant be account wide because that makes no sense. Why plan an MMO if you want everything your character achieves to be available to all your chars?
pve is an experience for me. Im fairly sure my char doesnt have much to say about it. If people want to rp it as a char going through the game they can. They can not turn of titles if they dont want the bounus until they think they deserve it. But not everyone roleplays their char.

When I play its me controlling a char. Its fun and I enjoy it.

As for the MMO comment, GW isnt an MMO. Also who says thats the only reason you can play it for? Im not playing for gear or fame. Im playing for fun.

If there is a way that can make the game more fun thats great. Grinding to me isnt fun. Yet having titles ive already achieved on other chars, and therefore the advantages of them, would make the game more fun for me.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Aera Lure
Well, you and others that want six max titles account-wide easily
No not at all. I can obviousely only speak for myself here but I highly doubt thats the intention of the majority either. I feel the current system punishes people who play multiple chars. It stops anyone who does that from getting KOABD, even though they may have achieved exactly the same titles as someone else who does have KOABD.

Sleeper Service

Sleeper Service

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Dec 2005

CULT

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
(...)
No not at all. I can obviousely only speak for myself here but I highly doubt thats the intention of the majority either. I feel the current system punishes people who play multiple chars. It stops anyone who does that from getting KOABD, even though they may have achieved exactly the same titles as someone else who does have KOABD.
nope never has been my personal intention either, from what most people (all) favour that has never been the case as well.

it is about punishing people who play multiple chars and profiting as much as possible from the game. When I bought into GW there were NO titles, i played 8 separate chars regularly. And they all finished Chapters 1 and 2. When NF came out i bought an extra 2 slots....played through with my main and slamed against the grind for skills wall.

Result? now i play one toon. The prospect of mindlessly repeating SS/LB runs and farming those stupid EN zones over and over and over again just to get correct effects is just ridiculous.

people who enjoy(ed) playing multiple toons, different classes are now punished by the (pve) titles system and yet these same people have played as much net Time as anyone else.

Grind reflects time spent not skill correct?
Then let it reflect REAL time not some virtual toon time.

i couldn't care LESS about koabd track.

lyra_song

lyra_song

Hell's Protector

Join Date: Oct 2005

R/Mo

The next person who says anything along the lines of "the system punishes people who plays multiple chars" is gonna get kicked in the head by me.

Its seriously getting stale.

Playing 1 character heavily has advantages.
Playing many characters heavily has advantages.

The current system is FAIR.

All players have to do the same amount of grind per character. And the OP has already pointed out that the types of grind is very often the same type of action, non-dependant on class.

Players who have more characters have to do more grind but they have more characters with those titles.
Players who have less characters have to do less grind but have less characters with those titles.


Players with many characters have a huge amount of things available to them, in terms of builds, functionality, storage, etc.
Players with few characters are a lot more limited.

Nobody is punishing you for anything. STOP BRINGING IT UP.

How much time YOU HAVE has nothing to do with the game.

There is no punishment angle.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by lyra_song
Players who have more characters have to do more grind but they have more characters with those titles.
Players who have less characters have to do less grind but have less characters with those titles.


Players with many characters have a huge amount of things available to them, in terms of builds, functionality, storage, etc.
Players with few characters are a lot more limited.

Thats kind of the point. The current system requires either you have lots of time or play a single char. Changing it would simply allow everyone to have all the advantages without the disadvantages. Yet to achieve that you would still have to complete the title to begin with.

lyra_song

lyra_song

Hell's Protector

Join Date: Oct 2005

R/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth
Thats kind of the point. The current system requires either you have lots of time or play a single char. Changing it would simply allow everyone to have all the advantages without the disadvantages. Yet to achieve that you would still have to complete the title to begin with.
Yes, that IS the point. I didn't dispute that.

It's the reasoning that attempts to justify the point that is completely flawed when it uses the "its punishing the player" as its argument.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Punishing is never really the right word to use I agree. It isnt set out to punish. But because of how it works it favours or rewards one side more than the other.

I dont think for a second this is intentional or that Anet has some evil plan to turn everyone into a single char kind of player.

That doesnt however change the fact that it does favour those who play with fewer chars, as they can spend the same time and do the same things as someone who plays multiple chars yet still come out with something more.

All this is suggesting is it would be nice to have that changed. So that people who do use multiple chars get the same rewards.


So perhaps the argument should look more like "it favours one group of players and it would be nice to have it changed."

Its also something that would be a fairly small change, they already have titles, they already have account wide titles. Its not as if it requires a whole new system to be sorted out.

Navaros

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2005

Mo/Me

All grind-based titles should indeed be account-based.

However, that list also needs to include Legendary Skill Hunter, which is 100% grind.

Vanquisher is also grind and should also be account-based.

Should also include Survivor also as after level 1 of that, it too is mostly grind. Plus characters who were made before Survivor was introduced never had their fair opportunity to get it, which this would fix.

All tiers of KOABD should also be account-based.

Having to repeat any of the insane required grind time for the above titles across multiple characters, is outright ludicrous and should not be necessary. They should all be account-based for that reason.

To avoid getting caught up in semantics with some grind-based titles being excluded, might be better to make all titles that take a ludicrous amount of time be account-based. That's how it shoulda been since day 1. Should definitely be fixed to be that now.

You can't see me

You can't see me

Forge Runner

Join Date: Nov 2006

USA

P/W

I support this thread and it's ideas.


Not because I'm lazy, or want easy titles, but there's an element to the game that I'm getting sick of.

Repetitveness.


To make accomplishments on more than one character, you must retrace your steps.

Retracing your steps across 10 PvE characters across all campaigns is what I've done now. Let me tell you, it was hell. There are no new challenges to face. To go through a campaign, you must prove you can do the missions. On other characters, you must prove it AGAIN. And AGAIN. It's like hearing a very bad echo in a small cave. Campaigning is grinding. It takes little skill, and unescasarry time.

Do you see my point? The game is filled with repetiveness. I feel that making grind based titles, especially ones like drunkard, faction titles, wisdom, skill capturing, and treasure hunter account based would stop some of that repetiveness and maybe give people a chance to do something else.

bilateralrope

bilateralrope

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Nov 2005

New Zealand

Xen Of Onslaught (Xen of the Pacific division)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Snow Bunny
Most GW players are

a. selfish
b. whiny
c. lazy
d. generally impatient.

So....the poll shouldn't tell you much.
It tells us that most GW players that have responded would prefer the change, which is the only thing I wanted those numbers for.

Quote:
Again, /notsigned.
And here you go trying to skew the numbers in your favor.

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

*Edit*
To slow, this is aimed at Navaros.

I disagree with Legendary Skill Hunter as taking your char to each boss and capping is different when playing a monk instead of a warrior for example.

Vanquisher is most deffinately a skill title, and the experience is vastly different from proffesion to proffesion.

Survivor again I would keep the same, while it can be farmed it still requires a certain degree of skill. Although I completely agree with it being possible to do with older chars.

KOABD no because it would count skill based titles on other chars.

bilateralrope

bilateralrope

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Nov 2005

New Zealand

Xen Of Onslaught (Xen of the Pacific division)

Quote:
Originally Posted by lyra_song
Playing many characters heavily has advantages.
What advantages do they have to counter the large time investment required just to make them equal to the characters of players with only one character ?
Quote:
All players have to do the same amount of grind per character. And the OP has already pointed out that the types of grind is very often the same type of action, non-dependant on class.
Which is what makes it so boring.
Quote:
Players who have more characters have to do more grind but they have more characters with those titles.
And they have to spend more time doing the repetitive boring tasks just to get their character up to the same stats as someone who only plays that character.

Punishing might not be the right word. But it is certainly discouraging people from playing multiple characters.

Sleeper Service

Sleeper Service

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Dec 2005

CULT

sure feels punishing to ME, beg to differ.

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

[QUOTE]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Isileth

So no, im not asking for a free title. Im asking to be able to display something that ive achieved.
all right in that case i have an extremely fair compromise.

you can display any title you have earned on any character you choose which satisifies what you have stated many times is what you want......recognition of achievement of that title to show it off

to make it fair to the rest you will not have the bonuses that go with that title except on a character that earned those bonuses.

no instant account wide salvage/lockpick for example.

but since you want to display the title that hardcore farming bonus wont effect you if you dont have it on that character.......right?

BlackSephir

BlackSephir

Forge Runner

Join Date: Nov 2006

A/N

Yeah, because all Sunspear, LB, GW pve skills are used for farming.
Owait they aren't
Don't fail again loviatar

Isileth

Isileth

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/W

Well to start with I dont have any hardcore farming titles, I only have 2 maxed titles and both are skill based

Second that still doesnt solve the problem that to reach the bounuses takes longer with multiple chars than it does with just 1. Having both the title and the bounus means you only have to complete it the once so you can play lots of chars without the disadvantage of it.